I’ve done my best to avoid the ridiculous summer hype from across the city, which appears as regularly as rain during the Fair. Ex-Celt Kenny Miller and poor old Barry Ferguson are wheeled out for their hot takes on how Celtic are in trouble this time, with all the accuracy of a stopped clock.
Their Olympic sized egos took a humbling last night; maybe Mick isn’t quite the Svengali they’d hoped. I know we keep winning (and in style) but we should always learn from the complacency of others.
For me, the biggest win of the summer is the new deals for Kyogo, Maeda and McGregor. I am excited about the five new arrivals, but so far, they mean nothing. All we know is that we paid the asking price on each occasion to get them in early, as they were each high on the target list. None are here because they were on frees and we had squad gaps to fill.
There are still worries ahead of this season. Domestically, we will face a direct opponent that is recruiting height and muscle to match our skill and style, a modern take on the Jimmy Johnstone – John Greig battles that so defined the Celtic and Rangers era.
Europe is far more concerning. You can definitively say we are not ready to compete for the heights achieved under Gordon Strachan in the Champions League. Ponder that for a moment. We will certainly compete for third spot in the group; don’t bet on a positive outcome, though. Our own Greek tragedy could be a couple of months away.
195 Comments- Pages:
- «
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- 6
- »
The Old Fenian Gun
https://youtu.be/0C0dO4zCI5w
Vatican Live 🇻🇦
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=C3a7h8MWK2w&pp=ygUSdmF0aWNhbiBtZWRpYSBsaXZl
Good Morning Celts – Grand Day To Be A Tim…
CELTIC40ME @ 10:09 PM,
Yes, we have many U23s augmented by the five summer transfers and five “B” team squad members that BR seems to have taken an extra interest in.
They join the five U23 that are there or there abouts in the first team squad; Kobayashi, Bernabei, O’Riley, Abada and Oh.
That’s a lot of potential no doubt.
Of course are correct, Brendan Rodgers will be looking at all the players he has and assessing where they are.
He will be looking very intensely at player development, some fast tracked like Abada and Newrocki to be significant first team players now.
Interesting that he has brought Jack Lyons back in to help with that, it’s obviously key.
We do though need more experience and quality in and you are right we do have time but a lot to do within that time.
Hail Hail
TURKEYBHOY @ 9:19 PM,
It sounds to me far from the case, Greg Taylor must have won over the vast majority of his doubters with his development and performances.
Yet you must put it into context, Boli Bolingoli was brought in as Kieran’s replacement (I Know) and Greg was his back up.
He made the left back position his own.
Bernabei was brought in to be our number one left back and Greg still kept the position by his dedication, application and merit.
Still, we are a far cry from the KT days and we need to improve at left back, there should definitely be a prominent place in this squad for Greg though.
Hail Hail
Hello again all you young rebels
Again, another post I feel I need to respond to, despite log ins
and a recurring problem of some type of ad telling me to rotate
my device whilst blacking out my screen.
To be honest, I’m too tired after a day of work down our local
soccer club to be bothered.
But after a wee look in and some of the quality posters have
given us their wisdom, I do make an effort to read through.
And Lo and behold a post comes on that makes you so proud of
this dear green place.
PAMELA
My goodness that post made me well up, your dad was a special
bhoy, but you don’t need me to tell you that.
So special he will be honoured as our update nom de plume, and
forever remembered.
Well done Mod.
RIP Ronnie
Hopefully I’ll get the time to sort out laptop probs, might need
wee Grace to guide me through though, but just like a few before
me, General McCarthur, Big Arnie, and the bold Brendan,
“ I’ll be back “
H H. Mick
BURNLEY78 @ 9:56 PM
Timbhoy
It may have escaped your notice but Celtic has signed 5 players to complement. The 4 we signed in the winter window. In that period 2 first team players have left us. At least 2 of those signed would be expected to be regular first team players. The other 3 could be eased into the team over time.
We may have one or two others to come. This iis on top of and incredibly strong season when we won a treble.
As it stands we will be much stronger than a year ago.
Well, it’s a stretch to say we are much stronger than a year ago.
It’s not two first team players that left during that period, it was actually five.
Juranovic
Giakoumakis
Jenz
Jota
Mooy
All decent first team players, as it stands only Alister Johnston and Maik Nawrocki look like improvements and then only marginally.
Although we did have a great domestic season and we won a world record treble, it has to be said our domestic opposition wasn’t up to much.
No disrespect to Ange, who did a great job under the circumstances but we were lacking while up against the quality teams we met in European competition.
You say we may have one or two others to come.
For me that won’t cut it, no mibees, three quality, experienced first team players, with the necessary physicality, technical ability and tactical awareness to make a difference.
Hail Hail
Hello – MELBOURNE MICK @ 6:36 AM,
Great to see you on.
It was indeed an incredibly touching post from GG’s daughter, Pamela.
Do you remember his grandson was with the Celtic development team?
Hail Hail
Good morning from a greyish North Staffs.
Pamela – your dad would be proud of your post – God bless you and your family.
I see Hibs are sponsored by bevvy.com 😁
Mon the Hibees. 😂
Good morning Pamela,
Glad you managed to log on and post a fitting tribute to Ronnie.
As has been posted Ronnie was well respected and will be missed on CQN.
Until we meet again…
Keep the Faith!
Hail Hail!
CHAIRBHOY on 28TH JULY 2023 6:20 AM
Some work but not a lot. Plenty of time
CHAIRBHOY
Didn’t you also tell us all about how we’ve now got a better manager than last season? Isn’t that an improvement?
CELTIC40ME @ 9:19 AM,
Well yes, what my point was aimed at, was the evolution of the squad, that should be an ongoing constant.
Ange was the right man at the right time, no doubts yet his abrupt departure meant a rethink.
Replacing Ange with Brendan Rodgers and Glen Driscoll is an improvement and more importantly the right team at the right time, they have worked at a higher level and have more European experience (albeit with mixed results).
So overall we are in a better place as long as we can see the real need to improve and evolve the squad.
As you say, we have time and for me we are on the right track.
Hail Hail
, Pamela,
Many thanks and best wishes.
We all know you have so much going on , so your heartening post is very much appreciated.
I hope you can tune in during the live updates at some point as we all remember your dad fondly.
Cheers, thanks and HH to yourself and the whole family.
LENNYBHOY @ 8:41 AM,
Good to hear from you, though obviously in such sad circumstances.
Don’t worry if you don’t wish to answer but I had a teacher called Mr Docherty at St Andrew’s – was GG from the same family?
Hail Hail
The Celtic supporter Ronnie ,did he sit in the front of the main stand behind the home dugout,commenting to the partly blind supporters
CHAIRBHOY on 28TH JULY 2023 9:28 AM
I’m not sure why you seem determined to be so worried about it then. Or make others worried.
We’ve already spent €14m on evolving a squad that won a treble last season. We’ve made a signing im what you described as a key area. You’ve got your man in charge, who should be an improvement domestically and in Europe.
We have time, money and a manager assessing what he has already in the squad
While an improvement on Greg Taylor would be nice we absolutely don’t need a better left back than him
He was an important part of our treble winning team. At no point over the last season did anyone say we need a new left back
CHAIRBHOY
Doesn’t Brendan improve players as well? You don’t seem to have factored that into things.
Maybe Greg falls into that category?
CELTIC40ME on 28TH JULY 2023 10:13 AM
We won a treble last year.
AND
Greg Taylor was terrific as part of that team.
AND
We now have ambitions to kick on and make a mark in Europe.
AND
Improving our LB to fit the template of the new boss & make us more robust defensively would make sense.
SO,
We need a better LB to complement the team. Bit of ambition will mean some old heroes will drop to the bench or leave. That’s progress. Nothing to do with taking a pop at GT. Finances allowing I could replace his name with any in the squad but that one, in Rodgers 1.0, given what he needs in that position, looks a gimme.
HH
Greg Taylor played in 37 domestic fixtures last season, winning 34, drawing twice and losing once
BIG WAVY on 28TH JULY 2023 10:29 AM
We don’t need one. Greg Taylor is good enough, it’s nothing to do with sticking up for heroes and wee guys. It’s just looking at results and performances from last season and factoring his age, 25, his experience at the highest level and that he has improvement still in him, hopefully with the help of our new manager
Our European campaign threw up many more material issues than our left back if I remember rightly.
It’s a question of “need”. Improving is important but that doesn’t mean you discard players who are good enough. I would like a better left back, of course, but GT is also good enough that we don’t “need” better
It’s the same every summer. We identify areas that we could improve in and suddenly we “need” replacements. Like players that have won every trophy available, went on record-breaking winning runs suddenly aren’t good enough. And if we don’t get them then we’re somehow weaker.
To improve on Greg Taylor will cost a fair few quid it means less money in more crucial areas. Save the money and spend it on matchwinners.
CELTIC40ME…
Yes, all you say has merit and futureproofing the squad is important.
Greg has done great, he has improved, can BR make him better? Maybe, we’ll see, but he’s got lots of self belief and has made great strides in technique and physicality, his managers seem to really believe in him.
Yet the fact is Celtic rarely come under sustained, pressure and offense from the opposition, when we do we are found wanting.
We have written these games off in the past, although I disagreed with this approach there was logic in it…
The money we would need to spend to be competitive would equate to the extra money coming in and that was only if we were successful, if we failed to secure European group stage football for instance then we would be losing money.
The “gamble” was regarded as not worth it, a great example Rangers in the 2011/12 season.
The world has changed in the last decade, now there is a real need to be competitive at the European level or fall even further behind.
Also the value of the money coming in from a guaranteed UCL group stage run has improved and the more results you get the more money and co-eff points you get.
If we didn’t invest in the team a decade ago, we could go to Europe and do our best with little or no expectations, it didn’t effect our financial stability nor our domestic status.
Win the league, maybe a double…
These days if we are going to sit on our hands the Club from Ibrox will be more than happy to take our place.
So domestic competition
Extra financial and co-eff rewards
Kudos to remain a significant world player as a football club
Are all at stake if we fail to properly invest.
Last seasons UCL was proof of that.
Hail Hail
“It’s a question of “need”. Improving is important but that doesn’t mean you discard players who are good enough. I would like a better left back, of course, but GT is also good enough that we don’t “need” better”
– That makes no sense at all. Domestically GT is fine. We attack 90% of the time. His game isn’t exposed & he stepped up to the inverted role fantsticlly. He also had no pressure put on him by Bernie being a bit of an odd signing.
We’re not building for domestic.
Europe. Look back at Bodo Glimt for GT’s natural stature as a failing and his weaker defensive skills too.
We need to be more robust in Europe to just stay in games, sneek a point against a pot 1 or 2 at best. We need a keeper who can deliver Forster-like performances and a better ‘defender’ at LB.
HH
I think we need a bit more height in the team,which would go against GT,who is the most improved player in the squad
Big Wavy
My recollections are you were never a fan of Taylor.Not just you,a good few.My problem is that,you continually,along with others target Taylor to be replaced,as we need better for Europe.If that were the criteria,we could replace the whole team.Its absolute nonsense,and just a cover for an agenda against a player,you and others,have never taken to.Nothing in the players performances,which have been outstanding,suggest he would be some kind of weak link in Europe,but the theory gets
repeated every time.Apart from his excellent play,he is also a standout in the diressing room,immensely popular with the players,and the big bonus for me,hated by the scum for the way he has embraced our cub.
If everyone had the heart of Taylor maybe we would do better in Europe.
BIG WAVY on 28TH JULY 2023 10:53 AM
Our failings against Bodo Glimt weren’t down to GT. He didn’t even play in one of the games. Tactically it was Ange’s worst two games, not helped by an immobile and unathletic midfield. Biton & Rogic, Rogic and O’Riley weren’t able to cope with the running from BD
By your argument all of the team aren’t good enough. In the two crucial games against Shakhtar Jura got absolutely roasted, in the other games our finishing wasn’t good enough and our tactics, according to received wisdom were too naive. So the manager, the strikers and everyone else basically. So why does GT get singled out?
Our European exits were down to not putting the ball in the net.
Our chances to goal ratio was dismal.
HH.
Greg Taylor’s getting it in the neck for games he didn’t even play in
CHAIRBHOY on 28TH JULY 2023 10:52 AM
Did you read what Brendan said about our business model a couple of days ago? I don’t think you and him are thinking along similar lines
Bada,
We will have,AJ,CCV,Navrocki or Carl,plus a very tall Hyun..I never see,Robertson at Liverpool,or playing for Scotland hit with this,too small theory.Some of the greatest full backs in history were small.Giants like,Carlos,Alba,Mc Grain,Robertson.There are teams queueing up for our tiny ex RB at the moment.
Sorry this does not wash with me.Its an agenda that’s been going since Taylor signed.Can be denied ll they want,but it was on these pages from the start.
Interesting focus this morning on Greg Taylor.
Happy to concede I’ve posted previously about upgrading this position.
When KT left, Neil did something I’ve seen many managers do over many years and have simply never understood.
He replaced a departing really great player with two potentially quite good players in that position. (Greg & Boli)
Greg has made it his own. Respect.
IMHO
The improvement in his tactical understanding and leadership has been terrific.
He is sound technically.
My concern has always been around his size and physicality.
If he can add some (quite a lot actually) physical power?
… he will move onto the next level.
New GK, LB and replacements for Jota and Mooy still required.
As it stands the starting 11 is still weaker than when season ended.
Taylor is the new James Forrest for many.No matter how many important Cup,and European goals,his fantastic goals and assists record,his haul of medals,putting him right up there to legend status,so many still don’t rate him.I only how future generations of fans are kinder,when they are looking back.
St Tams,
And you know this how?.Obviously you have inside knowledge on our new winger,our 2 new midfielder,one a holding Mid,which we have not had since Broony.Another CH,but we are weaker ?
I will bow to your seemingly great knowledge of our new players,and agree with you.We are in dire straights.
Remind me to get back to you as the season progresses.