In the range of events I never thought would possibly happen, David Murray appearing on a podcast with Graeme Souness discussing EBTs is right up there! You would expect the master architect of the scheme that destroyed Rangers and a recipient of an EBT, paid when he was Blackburn Rovers manager, would keep well away from this subject. That they did not, tells you a great deal about the personalities of both.
Murray credited himself with giving Rangers nine-in-a-row and Gascoigne, and admitted to the sins of ambition and vanity. Ambition, that football fault which is so similar to being just perfect. Always be aware of characters throwing that around as their fault (I’m not going to mention our former vain and ‘ambitious’ character).
His technical defence was that auditors for Rangers and Murray International Holdings (MIH) both signed off on his EBT scheme. True, but wholly irrelevant. A quick explainer:
An EBT is a loan. Employers loan staff money every day. Crisis loans, relocations loans and loans to cover health-related issues are common. If it is a short-term matter, or in a small company, little or no paperwork is required. At other times, the loan needs to be formally written up. These loans can also be forgiven (often happens when a crisis loan is issued). No problem with this and no employment tax is due.
Rangers EBT scheme effectively paid footballers, managers and execs with these types of loans, however, for the footballers (at least), the loans were contractual obligations, with a clause which meant they never had to be repaid. In 2017, the UK Supreme Court ruled that these contracts were disguised renumeration and that employment taxes were due on them.
The contract invalidated the EBT structure. MIH possibly did not have the same contractual arrangements, so EY, their auditor, would be untroubled by the scheme. The point David Murray did not address, was whether Rangers auditor – Grant Thornton – were informed about the contractual nature of the club’s EBTs.
Grant Thornton are unlikely to defend themselves against this contagion, but no one pursued the firm for poor advice in relation to the signing of Rangers accounts. It is not credible to suggest that Grant Thornton knew of these contracts and no one has claimed they were told.
In adopting an ‘innovative tax strategy’, Rangers knew a challenge from HMRC was possible. They would have got away with it, were they not raided by City of London Police in relation to the Jean-Alain Boumsong sale to Newcastle (then managed by Souness). This transaction was subject to investigation by the Stevens Inquiry. That issue is worth an hour of your time reviewing the characters involved in the UK game at the time.
When this was going on, other things were crumbling around Murray. The Bank of Scotland went bust and was sold, with new oversight and a different appetite for his largesse. Rangers won three successive leagues in the run-up to administration, they were solvent and could have chosen to set money aside from Champions League qualification to offset a potential HMRC settlement. Instead, they returned to the roulette table year after year.
If I had my way, I would build a statue to David Murray outside Celtic Park. He has done more for our success than anyone not directly connected to Celtic. Without his navigation, Rangers would never have been liquidated, and Celtic would not have removed that “World’s most successful….” writing from the walls of what he vaingloriously called Murray Park. Celebrate the man, he is a gift to generations of Celtic fans.
Also, when he dies, I’m open to offers on writing a book.
326 Comments- Pages:
- «
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- 6
- 7
- 8
- 9
https://celtsarehere.com/steven-gerrard-addresses-celtic-paper-talk/
Celtic without Daizen Maeda are a wet blanket
Daizen Maeda still at Celtic = LASK 0-8 Celtic.
McInnes would have been sacked weeks ago and all the talk would be about Sevco2.
But here we are after McInnes blew our house of cards down twice in a week.
Remembering Cable st and the fascist scum getting chased
https://x.com/PRL_library/status/2106823159131632003
Eyewitness to Cable st
https://x.com/antearmann1967/status/2106892306427088909
HH
South Africa is the conscience on the world:
https://x.com/yvonneridley/status/2106498594627113051
U2 in their pomp couldn’t gather crowds like this.
Wow!
The exiled Rebel CSC
The PLC statement was, in my opinion, ill timed and reactionary. Our PLC and green brigade/collective morphing into the zombie owners and onion bears we laughed at in the banter years. We have a way to go before we hit rock bottom.
I do have a couple of questions though. Did the collective hire the balaclavas from the onion bears (green onions) and was it just the masks or full gimp suits. Secondly does anyone in the collective have shares in tennis ball companies and have they thought about getting sponsorship from a tennis ball manufacturer. Could go a long way to buying the 34% of shares needed to get a new owner.
At least we won the six’s and the sun is shining. Hail Hail.
From what I can gather :-
Huns wearing balaclavas, disgusting and outrageous.
Celtic supporters wearing balaclavas, good, fun and acceptable.
HH.
Greenpinata
That’ll be Celtic fans with one of your imaginary “agendas” that,like the 4corners ‘agenda’ you seem to type with ease, but when asked for an explanation you basically bolt!.
So you where do you sit An Tearman on Bakaclavas, without the deflection.
TAURANGABHOY on 5TH OCTOBER 2026 7:43 AM
Glasgow weather forecast today is for 90% rain
Without the deflection of the G/B and Balaclavas
Where do you sit on the power structure of the PLC
Do you agree that there is valid criticism (and more) of the PLC that they are subservient to the Majority share holder who behaves as if he is “The owner” and is referred by the present manger as “The owner”
There is no doubt that there is toxicity around the club, your finger pointing from the other side of the world only points at the fan base……….. why
A new Chairman and CEO are urgently required, Investment required in the Stadium, the team, the temporary nature of management of the football dept needs resolved, with a modernised structured led by a football oriented CEO and DOF is urgent, who is responsible for carrying out these tasks…………….the fanbase ? where do sit on all of the above issues
BTW I love balaclavas having climbed a few hills and munro’s they are brilliant for keeping the lugs warm, apparently they also help preventing your doors getting kicked in at 6 am for a minor charge like BOTP
An Tearmann,
What f@cking imaginary agenda are you on about.
Balaclavas to hide identity are sinister and intimidatory no matter who is wearing them.
They serve a practical purpose perhaps when working on an oil rig in the Artic circle, not on city streets or a golf course.
The four corners notoriety is not imaginary. It is real and factual.
Sometimes my friend, I think you live on a parallel universe to the vast majority of people.
HH.
15 Most Dangerous Cities in the UK
Security Journal UK
https://securityjournaluk.com › most-dangerous-cities-in-…
15 Apr 2025 — A fellow student, also 15, has been charged with his murder. Violent crime constitutes a significant portion of reported incidents in Sheffield.Read more
Glasgow not in the top 15
12 Most Dangerous Cities in the UK: 2026 Crime Stats
Reolink
https://reolink.com › Blog › Home Security FAQs
25 Jun 2026 — What UK city has the highest crime rate? Blackpool currently has the highest crime rate, particularly for violent offenses. Is Glasgow or …Read more
Top 12 Most Dangerous Cities…
UK Crime Rate Overview
Glasgow not in the top 12
Lionsroar no such thing as a perfect world or football club. Extremes just aggravate. Yes I agree that fans should have a voice. No I don’t agree that includes wearing balaclavas to intimidate. I doubt you that throw tennis balls at hares on your way up. Deflection. Denying the majority owner is the owner is deluded. Thinking that you can force him to change staff under duress is arrogant. The other large shareholders back him. You say the fans don’t and yet 99% renewed. Moaning in the pub is one thing, disrupting players and club staff is self destruction. How on earth do you think that behaviour is going to end in any positive result. The majority owners says the line has been crossed. You don’t need to be a genius to work out what comes next.
So you support people breaching the peace but think they should hide behind a mask so that they won’t get caught. Petals.
What club doesn’t need investment, modernisation renewal. It all takes time and money. Ask Man U Spurs Chelski. Not instant pudding, support the team or find another. Plenty of fans would love to have a season book.
Off to my scratcher so won’t be able to respond. There has got to be a better way.
again – now read this – i dont condone st andrews but understand why it happened
the balaclavas were worn to avoid identification not for intimidation
that said, if the board knew it was going to happen, they probably already have the names
the collectiove did it, the board knew about it and now we’ll have the stadium just like last year
genius on both parts, arrogance being just one reason it happened
did we disrupt players too ? genuine question….
TAURANGABHOY on 5TH OCTOBER 2026 8:43 AM
Thanks for the reply, safe to say your are obsessed with the fanbase and certain sections of the fanbase, you can’t take a macro view of why the toxicity around the club is happening
I only ever Post/speak on behalf of myself, they are my views, I don’t pretend to speak on behalf of anyone else or group, certainly not on behalf of the vast majority of people, that is arrogance of another class, I never said that Dermot can be “forced” to change staff, that’s in your head not mine, I have no answer or idea how to as you put it “force” Dermot to do anything, I never said the “fans” don’t back DD, once again you are projecting your irrational dislike of the Celtic fanbase in your head onto me, if you want to quote me at least do it accurately
All the issues that I asked for you to comment on or go into detail with your thoughts ideas on how to resolve the issues affecting the state of the club now, you have no idea, no answer apart from the fanbase ZZZZZZZ
Dermot is the majority share owner, not the majority owner
BTW I renewed my S/T and I speak only for myself, as Celtic was a gift from Grandfather then Dad then to me, Celtic born in St Marys in the Calton 1888 still going and alive because the fanbase have guaranteed their survival, I was born in the East end of Glasgow, I go to support my team on the pitch
Celtic, Celtic that’s the team for me
Greenpinata
Belter coming from you farting out Blairs success
while omitting 1 000 000 Iraqi dead.
I know the 4 corners is not imaginary i am there nearly every day at night.
What is not imaginary is you posting and demonizing and painting my city as some form of violent update on “no mean city” when I defended the city you farted i had an agenda.
As I said type it and forget it,bolt! when asked what agenda I had ..nowt to do wi Balaclavas!
TAURANGABHOY
Have you decided there was a breach of peace or have Police Scotland ? Because if it’s you, that only counts in your own head.
Taurangabhoy on 5th October 2026 7:43 am
So you where do you sit An Tearman on Bakaclavas, without the deflection.
I never sit on a balaclava,I find them really handy on the hill,I have 3 which covers the menace of winter mountaineering,first is very light,stretch,great in high winds.2nd is a synthetic man made fabric with toggle to tighten,used as a layer system with first gives good protection eliminating the torrid menace of freezing rain and Hail.my 3rd Balaclavea is a dachstein balaclava slips on over 1&2,with goggles keep me sealed and cosy toddling bout in artic conditions especially as part of a layered system.
Jeez this my 4th essay on Balaclavas,on various sites over 2 days,totally functional and non threatening,look more daft than threatening in fact.
SumdimightdieCsc
The Turks make lovely baklava. Wouldn’t want one stuck to ma heid though.
I never ever thought as ma maw stuck my first balaclava oan ma heid in 1961, that 65 years later it would be a major discussion point on a Celtic fans forum, por cierto.
Por Cierto on 5th October 2026 1:08 pm
I never ever thought as ma maw stuck my first balaclava oan ma heid in 1961, that 65 years later it would be a major discussion point on a Celtic fans forum, por cierto.
*as a wee bhoy who due tae poor health and spending many a school day up at Yorkhill’s historic Children’s Hospital had his first full year at school when I was in the quali and grew up and out the way fae the wee loddie that my da threatened tae send me away tae be a jockey I had mine stuck on my heid in 1953.