Home :: About :: XML/RSS Feed
'
[an error occurred while processing this directive]
'
'
[an error occurred while processing this directive]

Celtic PLC shares are traded on the Alternative Investments Market (AIM). Celtic Quick News cannot be held responsible for any loss due to incorrect information found here.
All information is provided 'as-is', to you use it at your own risk. Always seek professional financial advice before making an investment decision.



Previous Articles


:: Wage management necessary for Celtic to flourish ::
:: Celtic interim accounts show player investment at ... ::
:: Celtic shares vacillate as Rangers withhold balanc... ::
:: Early treatment of Zurawski will destroy Celtic pl... ::
:: Dropping Nakamura to protect the defence will not ... ::
:: Dunfermline 1-8 Celtic ::
:: Dunfermline v Celtic Live Updates ::
:: Key weekend across Europe for Champions League see... ::
:: Press conference update - Keane will help overcome... ::
:: Petrov likely to drop out against Dunfermline ::


Celtic Links

Sixtee7 - cool Celtic t-shirts

Dateline: 25 May 1967
Dateline: 23 May 1967
Dateline: 19 October 1957
Jimmy Johnstone
Brian Quinn interview
Martin O'Neill era ends
More thoughts on O'Neill
State of the club report 2007
BBC: Celtic win European Cup
Celtic 2 Inter Milan 1, Guardian
The Copydesk


Common Questions

 >>How to add a comment on Celtic Quick News
 >>Stevie21's Link Creator
 >>Subscribe to Celtic Quick News podcast •






WebCQN


[an error occurred while processing this directive]

Celtic Quick News: quicknews Archives

Recently in quicknews Category

Thursday, May 1, 2008

Paris St Germain banned from next League Cup Paris St Germain have been banned from defending the League Cup next season after some of their fans unfolded an abusive banner during this season's League Cup final, the French League (LFP) said on Wednesday. (Guardian)

| | Comments (0)

McManus targets top team return McManus suffered a calf injury in last week's 3-2 victory over Rangers but is confident he can play in Celtic's final three league games. (BBC)
| | Comments (0)
[an error occurred while processing this directive]

Celtic PLC shares are traded on the Alternative Investments Market (AIM). Celtic Quick News cannot be held responsible for any loss due to incorrect information found here.

All information is provided 'as-is', to you use it at your own risk. Always seek professional financial advice before making an investment decision.

Thursday, February 23, 2006
Champions League winners will determine Scottish champions ticket to group stage

Who wins the Champions League has a bearing on whether this seasons Scottish Premier League winner will gain automatic entrance into the Champions League. As such, the outcome could be worth millions of pounds to Celtic.

If the winners qualify automatically for the group stage from their domestic league, the SPL winners will also gain automatic qualification to the group stage.

From the way European Leagues are looking now, our interests will be served if Lyon, Bayern Munich, Juventus, Barcelona or Chelsea wins the tournament. You can add Milan to this list if they hold off their domestic challenge from Inter.

I would be happy to see Real Madrid leave the tournament at this stage, as there seems to be a rule preventing London clubs reaching the final, and Arsenal do not look like this will be their season.

It would be foolish to underestimate Liverpool, as they are a better team this season than last. They are also fighting on three fronts, so are less likely to finish in the top two in England.

A Benfica victory would not go amiss.
Posted by Paul67 at 1:28 PM :: 

281 Comments:
  • At 23/02/06 13:30, Blogger Martybhoy said…

    podium?

     
  • At 23/02/06 13:31, Blogger DiscyBhoy said…

    first?

     
  • At 23/02/06 13:33, Blogger QOTSA75 said…

    hmmm, it all seems up in the air, we should have a better idea by the quarter final stage.

     
  • At 23/02/06 13:33, Blogger Big Joe said…

    qaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

     
  • At 23/02/06 13:33, Blogger Martybhoy said…

    I've touted Barca since day 1 of this tournament. I really hope it is their year and I would really like to see that man gain a well deserved European medal for all his efforts in football. He set up the cross that created the winner last night and made a real difference. I had the pleasure of watching the game with some Barca fans and it turned out to be a great night.

    Come on the Barca!

    Quick quiz on European Cups. Name the 3 cities in the UK to have had two teams (not necessarily in the same year) at the semi final stage or better.

    Hail Hail

    Martybhoy

     
  • At 23/02/06 13:34, Blogger Subterranean said…

    P8ddy

    At the risk of a bolding ;-D , your statistical analysis [sic] of relative league performance between Seasons 2004\05 and 2005\06 is not valid. You are trying to compare two different sets of data that are subject to different variables, conditions and environments. You have an opinion and generally argue in support of that opinion in a robust and articulate fashion. That is fine. However it is misleading and incorrect to support your opinions and conclusions with a superficial statistical analysis that is basically not scientifically valid. Conclusions can be drawn and interpreted from correctly analysed data, but it is wrong to contrive an incomplete analysis of data to support conclusions that have already been formed. Perhaps the simplest and safest statistical comparison is just to look at the two leagues tables after the same number of games played. You will see that Celtic are currently sitting on top of the league, 13 points clear of the team in second and 21 points clear of the team in third place. It is an entirely different and pleasing picture than last season. And I am not a statistician ;-)

    My own subjective and qualitative analysis, based on watching games at Celtic Park and on Setanta, is that Celtic are performing relatively better in the league compared with last year. I’m certainly enjoying watching Celtic more than I did last year. Call me old fashioned but I want to go and watch good and entertaining football between two competing teams. Generally, our league opponents are now stronger and playing better in matches against Celtic. And one of the effects of this increased competition is that the better performing teams are also taking points off each other. An anomaly is r@ngers ;-) . Last year’s eventual champions apparently strengthened their side from last year, but have performed dramatically less well in the league this year. This may well be the most significant factor in any comparative analysis. Hearts, Hibs, Kilmarnock and Inverness Caley, in my opinion, are all better and stronger teams than last year. Falkirk are a better team than the relegated Dundee. Motherwell and Aberdeen have remained at about the same level and may even be slightly stronger. Dundee Utd started poorly, consistent with last year, but are now improving under a new manager. The performances of Dunfermline and Livingstone in the league have declined. Yet the Pars beat Celtic in the league at Celtic Park and are in the final of the CIS Cup? Celtic, in a major transition and with a new manager and players, are sitting top of the tree. They have performed and delivered this year in the league matches that matter. Without doubt there have been some poor performances, particularly in defence. However, I am optimistic that in a difficult football and economic environment, Celtic will continue to improve on last season.

    Chris
    From previous article

     
  • At 23/02/06 13:38, Blogger Denia Bhoy said…

    I think Juve are the best all-round team left in the CL although Barca a bit more exciting. Would love to see Mourinho's interview after being on the receiving end of a blitz at the Nou Camp.

    Wet, windy, hailstones and even snowing all across Spain.

    Hail, Hail

     
  • At 23/02/06 13:41, Blogger eventheoliveswerebleeding said…

    At 1:34 PM, eventheoliveswerebleeding said…

    Paul67 my first ever post and you then started a new article.
    Thereforei have copied this acrross form the last article.

    I suspect that if Celtic, or any of it's supporters, were to complain to UEFA about the 50,000 fans singing scetarian songs last night.
    Then there is the possiblity that UEFA would possibly see this as rival clubs/fans ,trying to create trouble.
    The complaint could lose credibility for this reason.

    I am therefore hoping that someone from NIL BY MOUTH or the Scottish press ,will see this post and act upon it.
    Also that they can provide feedback on UEFA's response.

    I am hoping that they will write to UEFA and complain about the anti Roman Catholic songs which were sung by the vast majority of there 50000 support last night.

    Burnley78 posted earlier with regards to the fact that Rangers are allowing UEFA to broadcast against racial intolerance.

    Yet at the very same time Rangers have sanctioned a banner stating "we are the people".

    UEFA should have what the statement means explained to them.

    UEFA will have had representatives at the match last night.
    Someone should also explain the words of Hello! Hello!
    The expletives about the Pope in Follow Follow,and were up to our knees in Fenian Blood.

    I do not believe that when a UEFA representative hears this bile at Ibrox that they are aware of the exact meaning and the level of hatred portrayed within the songs.

    I am sick to my stomach that this is acceptable.

    Also if we have any TV or newspaper journalists looking in.

    Why? oh! why? don,t you condemn this behaviour instead of making statements such as the Rangers fans are in full voice.

    If you are not part of the solution, then you are part of the problem.

    Make a difference.

     
  • At 23/02/06 13:43, Blogger TheMadMurph said…

    I made the mistake of reading the article before realising it had just been posted!!

    Here's hoping for the correct results for us then!!


    TMM

     
  • At 23/02/06 13:46, Blogger Bhoydell said…

    Am I the only one who thinks this reporting of each other for song's and video's is childish?

    I am sure UEFA and everyone else knows what's going on, but in fairness to Rangers, how do you stop 50,000 people singing a song?

     
  • At 23/02/06 13:48, Blogger Paul67 said…

    Welcomeeventheolives..

    I suspect you are correct, we should leave Rangers problems for others to sort, it is not our business afterall.

    Chris, there is a statistician in there somewhere, or at least someone who has had to answer for his research.

     
  • At 23/02/06 13:52, Blogger hairbhear said…

    Just been listening to Jose's comments re last nights Chelsea v Barca match. Laughed out loud when I heard the crap he was coming out with.

    Watched the match live last night, rather than the other rubbish on Sky Sports 2. Del Horno deserved to go, he had already chopped Messi down twice in the previous 3 minutes and should have been booked for these. His third foul was a stupid/reckless challenge and he only had himself to blame.

    Back to "the chosen one". What goes around comes around ya wee sh@#e. G.I.R.U.Y. wee man.

    Best of luck Henke, a Champions League medal would be just rewards for one of the best players ever to have played in the green and white.

     
  • At 23/02/06 13:53, Blogger timoot said…

    Didn't take you for a Pontius Pilate, Paul and to be honest I'm a wee bit disappointed.

     
  • At 23/02/06 13:53, Blogger pablophanque said…

    Bhoydell, I sincerely hope so.

    pablophanque

     
  • At 23/02/06 13:54, Blogger Chairbhoy said…

    Paul67,

    Really is a lottery at the moment 5 or 6 teams look capable of winning - Think I'll stick to Barca for football/HL reasons

    From the last post! Awe_Naw_No_,

    Wasn't questioning your comments, your post got me searching through Chelsea’s recent results. I read some other postings and I'd made my remarks an open question.

    Subterranean didn’t mean to breach CQN criterion, (so my disclaimer) – At no time did I mean to be misleading and incorrect by supporting my opinions and conclusions with a superficial statistical analysis that is basically not scientifically valid – ; ¬))!!

    Personally, wouldn’t like to see either in a CP Dugout (unless they are getting drubbed in CL SF). My point is that FR has proved himself better than the self nomenclatured special one. I think on a BANG FOR BUCKS basis Mourinhio has been average!

     
  • At 23/02/06 13:57, Blogger EdwardUrsus said…

    Hi Paul,
    I'm surprised your post didn't comment on the ramifications of Rangers winning the C.L (ok, ok I know, but I can dream.
    A few folk have mentioned some of the songs sung at Ibrox last night, anyone who has read my previous posts know my views on this, one point I would like to make though, if as is called for some sort of sanction is taken over it, how do you intend stopping your own bigots from bringing the same sanctions to C.P?

     
  • At 23/02/06 13:57, Blogger darich67 said…

    Martybhoy

    the three cities are Glasgow, London and Dundee

    hail hail

     
  • At 23/02/06 14:00, Blogger Paul67 said…

    Chairbhoy, agree on the Chelsea manager.

    With a stronger squad, he needed every trick in the book to overcome a Martin O’Neill team.

    The ‘bang for bucks’ argument is irrefutable.

    Timoot, not my campaign, and I could think of dozens of reasons why it is not a campaign for Celtic or Celtic fans.

    Their problem, not ours. Involve yourself with it, and you will be associated with it by others.

     
  • At 23/02/06 14:01, Blogger rimtimtim said…

    I don't know which rule you are referring to Paul with regards to London clubs not getting to the final. I just don´t think clubs from the big smoke have been hungry enough down the years. Arsenal have a lot of new potentially hungry players and there was not one English bloke on the field of play the other night. By the way a team called Nelson from Lancashire claims to be the first English club to have won in Real Madrid's stadium, in the 1920´s. Their club chairman says that Bernabeu himself was in the team! The best football has always come from UP NORTH.
    Barça look very solid though and have great footballing talent and Henrik´s experience. If their winning helps us then it´s a double whammy.

     
  • At 23/02/06 14:03, Blogger Subterranean said…

    Paul,

    ...the statistical chances are low ;-D

    Chris

     
  • At 23/02/06 14:04, Blogger Bhoydell said…

    Edward,

    I agree, I do think Celtic have sorted the problem at CP, its the away terracing terrorists that infuriate me. There might also be a wider discussion in this around bigoted v political songs ?

    But again, while Ranger's perhaps could have done more, how do you stop people singing a song?

    I was also about to post on my thoughts around Henrik Larsson but I will leave that for another day as I have a meeting to go to, suffice to say he will never be a Celtic legend in my mind a mercenary yes, a legend never.

     
  • At 23/02/06 14:06, Blogger 6countiesfry said…

    Re. bigoted songs

    We can't get on our high horse - there are still too many cretins who sing the foul line 'Soon there'll be no protestants at all..." It sickens me, and the club should address SPECIFIC lines in songs and condemn their being sung.


    And it is childish ( but true ) the they're worse than us argument.

    Thirdly, it's a freedom of speech issue. As is being discussed elsewhere in the media, if you are for freedom of speech, then you have to argue that your enemies are allowed to say what ever they want, no matter how disgusting it is to you.

    Here endeth the lecture....

     
  • At 23/02/06 14:18, Blogger thismancraig said…

    Horrible debate on 'they're worse than us etc'.

    One area where we can claim the high ground is that as a club we have actively discouraged the bigoted element whereas (as Graham Spiers often highlights) the prematch atmosphere at Ibrox is very different.

    I'm also going to take a stand and say that Henrik Larsson is a Celtic legend.

     
  • At 23/02/06 14:20, Blogger Martybhoy said…

    50F degrees
    People in southern England turn on the central heating
    People in Edinburgh plant out bedding plants

    40F degrees
    Southerners shiver uncontrollably
    Glaswegians sunbathe on the beach at Largs

    35F degrees
    Cars in the south of England refuse to start
    People in Falkirk drive with their windows down

    20F degrees
    Southerners wear overcoats, gloves and woolly hats
    Aberdonian men throw on a T-shirt; girls start wearing mini-skirts

    15F degrees
    Southerners begin to evacuate to the continent
    People from Dundee swim in the River Tay at Broughty Ferry

    Zero degrees
    Life in the south grinds to a halt
    Inverness folk have the last BBQ before it gets cold

    Minus 10F degrees
    Life in the south ceases to exist
    People in Dunfermline throw on a light jacket

    Minus 80F degrees
    Polar bears wonder if it's worth carrying on
    Boy Scouts in Oban start wearing their long trousers

    Minus 100F degrees
    Santa Claus abandons North Pole
    People in Stirling put on their 'long johns'

    Minus 173F degrees
    Alcohol freezes
    Glaswegians get upset because all the pubs are shut

    Minus 297F degrees
    Microbial life starts to disappear
    The cows in Dumfriesshire complain about farmers with cold hands

    Minus 460F degrees
    All atomic motion stops
    Shetlanders stamp their feet and blow on their hands

    Minus 500F degrees
    Hell freezes over
    Rangers win Champions League

     
  • At 23/02/06 14:21, Blogger Martybhoy said…

    Chocolate Teapot to Darich67. Can see myself winning a right few quid on that one down here in London taaaan.

     
  • At 23/02/06 14:25, Blogger Arranmore said…

    I reckon the main reason people at CP sing bigoted lines in songs is cos they don't know what the real line is. Anyway, who wants to sing at CP? You'll be wanting folk to stay till the end next! Dearie me!

     
  • At 23/02/06 14:25, Blogger salt&vinegarofcasualty said…

    Bhoydell,

    I hope you have a kevlar coated hard hat on stand by after your comments regarding the KoK's.

    I think you'd be hard pushed to find a Celt who shares your views on that one my friend.
    To say he was mercenary is just ludicrous.

    At anytime in his time at PH he could have chased the big bucks from the Premiership as Van Hooijdonk, DiCanio and Viduka did, but he didn't.
    He may have been the highest paid Celt ever but compared to any of the EPL top strikers he was on about half what they earn.

    I think the guy really had/has a love for our great club and your comments to the contrary and just insane.

    /Bishop B

     
  • At 23/02/06 14:26, Blogger Glass Half Full said…

    Edward Ursus - re sectarian singing - I refuse to debate this issue with anyone whose position is the usual mealy mouthed "Curse on Both Your Houses", "Each as Bad as the Other".

    Why don't you and the rest of 'ra people' concentrate on flattening your Mount Everest of a problem, and leave us to tackle our very real "Ben Lomond" of sectarianism?

     
  • At 23/02/06 14:29, Blogger the right rev. david hay (preaching pure football) said…

    bhoydell an absolutely disgraceful statement. id have thought better from a long time poster.
    paul, i suggest removal for many violations, especially language.
    maybe an incumbent from the 4th estate is amoung us right enough?

     
  • At 23/02/06 14:31, Blogger the right rev. david hay (preaching pure football) said…

    me spel cheques naquerd du two anger :-(((((

     
  • At 23/02/06 14:34, Blogger Celticblog said…

    I was asked earlier how the Reserve and Youth teams were doing in their leagues.
    The Under-19s are nine points clear of Motherwell, who have a game in hand. And our wee Italian-tournament-winning Bhoys play St Mirren at Airdrie's Shyberry Stadium on Friday (7pm) in the qaurter-finals of the Youth Cup.
    The Reserves are level on points with Aberdeen, who have a game in hand. But the two teams have to meet again in a few weeks.
    Full details on:
    CelticFCblog

    Cheers,
    JohnBhoy

     
  • At 23/02/06 14:34, Blogger Awe_Naw_No_Annoni_Oan_Anaw_Noo said…

    Bhoydell,

    Hang your head in utter shame

     
  • At 23/02/06 14:36, Blogger dandelionskill said…

    P8ddy,

    Why can’t you accept that all the other teams may have improved?

    If you take Killie, Aberdeen and Hibs for example, who have been blooding/playing more of their young rookies than they would normally do in recent times, due to financial restraints, then surely you would admit that these young lads have the benefit of at least 1 more years experience and so should therefore be more accomplished at the job they do.

    As regards your answer to thismancraig and the golf anology –
    Dunfermline played on a plastic pitch last year and a grass one this year.
    How does that change in circumstances effect your 77% stats theory that you posted yesterday?

    If this was a game of Runaround (Mike Read 70’s kids programme), I wouldn’t be running to stand behind you on this one. :-p

    Not that you'd care ;-p

     
  • At 23/02/06 14:37, Blogger leabgarrow said…

    Bhoydell - another attention seeker, don't bite folks.

    Glass half full, mostly agree with your statement on "songs", good analogy.

     
  • At 23/02/06 14:43, Blogger hairbhear said…

    Bhoydell - Mercenary? A bit strong don't you think

    Len Brennan 2:25 - You took the words right out of my mouth.

    I can see this thread developing into a was he/wasn't debate.

    For many of us we remember McNeill, Jonhstone, Lennox etc. for those older it's McGrory, Gallacher etc.

    For many of today's Celtic support Henrik Larsson is the best player they have and probably ever will see wear the hoops. For that reason I would consider him a legend.

    My son is five years old and can only name three Celtic players past or present - Bobo(it's easy to say for a small child), Hartson (he scores goals) and Henrik Larsson, he's known his face since he was 2 years old. For that reason I would consider him a legend.

    Online dictionary definition of legend is; someone or something very famous and admired, usually because of their ability in a particular area.

    You make your own judgement.

     
  • At 23/02/06 14:44, Blogger QOTSA75 said…

    martbhoy, hee hee hee, liked that one.
    Bhoydell-is your meeting in Carstairs for therepay on your criminal insanity?

     
  • At 23/02/06 14:45, Blogger Paul67 said…

    Bhoydell, is that a hand grenade in your pocket?

    We have discussed Henrik before. The agreement we came to was:

    He would have left if we did not pay him that enormous last contract.

    Henrik occupies a special place for me, worth every penny, but they are all here for the money - with the possible exception of Roy Keane and anyone else who has declined twice the money Celtic have offered to play for Celtic.

    If I can paraphrase Kojo, or maybe Jack himself, ‘what are you going to do for me tomorrow’. When it comes to players, sentimentality is a hindrance that inhibits many losing teams.

     
  • At 23/02/06 14:49, Blogger OttoKaiser said…

    Bhoydell,
    You're at the wind-up surely?
    Certainly Henrik was paid vast sums of money for what he did at our club, and no, maybe he didn't grow up with the club as his first love (I don't think that is necessarily grounds for legend status - just see the debates recently on Peter Grant). However, the man scored so many important goals for the club and not only scored but contributed through his whole game that he certainly IS a legend. Did you see him after he scored his 2nd at CP in his last competitive league game?

     
  • At 23/02/06 14:57, Blogger FrankieBhoy said…

    Martybhoy

    To clarify your quiz question, it related to European trohpies not The European Cup ?

     
  • At 23/02/06 15:00, Blogger otis_green said…

    Henrik not a legend? or Bhoydell not a Celtic fan? you decide.
    unless of course KirstyMcCabeCSC can come up with the REAL reason,you know the drill by now Buckie Bhoys/wrong school bla bla bla .....zzz

     
  • At 23/02/06 15:04, Blogger williebhoy said…

    A rangers supporting friend at work brought in yesterday's match programme. I noted that Rangers were offering accomodation for those on the community coaching programmes at Garscube Sports Centre, home of some of the finest pitches in Scotland...pity they missed out the bit Used by Celtic youth tems on a weekly basis.

    Murray Park not good enough then, An academy with no accomodation...Has it been done on the cheap lads ?
    Surely they could use the 150 room Hotel that they were shouting about building back in 1997, must be finished now.

     
  • At 23/02/06 15:07, Blogger Adrian1888 said…

    Bhoydell

    You are just her to cause trouble aernt you the contribution Larsson gave to this club was Lengendary. I wont go through the stats we all know them. What happened did he decline an autograph one time and you looked down on him ever since.

    Like Jock Stein said "Celtic was not my first love but it will certainly be my last"

    This could apply to Larsson in a way.

     
  • At 23/02/06 15:08, Blogger Dell said…

    Len Brennan, Adrian 1888

    Bhoydell is in important meeting, don’t be too harsh on him, obviously he’s sensitive about imposters earning a fortune and being announced the King of Kings when it should be me King Dell

     
  • At 23/02/06 15:14, Blogger p8ddy said…

    Subterranean...

    At the risk of a bolding ;-D

    Self fulfilling prophesy! :-D However, you should read my conclusions rather than the conclusion you think I'm drawing. I only used the statisics to illustrate the league was no stronger than the year before. Certainly didn't use them to make any postulation about the qualities of Celtic.

    p8ddy's post-

    Estadio, whilst your sentiments are laudible, your assertion that the league this year is of a higher standard simply doesn't hold up to scrutiny.

    That was my only point!

    your statistical analysis [sic] of relative league performance between Seasons 2004\05 and 2005\06 is not valid. You are trying to compare two different sets of data that are subject to different variables, conditions and environments.

    ...and trying to extrapolate if the differing variables (primarily players & management) are making a better or worse league. I am comparing two identical sets of data - The SPL table after 27 games in both seasons. There is nothing wrong with the statistics, or the premiss. The only meaningful change to the league was the introduction of Falkirk at the expense of Dundee. Given the relegated club was not one that had came up and went straight back down it's a relatively safe assumption that the respectful skill sets of the teams is not dissimilar. Analysing the data with regard to positions and not specific teams also makes the analysis rather safer as it then discounts the vagaries of individual teams collapsing/having a meteoric rise. The environments are also within standard deviation - ie year on year they are subject to the same minor change (between 2 and 5 percent dependant on whether Celtic play once or twice at the ground in question).
    My point was not to use the statistics to determine if Celtic were better this year or last, but to determine if the league was on an upswing, as stated by estadio.

    You have an opinion and generally argue in support of that opinion in a robust and articulate fashion. That is fine. However it is misleading and incorrect to support your opinions and conclusions with a superficial statistical analysis that is basically not scientifically valid. Conclusions can be drawn and interpreted from correctly analysed data, but it is wrong to contrive an incomplete analysis of data to support conclusions that have already been formed.

    How is my analysis superficial? It is not a macro analysis carried out with due scientific rigour, but as a rule of thumb indicator it's perfectly valid. The numbers won't reveal precise characteristics of the league but they do stand as valid.
    I'm measuring the same league over the same time frame in two different years. The league format is identical, the teams are within standard deviation (ie it's more or less the same teams competing for the same prize). Given that I'm not vbeing team specific it's perfectly appropriate. It's not too different to examining yer on year trends in the finances of the club. 2004 vs 2005 for instance. As long as you state the assumptions/risks and variables that might colour the result.
    Thankfully, regarding the variables - these actually contribute to the conclusion, as financial strictures, player movement and other managers make the league stronger or weaker! I didn't use the stats to extrapolate whether Celtic were better than last season. Taken out of context, the statistics are meaningless. It's as valid for you to say p8ddy, your point is wrong as jam has reduced in price this year! as the point you are actually making. The statistic only supports the conclusion I came to, which was the the league is no stronger this year than last.
    Also, I would never try and twist data to suport an argument. I've stated many times on CQN, I'm open minded, I want to have my worries adressed and indeed discounted. I want to be converted. Certainly, I'm not entrenched in my views, and I'd never be so closed minded. I've never had a problem with being wrong, I don't imagine myself infallible. If I had examined the stats and the numbers had proved me wrong, I'd be happy about that. Honestly.

    Perhaps the simplest and safest statistical comparison is just to look at the two leagues tables after the same number of games played. You will see that Celtic are currently sitting on top of the league, 13 points clear of the team in second and 21 points clear of the team in third place.

    Looking at the league table from this year to last tells you the position the teams are in, nothing else. Certainly, it doesn't tell you about the relative strength or weakness of the league. The empirical data you are using to bolster your suppostion of my statistical weakness is actually far, far weaker than mine! :-)

    It is an entirely different and pleasing picture than last season. And I am not a statistician ;-)

    Beyond doubt my fine friend. Beyond doubt. :-) We are in accord on that note!

    /p

     
  • At 23/02/06 15:15, Blogger CELTICFC NUMERO UNO said…

    Remember bhoys and ghirls some people just post rediculous comments just for a reaction. They have the same mental defficiency as the ‘experts’ of the various phone ins. Try not to rise to it.

     
  • At 23/02/06 15:17, Blogger VargasShampoo said…

    Bhoydell - make that 9 pints of Martel, a pint of Pernod & a Castrol GTX shandy.

    I would ditch that meeting you need to go to & have a wee lie down if i were you. Henrik not a legend?

     
  • At 23/02/06 15:20, Blogger leabgarrow said…

    well, one poster has certainly increased his profile today, in a Gerry McNee esque fashion.
    DO NOT BITE!!!

    I can almost hear the titters in the background!!

     
  • At 23/02/06 15:21, Blogger CambuslangisaReality said…

    Bhoydell - am i singing the right words here?

    Wullie Falconer.....Wullie Falconer.........Wullie Falconer is The King of Kings!!

     
  • At 23/02/06 15:22, Blogger evil rhum baa baa said…

    Bhoydell...

    Paul, can we get an electric ASBO on him for this?

     
  • At 23/02/06 15:23, Blogger RubberBalloons said…

    Re the sectarian singing debate.
    Rangers as a club actively encourage this type of behaviour.
    They bow to the bigots and bring back "Simply the best" after warning the fans it would be stopped if they continued to add in their own sectarian lyrics.The fans never stopped , but so what. They play flute music to accompany "Follow Follow" with the obvious Orange Order connotations and sell orange Christmas trees in the club shop.
    Not to mention banning Eggs Benedict,Bob "FTP" Malcolm, and refusing free Peperami because the wrappers were green etc you can see that this club clearly has a problem.
    They pander to the bigots because they need their cash.
    Compare this attitude to that of Celtic.
    Name one thing that Celtic as club do to encourage sectarian behaviour.
    Name me one sectarian song sung regularly at Celtic Park.
    The difference in the two clubs is night and day.

     
  • At 23/02/06 15:27, Blogger madmitch said…

    Blantyre Kev

    Your post was therapy for you, well it was therapy for me. Cl qualification looms large for the club, failure and it will be a fire sale of "Ibrox" proportions.

    Good point about Multimedia income, the £5.5mill reduction should be seen in light of the £7.1mill EUFA CL money that was present in 2004/05. Taking out any uplift due to the qualification tie that was not there a year previously the progress being made seems encouraging, £200K+ pcm?

    Also interested in how the merchandising holds up, the first half of 2005 was poor not only because the strips were changing but also because the team was playing poorly and the only buzz came from Craig B.

    However my questions from before still stand:

    1) Nike £5mill - Any idea on staging? Monthly, Quarterly, Half yearly?

    2) Player Investment 2005/06 - Any idea on the staging, I don't think we have paid up front on this so we will still have cash to pay out. Any ideas?

    3) Player Investment 2006/07 - Any ideas on the amounts available? We seem to be looking at the same overall wage level so it all comes down to what we can afford. The gambler in me thinks £10mill net but we have to pay the second instalments on some of the existing players and we also have to find the cash for Lennoxtown.

    4) Debt - I can see a negative cashflow of £2mill in the second half so the debt will be in 8 figures again.

    5) T/O - £55-57mill is my best guess.

    6) Total Footbal wages budget - £25mill and falling?
    I suspect there will be a "Deadwood II" come the summer. £9mill in basic pay looks to be short term and their replacements will be on considerably less.

    7) GTF provision - £1.4mill set aside on the balance sheet for this. Will it be used, has any been used already?

    8) Any ideas on how we can get the T/O up to £100mill in the medium term outside of a trip to the EPL?

     
  • At 23/02/06 15:59, Blogger Bhoydell said…

    Leabgarrow, never been an attention seeker in my life, people are allowed opinion's that differ from you. Henrik was probably the best striker I have watched at Celtic, (although I did see Dalgliesh just before he moved on), however there is one simple question about this guy who had a true love of our club (according to some), would he have shown this love by signing again if we had not offered him £35K per week.........?

    This was also the guy who took £1m from his "farewell" game and didn't give 1p of it to charity, celtic or anyone else, striaght in the hip like any good mercenary would..

    This is guy who only a few months ago said he didn't understand were the money went to a Celtic (answer check your own bank account)

    This is the guy who came back and stuck it to us for Barca.


    Johnston, McNiell, Auld............. celtic legends.

     
  • At 23/02/06 16:00, Blogger timoot said…

    MadMitch

    Wasn't 7 million or so of the recent share issue to be set aside for Lennoxtown and some for debt reduction.Since the target was reached or even oversubscribed surely that issue( Academy/Training centre) is now resolved.

     
  • At 23/02/06 16:02, Blogger FrankieBhoy said…

    LarryBhoy

    It's a long running joke in the Fiver to link Rangers with Catholic references.

     
  • At 23/02/06 16:03, Blogger LarryBhoy said…

    New to CQN, first post a bit off the beaten track, but does anyone know the answer to why the Guardian refer to TFOD thus;

    In The Fiver today, under A Bad Night in Benfica

    link - http://football.guardian.co.uk/fiver/

    "Since then, Benitez has repeatedly shown that he's a smart man and a clever manager. So why he sent Liverpool out to play for a 0-0 against Benfica - probably the second-worst side ever to reach the Big Cup knock-out stages after the Pope's O'Rangers - was about as baffling as James Blunt becoming a global pop phenomenon."

    ???

     
  • At 23/02/06 16:05, Blogger martinobhoy said…

    Paul

    London's not the only capital city that cant seem to produce a European champion. If you look at the big 5 countries only Madrid has done it with Berlin, London, Rome and Paris all failing to win a single European Cup.

     
  • At 23/02/06 16:08, Blogger FrankieBhoy said…

    I reckon only 4 European Capital Cities have provided European Cup winners. Anyone name them ?

     
  • At 23/02/06 16:09, Blogger leabgarrow said…

    whatever.

     
  • At 23/02/06 16:10, Blogger thismancraig said…

    Bhoydell, I think Paul's response to your original post is enough. I wonder how many 'legends' would have stayed with the club had they played in the modern era? You mention one who would have been off quicker than you can say 'mibbees aye'

    Henrik could have left for more money on several occassions, he has just rejected a new contract with Barca to return to Sweden for less money as well.

    At Celtic Park, he played for Barca thus had no option but to stick his chance away.

    File him away under Legend.

     
  • At 23/02/06 16:10, Blogger SimplyaBhoy said…

    I personally don't care how much Henke earned. I just loved the guy for what he did for our club.

     
  • At 23/02/06 16:20, Blogger Nuclearfalloutbhoy said…

    Hairbear….you said at 1.52pm in relation to the current Chelsea Manager

    Back to "the chosen one". What goes around comes around ya wee sh@#e. G.I.R.U.Y. wee man

    Are you serious? This is presumably because Porto beat us in the UEFA cup final? Is this anyway for a Celtic fan to behave?

    Yours is the sort of view I would expect to see on Follow Follow and I'm disappointed in the extreme to be reading it on here

     
  • At 23/02/06 16:21, Blogger Awe_Naw_No_Annoni_Oan_Anaw_Noo said…

    Bhoydell,

    If you can just remember Dalglish before he moved on, then you cant remember the Celtic legends that you mention, or experienced what tehy brought to the club. Seems a paper thin opinion to me that your holding. Henk could have went for more - transfer fee and wages but he didn´t. Henk done many a charitable thing while in Scotland and for Scottish people and didn´t blow his trumpet about it or seek publicity.If he thinks that the club is not well finacially run then maybe he was hanging around with madmitch what´s wrong with that ?

     
  • At 23/02/06 16:23, Blogger Paul67 said…

    Astute observation Martinobhoy.

    I could go further still and say that apart from Lisbon, Madrid and Belgrade, no other capital city has produced a European champion.

    Could it be that football is most effective when based in the industrial heartlands, not the commercial centres?

    Welcome Larrybhoy. I am under the impression that the guys at The Guardian like to enjoy themselves.

     
  • At 23/02/06 16:24, Blogger OttoKaiser said…

    Larrybhoy - I think it was because TFOD qualified to the knock-out stages with one of the worst records in CL History - only one win in the six games. Also, I'm pretty sure one of the guys who writes the Fiver is a Hoops man.

    nuclearfalloutbhoy - not wanting to put words in peoples mouths but I don't think it's because we lost the final - there was an article published where he was describing his teams preparations for the final and I think during one of the team talks he said something to the players to the effect that if contact was made - go down, as it would upset our mentality. I think Karma would have been a better way to put his teams result last night, in light of his gripe at Messi "provoking" Del Horno.

     
  • At 23/02/06 16:24, Blogger otis_green said…

    LarryBhoy, they call them the Popes O'rangers and us the Queens Celtic, somebody always bites.

    Now feeling very disappointed because according to Dell I have never seen a Celtic legend play for the club (nor has he right enough) unless of course he meant Mo Johnston,which I'm gpoing to have ot disagree with.

    and nuclearfalloutbhoy,is there any room for such passion/downright rudeness in football? I say.....yes

     
  • At 23/02/06 16:25, Blogger thismancraig said…

    Amsterdam

     
  • At 23/02/06 16:25, Blogger madmitch said…

    timoot

    The £14.55mill cash injection from the share issue means that we currently have a bank debt of £8.74mill. This is where the proceeds now reside, with the bank to keep the debt down.

    On top of this will be a negative cashflow of £2mill in the second half (my best guess - last season and the lack of SC games) of the season means that we will have a debt in 8 figures come June.

    £10mill+ in debt and not a brick has been laid for Lennoxtown. The training ground will then have to be paid out of existing resources as the share issue money would have been spent to keep the debt under control.

    Consequently times are a bit tight at the moment and if no CL money shows up in 2006/07 we will be in deep doo-doo.

    All issues can be resolved but it will take a bit of imagination and business acumen to get things back on track. things that BQ has not been noted for in the past.

    The way out of "sale and leaseback" of the training ground is readily available but the papers would have a field day with it to try run the club down. However we may have help from an unusual source, TFOD if they have to do something similar for MP then the cries will be somewhat muted.

    Sale and Leaseback:
    £7-8mill capital cost = £500Kpa in interest payments. Split between the youth set-up and the first team the figures would be containable.

    Sold to the public as a way of releasing funds to finance extra player investment? Would be the way to go, bricks and mortar have rarely won a game for anyone.

    Ten / fifteen year deal and the £7-8mill capital sum will be more manageable when the arrangement comes to an end.

    Season ticket prices up 30 - 40% over the next 10 years? £10mill in extra revenue from this source alone in 2016.

     
  • At 23/02/06 16:28, Blogger Paul67 said…

    thismancraig, I think you'll find The Hage is the capital city of The Netherlands.

     
  • At 23/02/06 16:29, Blogger hairbhear said…

    Nuclearfalloutbhoy 4:20

    I'm about to leave work for home so haven't time to answer you now but will do so later.

    My problem with Jose is Porto diving against us and then Man Utd a few months later.

    Now he complains when done to him.

     
  • At 23/02/06 16:30, Blogger otis_green said…

    Paul is Amsterdam not the capital, and the Hague the seat of Government?

     
  • At 23/02/06 16:32, Blogger thismancraig said…

    Paul67 that's what I thought,

    However, according the MSN our survey says...

    Amsterdam (The Netherlands), seaport and largest city of The Netherlands. Amsterdam is located in Noord-Holland (North Holland) Province, on the IJ (an arm of the IJsselmeer), near The Hague. It is the commercial, financial, and cultural center of The Netherlands, as well as the country's official capital; however, the real center of national government is in The Hague.

     
  • At 23/02/06 16:34, Blogger FrankieBhoy said…

    thismancraig

    Hope they don't have the question 'What Is The Capital of the Netherlands' for a million quid on Who Wants to be a Millionaire.

    If Amsterdam is included then there are 5 European Capitals with a European Cup winner.

     
  • At 23/02/06 16:34, Blogger dannybhoy67 said…

    Glasgow and Belgrade?

     
  • At 23/02/06 16:39, Blogger dannybhoy67 said…

    ah, and Bucharest

     
  • At 23/02/06 16:40, Blogger FrankieBhoy said…

    Madrid
    Lisbon
    Belgrade
    Bucharest
    Amsterdam (late entry)

     
  • At 23/02/06 16:40, Blogger Chairbhoy said…

    Was Frankurt or Munich the Capital of West Germany?

    Leabgarrow - Chomsky Quote??

     
  • At 23/02/06 16:43, Blogger Paul67 said…

    Thismancraig/otis

    Celtic Quick News officially recognises that The Hague, as seat of government, monarchy and embassies, is capital of The Netherlands.

    MSN is clearly involved in some plot to usurp the Dutch establishment.

    Dannybhoy67, doh! Bucharest.

    Charibhoy, Bonn was capital of West Germany, and still is. Celtic Quick News does not recognise the reunification of Germany. :-)

     
  • At 23/02/06 16:44, Blogger LarryBhoy said…

    Re Pope's O'Rangers - thanks to all for the explanation - thought it might be a bit more intelligent than a simple wind up, but there you go :-)

     
  • At 23/02/06 16:46, Blogger SimplyaBhoy said…

    hairbhear - I'm with you on this one.

    "The Chosen One" incites his players to cheat against us and then is indignant when a Barca player gets one of his players sent off!!

    I personally quite like Jose, but he has done himself no favours with his comments from last nights game.

     
  • At 23/02/06 16:47, Blogger thismancraig said…

    I'm (more) confused but numbers is my game -

    The Hague is the seat of government, but, somewhat anomalously, not the official capital of the Netherlands, a role set aside by the Dutch constitution for Amsterdam. The Hague hosts the Eerste Kamer (lit.: "First Chamber") or "Senaat" and the Tweede Kamer (lit.: "Second Chamber"), respectively the upper and lower houses forming the Dutch parliament. Also the Dutch Queen Beatrix lives and works in The Hague. All foreign embassies and most government ministries are located in the city, as well as the Supreme Court and many lobbying organisations.

     
  • At 23/02/06 16:48, Blogger otis_green said…

    What do you expect from a country with two names Holland/Netherlands??

    hey Kirsty I'm not just saying that cos they've got orange strips!!

     
  • At 23/02/06 16:50, Blogger Big Joe said…

    Paul67.……………….or any 1 in the Know…….?

    A bit off topic ……………………….but

    When is the CQN golf …………………….

    test………..match…………..thing……….

    I am planning 2 return the my native land ………………

    And am trying to fit everything in……………….

    BigjoewholivesinSpainbutisPlanning
    someholidaysandFanciesafewBEERSswiththeCQNbHoys

     
  • At 23/02/06 16:51,