Re off/on side firstly i though it was off side but when i saw replay from roof perspective i think it was rather on than off. Anyway benefit of doubt was applied. Sammi was great but wilson is terific so far. Absolutely disapointed from my fav player izzy. Nevermind last 45 mins.
Michael on
mncelt
A player is in an offside position if:
he is nearer to his opponents’ goal line than both the ball and the second last opponent
But I will take it. We’ve been done plenty of times.
Glendalystonsils likes a mr whippy with his lime green jelly on
Sammi , Forrest and Hooper look in the mood. Turn it on in the 2nd half Bhoys!
miki67 on
Commentators……blah….those who can,do. Those who can’t,criticise.
My cat knows know more about the rules than the plums in the studio!
HH!
navanbhoy on
nervous for first 15 or 20 mins then we got the ball to forrest and samaras and it’s game on, we have looked much more comfortable since then.
goal was definately offside, about time we got a bit of luck with the officials though
Mon the HOOPS
corkcelt on
Craigan Thompson and his team would not have given that goal, so it probably was ok. but I would be raging if it was given at the other end.
Shocking tackle by a Basel player on Mc Geady straight leg to knee should have been a red. McGeady held back by the other Spartak players as he was trying to deck the perp
I humbly suggest it’s about where gary was when the ball is played..was he in front of the ball..if yes he is offside..its not about Sammie being in front of Gary ?
Raymy on
I wish they’d stop going on about beinng in front of the ball for the offside. Whether you are in front of the ball or not is immaterial. However if you are in front of the man playing the ball, then you are offside.
The rules say:-
It is not an offence in itself to be in an offside position.
A player is in an offside position if:
• he is nearer to his opponents’ goal line than both the ball and the
second-last opponent
A player is not in an offside position if:
• he is in his own half of the fi eld of play or
• he is level with the second-last opponent or
• he is level with the last two opponents
Offence
A player in an offside position is only penalised if, at the moment the ball
touches or is played by one of his team, he is, in the opinion of the referee,
involved in active play by:
• interfering with play or
• interfering with an opponent or
• gaining an advantage by being in that position.
So it matters not if the player is in front of the ball. His feet were in line if not behind Samaras’s at the moment the ball was played to him, ergo, onside
The position of the ball is not an issue.
Raymy on
By they i mean the so called pundits
'GG on
Crocker and Provan back on audio
the long wait is over on
Smart thing to do here is just kill the game – play it out. Nothing fancy required. Just be professional.
MHARK67 on
cmon the hoops keep it tight and disciplined for the first twenty off this half as they have nothing to lose now
i fancy us for one more in last 20 mins if we can keep a clean sheet till then
aw feck it dont care as long as we go through jabba et al wil be spewin
overseasbhoy on
Provan still crying over the decision….get over it….
'GG on
Nice play VW
O.G.Rafferty on
Lovely from Vic
miki67 on
I hope all fans of Scottish football will be delighted that we are keeping the coefficient increasing all on our own,and that we will be bringing much needed foreign income to the economy.
Glasgow Celtic…..our day has come and we’re doing it on our own. For everybody.
Good shot from the Borg……………..great save from Big FF.
toscanabhoy on
miki67
20:52 on
29 August, 2012
I hope all fans of Scottish football will be delighted that we are keeping the coefficient increasing all on our own,and that we will be bringing much needed foreign income to the economy.
Glasgow Celtic…..our day has come and we’re doing it on our own. For everybody.
Wee Wullie Bluenose to release an album in our honour.
HH!
miki67 on
And….we’ve got a good goalie…I hope that does not disappoint the muppets in the studio or the sad commentators lookin to diss us somehow.
Provan…..get a grip!
: > )
O.G.Rafferty on
I often think how much the man who invents a cure for baldness would make… but it would be nothing compared to the riches awaiting for a Davie Provan mute button on a night like this…
'GG on
Mathews persistent concedes corner
Raymy on
HIF are pushing. Celtic standing up to it with some resistance
607 Comments- Pages:
- «
- 1
- ...
- 6
- 7
- 8
- 9
- 10
- 11
- 12
- 13
- 14
- 15
- 16
- »
Re off/on side firstly i though it was off side but when i saw replay from roof perspective i think it was rather on than off. Anyway benefit of doubt was applied. Sammi was great but wilson is terific so far. Absolutely disapointed from my fav player izzy. Nevermind last 45 mins.
mncelt
A player is in an offside position if:
he is nearer to his opponents’ goal line than both the ball and the second last opponent
But I will take it. We’ve been done plenty of times.
Sammi , Forrest and Hooper look in the mood. Turn it on in the 2nd half Bhoys!
Commentators……blah….those who can,do. Those who can’t,criticise.
My cat knows know more about the rules than the plums in the studio!
HH!
nervous for first 15 or 20 mins then we got the ball to forrest and samaras and it’s game on, we have looked much more comfortable since then.
goal was definately offside, about time we got a bit of luck with the officials though
Mon the HOOPS
Craigan Thompson and his team would not have given that goal, so it probably was ok. but I would be raging if it was given at the other end.
Shocking tackle by a Basel player on Mc Geady straight leg to knee should have been a red. McGeady held back by the other Spartak players as he was trying to deck the perp
I think it’s clear to say, naebody knows the true offside rules. Even the commentators and studio guests are arguing about it. Who cares! ;-)
In my opinion hooper was behind samaras when the ball was played. Good goal, seemples.
Video of the goal
Well done Linesman , err i mean Hooper !
http://www.kirkintillochemerald.co.uk/showthread.php?p=32165#post32165
I humbly suggest it’s about where gary was when the ball is played..was he in front of the ball..if yes he is offside..its not about Sammie being in front of Gary ?
I wish they’d stop going on about beinng in front of the ball for the offside. Whether you are in front of the ball or not is immaterial. However if you are in front of the man playing the ball, then you are offside.
The rules say:-
It is not an offence in itself to be in an offside position.
A player is in an offside position if:
• he is nearer to his opponents’ goal line than both the ball and the
second-last opponent
A player is not in an offside position if:
• he is in his own half of the fi eld of play or
• he is level with the second-last opponent or
• he is level with the last two opponents
Offence
A player in an offside position is only penalised if, at the moment the ball
touches or is played by one of his team, he is, in the opinion of the referee,
involved in active play by:
• interfering with play or
• interfering with an opponent or
• gaining an advantage by being in that position.
So it matters not if the player is in front of the ball. His feet were in line if not behind Samaras’s at the moment the ball was played to him, ergo, onside
The position of the ball is not an issue.
By they i mean the so called pundits
Crocker and Provan back on audio
Smart thing to do here is just kill the game – play it out. Nothing fancy required. Just be professional.
cmon the hoops keep it tight and disciplined for the first twenty off this half as they have nothing to lose now
i fancy us for one more in last 20 mins if we can keep a clean sheet till then
aw feck it dont care as long as we go through jabba et al wil be spewin
Provan still crying over the decision….get over it….
Nice play VW
Lovely from Vic
I hope all fans of Scottish football will be delighted that we are keeping the coefficient increasing all on our own,and that we will be bringing much needed foreign income to the economy.
Glasgow Celtic…..our day has come and we’re doing it on our own. For everybody.
HH!
Big Vic is my hero, a class act
dudes enjoy the slice of luck, lets not debate it. bring on the second half bhoys………….. forrest to make it 2-0 ; )
KLV
Call me old fashioned!! I’m going with the officials
Goal
Sammi uses his strength and crosses. Cleared
Sammi outmuscles defender to get cross in
Brown playing well
Crocker Provan silenced
Bhoys
Can anyone tell me how many first half corners there were? Can’t find a site with stats
Thanks
We miss Joe’s runs into the box for crosses. Hoops is no target man.
good save big FF
Good save Forster from fk
great save
Good shot from the Borg……………..great save from Big FF.
miki67
20:52 on
29 August, 2012
I hope all fans of Scottish football will be delighted that we are keeping the coefficient increasing all on our own,and that we will be bringing much needed foreign income to the economy.
Glasgow Celtic…..our day has come and we’re doing it on our own. For everybody.
Wee Wullie Bluenose to release an album in our honour.
HH!
And….we’ve got a good goalie…I hope that does not disappoint the muppets in the studio or the sad commentators lookin to diss us somehow.
Provan…..get a grip!
: > )
I often think how much the man who invents a cure for baldness would make… but it would be nothing compared to the riches awaiting for a Davie Provan mute button on a night like this…
Mathews persistent concedes corner
HIF are pushing. Celtic standing up to it with some resistance