He pushed the covid vaccine and for people being banned from society, losing their jobs, etc, etc, if they even asked what was in this vaccine that makes a lot of people very ill soon after getting it.
I hope it didn’t blow back on him.
Paul The Spark on
Kev is a tit
The Blogger Formerly Known As GM on
!!BADA BING!! on 21ST SEPTEMBER 2025 9:57 PM
GM-you must be happy with the Board and the way the Club is run?
This is an amazing comment that conflates someone questioning the point of holding up bits of paper for a minute, then scrunching them up and throwing them on to the pitch with being “happy with the Board and the way the Club is run”.
timmy7_noted on
Kev, you are a wee weirdo. Been outside recently?
Was it the Blantyre mini man butcher’s apron celebration this weekend?
Prestonpans bhoys on
The Blogger Formerly Known As GM on 21st September 2025 8:57 pm
TM – cheers. I didn’t realise the HCTS covered European tournaments, I thought it was only domestic competitions
I explained to you hours ago how HCTS op-out works. There may be non ST individuals who will take the opportunity of getting tickets which normally would not be available to them, good they can see the Hoops.
Bear in mind disillusioned celtic fans with this board are not exclusively ST holders 🙃
ADVERTISEMENT
Tictastic on
Just ignore the boring barsteward…he’s sad…he’s got nothing else….
kajagoogoo on
timmy7_noted on 21st September 2025 10:19 pm
Kev, you are a wee weirdo. Been outside recently?
Was it the Blantyre mini man butcher’s apron celebration this weekend?
……..
Seems like it was the hoomza useless floot bawn in an empty hospital, during the plandemic.
Had we made the £5.2 million bid before the Kairat tie, I think we’d be playing in the CL this season. Let’s learn.
I think it might be a bit more complex than that.
Who knows when they decided they’d cash in and when his wishes changed? Who knows when he decided to push for the move? Who long it took to change their minds?
Maybe it all came after they went out of the conference league, four days before we had to register a player for the knock out tie?
He looks good, he look a like the sort of player who will do well for us, but he’s played against Kilmarnock and Partick Thistle so far. To expect him to walk off the plane, take Maedas place in the team and win us a game in the qualifiers is expecting quite a lot.
I think youre being a bit simple
celtic40me on
Simplistic even
celtic40me on
I do also think we could have had anyone on the wings for those two games and still not scored, never mind a guy with his pedigree who wouldnt have had time to say Hej to his teammates
ADVERTISEMENT
Prestonpans bhoys on
celtic40me on 21st September 2025 11:03 pm
I can see where you are coming from but there was no service to the centre fowards. He may, if available to purchase, made the difference.
Personally those two games bored me to death, made the tea for the next day during it…..
Stephenbhoyboy on
The Celtic board have for years failed to prepare for vital champions league qualifiers. Examples have been highlighted but playing centremids and kids at centre back, wingers as forwards and most recently just not having enough wingers/ forwards are just a few examples. The board punt any quality players as soon as the chance arrives whilst drawing out negotiations that lead to missing out on players and/ or said players coming to late to the party.
The shite facilities around the stadium for supporters and lack of vision regards growing the club has also been of significant concern. All of which is only worsened by their apparent inability to communicate effectively with supporters, and in some cases simply being obnoxious when they do speak.
The above failings have been exposed on numerous occasions. The folk that protest against the board are simply a reflection of their frustration about continued failures on and off the pitch. Those who point to having 77 million in the bank (technically 86 million as there is a another 9 million owed to the club vs what club owes out) as an example of success need to ask themselves, how many businesses and/ or wealthy folk have millions in an account collecting interest under inflation? The answer is none, money is invested to secure better returns.
We all want celtic to be the best they can be. We can continue on our current path or we can change things up. It does not need to be complete change or radical change but it cant be tokanistic change.
Sionnaigh on
The noise mongerers just don’t get it. Celtic ain’t just for Christmas, dominance ad infinitum. Ave Ave
kajagoogoo on
FSR only applies in serious, legal countries, were the footballing authorities don’t allow [fake] clubs to participate in their associations.
That can’t be claimed in Scottish football were Sevco were smuggled off of the back of a lorry, and presented as a different club entirely, and every club in SPL level Scottish football accepted this fraud without blinking a side-clicking-eye-lid.
Scottish football leaders are officially bandits, gangsters, mafia, and other flavours of Tories like PLC boards.
So take your fake rule book pish to blogs full of double speaking fearties of season ticket boycotts, “AS CELTIC WILL DIE” they say.
Greenpinata on
The thing is, Kev Jungle does make some valid points in a sea of balderdash.
HH.
ADVERTISEMENT
Auldheid on
The Battered Bunnet on 20th September 2025 12:52 pm
Amongst other things, what the accounts demonstrate is that there are too many folk running around like their trousers are on fire.
==/====
I only just caught comments on the previous blog from others but pleased to see most got the point about FSR that I was trying to make
Income down = Players sold to raise income (Khuns sale is probably for the highest price we will get, Maeda’s departure might be next highest or maybe Alstr Johnston all to be replaced by lesser players to develop) but your post makes it abundantly clearer Celtic are a house where the ceiling has been lowering and the basement rising for years.
Only CL money and good prices on some player sales have acted like a hydraulic jack to stop the house collapsing.
Hyper wages pushed the ceiling down and lower income has slowly pushed the floor up.
The financial reality has either not been put as bluntly as you did in your post or if put, has been seen through a happy clapper filter or infected by the Pedrophobia virus.
Having said that the house can be more stabilised by sticking to the living within our means policy, but much better execution of that policy when it comes to player trading in and out, balancing football needs by being swifter to meet them but also taking the financial benefit of finding more diamonds in the dust.
The days of the Celtic I and many grew up believing in are heading for the sunset, but that does not mean a new and better day will not follow as the misconceptions that create the current divide pass with the setting of the same
sun.
Chairbhoy on
Good Morning Fholks – Grand Day To Be In The League Cup Semi Final.
Noticed a lot of talk about our UCL peers FC Brugge recently.
Awe Naw – previously of this parish did an interesting comparison that he posted on SC t’uther day…
Awe Naw – September 20, 2025 1:49 pm,
Comparing how Club Brugge and Celtic FC operate to highlight differences between them. You can draw your own conclusions. My own personal conclusion is that a fundamental change has to happen for me to financially contribute to Celtic PLC.
Anyway here goes;
Ownership & Governance
Club Brugge (Belgium)
Ownership: Privately owned by Bart Verhaeghe, who holds a majority stake.
Governance: Operates under a non-profit foundation model, with a supervisory board overseeing the club’s activities.
Key Leadership:
President: Bart Verhaeghe
CEO: Bob Madou
Managing Director Sport: Dévy Rigaux
Managing Director Professional Football: Maarten Dedobbeleer
Sports Director: Maarten Dedobbeleer
Focus: Emphasis on sporting performance, player development, and community engagement.
Celtic FC (Scotland)
Ownership: Publicly traded on the London Stock Exchange as Celtic PLC.
Governance: Operates under a public limited company model, with a board of directors and shareholders.
Key Leadership:
Chairman: Peter Lawwell
CEO: Michael Nicholson
Chief Financial Officer (CFO): Chris McKay
Senior Independent Director: Tom Allison
Independent Non-Executive Directors: Sharon Brown, Dermot Desmond, Brian Rose, Brian Wilson
Focus: Emphasis on financial performance, shareholder value, and maintaining a competitive edge in European football.
Executive Roles & Responsibilities
Club Brugge
President (Bart Verhaeghe): Oversees the strategic direction and long-term vision of the club.
CEO (Bob Madou): Manages day-to-day operations, including financial management and operational efficiency.
Managing Directors:
Sporting Operations: Dévy Rigaux handles all aspects related to the first team, youth development, and performance analytics.
Professional Football: Maarten Dedobbeleer focuses on the senior team’s performance, match preparation, and tactical planning.
Sports Director (Maarten Dedobbeleer): Leads various sporting units such as coaching staff, scouting, analysis, and sports sciences.
Celtic FC
Chairman (Peter Lawwell): Provides strategic oversight and ensures the club’s activities align with shareholder interests.
CEO (Michael Nicholson): Responsible for the club’s day-to-day operations, including financial health and implementing the board’s strategic vision.
Senior Independent Director (Tom Allison): Acts as a liaison between the board and shareholders, ensuring effective governance.
Independent Non-Executive Directors: Provide independent judgment and oversight on various aspects of the club’s operations.
Ownership & Financial Structure
Club Brugge
Ownership Model: Privately held, allowing for more centralized decision-making.
Financial Transparency: Less public disclosure due to private ownership.
Revenue Sources: Primarily from matchday income, sponsorships, and player transfers.
Celtic FC
Ownership Model: Publicly traded, with shares listed on the London Stock Exchange.
Financial Transparency: Required to publish detailed financial reports, providing transparency to shareholders.
Revenue Sources: Diverse income streams including matchday revenue, broadcasting rights, sponsorships, and player trading.
Comparison
Both clubs operate within different governance frameworks, with Club Brugge emphasizing a centralized, private ownership model focused on sporting success and community ties.
In contrast, Celtic FC operates as a publicly traded entity, balancing the demands of financial performance with the expectations of shareholders and supporters.
Hail Hail
Chairbhoy on
Auldheid @ 3:50 am,
Here is a response mainly taken from my response to you et al on SC.
Yet let me add, it hopefully will help nullify your scaremongering in your reply to TBB.
We have for a long time now being selling HVPs.
Did we know when Ange left how much we would get for Jota?
When BR came did we know how much we’d get for Matt O’Riley?
When we bought Kuhn did we know how much profit he would get us in 18 months?
As long as we have good recruitment and UCL football we will have HVPs…
Now to tackle the subject in general.
We have a dozen years of the Peter Lawwell recruitment strategy, it was originally a Scottish football emulation of the Yanks’ Baseball moneyball approach.
We have lots of data and lots of examples of what works and what doesn’t, it was eventually honed as a working model after Peter Lawwell left as CEO, Ange, working firstly with Dominic McKay, then with Micheal Nicholson got our recruitment working well.
Interestingly enough when PL came back as Chairman, the recruitment approach changed but when he wrote about our official strategy in the 2023 annual report this is what he said…
”Our successfully proven strategy has delivered stability and footballing success over many years and remains the same. We must balance the signing of players that can be developed and sold when conditions are optimal alongside the need to sign players who are able to make an immediate impact and deliver footballing success. The execution of this strategy is increasingly challenging owing to wage and transfer inflation, but this formula has underpinned both our footballing success and financial stability over a number of years now and it is vital that we adhere to it.”
Peter T Lawwell, Chairman
September 18, 2023
So in the debate about selling high, buying low, or Rodgers likes oven ready players, or the FSR impacts our recruitment strategy – these are all partial arguments.
The strategy has always been a mix of “oven-ready” players and “development” players.
The Club has always needed financial stability.
Celtic knew that transfer inflation and wage inflation were going to be a challenge going forward.
The Board prefer development players because it’s a business strategy; they’re cheaper, they’re prepared to gamble and any losses can be borne by the football club’s strong cash flow position, any gains make the Board look like shrewd operators.
The football coaches and managers prefer oven ready players who can impact the team with the necessary experience and ability in the positions that they need covered or improved.
It doesn’t have to be a battle of wills though and when we have implemented the mix approach well, under Ange and in 2024 under BR, the team has improved, the results have improved and financial stability maintained.
I’ve broken down to Academy players, bought in development players, progressing players, loanees, bought in first team players.
Doohan – Academy/Free
Murray – Academy
Ralston – Academy
Donovan – Academy
Tierney – Academy/Free
McGregor – Academy
Forrest – Academy
Development Players…
Inamura – 1 mn
Osmand – Compensation
Yamada – 1.5 mn
Kenny – 150K
Players progressing down our development path
Sinisalo – 1 mn
Scales – 500K
Paulo Bernardo – 3.5 mn
Engels – 11 mn
HJ Yang – 2 mn
Loanees
Simpson-Pusey
Sarrachi
Bought in First team players
Schmeichel – Free
A. Johnston – 3 mn
Trusty – 6 mn
Carter-Vickers – 6 mn
Hatate – 1.5 mn
McCowan – 1 mn
Nygren – 1.5 mn
Jota – 9 mn
Maeda – 1.5 mn
Tounekti – 5.5 mn
Balikwisha – 5 mn
Iheanacho – Free
It is very clear, especially when you take into account we sell HVPs
MF Matt O’Riley
FW. Kyogo
FW. Nic Kuhn
FW. Adam Idah
That since Brendan Rodgers returned well over thirty first team squad players have left and that the team and recruitment has been managed within the parameters of our stated strategy.
The challenges of wage and transfer inflation as highlighted two years ago has been met by more players leaving the squad, than was added, these players have brought in well over £100mn in transfer fees.
We currently have a squad we paid £ 54 mn for and is valued at over £ 130 mn, with well over £ 77.3 in the bank and making £ 45.7 mn before tax in profits last season.
So look back “our successful proven strategy” and the challenges highlighted two years ago by our Chairman and you will find the football department has not only stuck to the strategy but met and bested the challenges.
The Board by it’s dogmatic attachment to their moneyball business model and the Executive who have been incompetent in executing the recruitment strategy are where the current issues lie.
Do we need to get better at identifying recruits – yes, is diligence necessary on the financial stability front – always, yet this is normal business as usual.
Any criticism of player identification or scaremongering on FSR compliance is simply hyperbolic smoke and mirrors to deflect away from a dysfunctional Boardroom
Well done to our CEO for not only understanding this but making a commitment to improve.
Our objective each year is to compete in the Champions League. Unfortunately this season, we suffered a loss on penaltiesin the tie against Kairat Almaty, which resulted in Europa League entry instead. As a Board, we take responsibility for thefailure to achieve that key objective and commit to improving going forward.We now look ahead to our Europa Leaguefixtures against FK Crvena Zvezda, SC Braga, SK Sturm Graz, FC Midtjylland, Feyenoord, AS Roma, Bologna FC 1909 and FCUtrecht, where we will hope to perform strongly and progress in the competition
Micheal Nicholson CEO
That is the sort of communication and approach we need to improve the situation, not scaremongering like the last statement did.
Hail Hail
An Dún on
Celtic40me
Who knows when they decided they’d cash in
///
I do.
They decided to cash in when we made them a £5.2 million offer.
Chairbhoy on
An Dún @ 6:19 am,
These excuses really won’t wash…
It is up to the Executive, supported by the Board to make this recruitment happen.
Kyogo went in the January and was not replaced.
A not fully fit Jota came in on the wing, did well but was long term injured.
We needed a quality striker and a winger to replace those two.
In the summer, in terms of first team players, Taylor, Kuhn, Yang, Idah, Meada were scheduled to leave.
That’s seven first team players that needed replacing, mostly in forward positions, and we needed more quality in midfield and defence as was evident from our exertions in 2024.
Bringing in most of the ten players needed in a timely manner was key.
Low balling Clubs through the summer and not caring if players were in or not, in a timely manner or not was just totally unacceptable.
Waiting for a month to pay the money required for Tounekti was crazy.
Not the worst, actually not getting a striker in at all and selling Idah was the worst.
How anyone can defend that window is nonsensical.
Hail Hail
ADVERTISEMENT
Back to Basics - Glass Half Full on
Good morning CQN.
Grand day to be a tim.
Mid September.
Frost !
Have a good one.
Back to Basics - Glass Half Full on
“How anyone can defend that window is nonsensical”
Agree Chairbhoy.
I’ve just not seen anyone defending it.
Back to Basics - Glass Half Full on
The transfer window just closed looks like a very bad organisational failure compounded by heel digging and positioning.
Ridiculous that it came to that.
The catalyst for the angst was defeat to #318 in the rankings.
For which several key figures at Celtic should take responsibility.
So far, two have done so publicly. CEO and manager.
PS – the CEO’s statement on the matter didn’t cut much ice with me.
When he explains HOW he is (and then the organisation are) going to improve … I’ll sit up.
As for his hopes?
No disrespect intended but big deal.
I hope for world peace.
The Blogger Formerly Known As GM on
You learn something new every day and it’s not even 8 oclock.
Courtesy of Kev (😯) I now know the SFA are responsible for implementing and ensuring compliance with FSR rules in Scotland.
Someone tell me this is wrong.
Bhoys Town on
eratic on 21st September 2025 10:07 pm
Just thought it was a bit pathetic considering our most promising player was using that wing …
maybe they thought it was better to hamper our promising players playing football on what was already a difficult pitch to play on…..
Brainless morons !!
—–
Totally agree. So much for back the players, criticise the Board. This was straight out of the Govan playbook from the day before. At least we now know what the agenda is – draw as much attention to ourselves as possible. Toddlers for Change.
ADVERTISEMENT
Burnley78 on
Greenpinata 2.07
Good post. Really true and easy to dismiss without thinking if that is ones mindset.
Chairbhoy on
Greenpinata @ 2:07 am,
“The thing is, Kev Jungle does make some valid points in a sea of balderdash.”
True…
Interestingly, his valid points seems to be the stuff I agree with and the balderdash is the stuff I don’t agree with;))
Hail Hail
Burnley78 on
Bhoys Town
Absolutely spot on.
No clarity over objectives
No vison
No plan
No idea
Wound up by a self egotistical party who simply wants to deflect from a dire performance in every recent major game. Except a backs to the wall in Munich which we ultimately lost anyway.
5 Rangers games without a win
Young Bhoys last minute against a very poor side already eliminated and just back from winter break
Aberdeen Cup Final shambles
Kairat Almaty
All games where we had advantage of a far superior squad and against weaker opponents.
Weirdly our manager actually takes zero blame and responsibility ???
But his faithful sheep like following jump onto a bandwagon and give the media all they need to destabilise Celtic.
Michael Stewart was a disgrace yesterday.
Back to Basics - Glass Half Full on
Bhoys Town @ 7:57am
“Toddlers for Change”
🤣🤣🤣
… followed by Calamity Jane style realisation
“Come to think of it, that ain’t so funny”
🤔🤔🤔
Chairbhoy on
Back to Basics – Glass Half Full @ 7:13, 7:20 am,
Hiya….
Well you are lucky.
You have not heard Clubs won’t let players go, good players don’t want to come to Scotland, the player was off piste… his mammy was worried about him.
For me the Executive is an unknown
Yet the Board’s first mea culpa in twenty years is huge for me.
The Boardroom as a whole needs gutting though, that’s for smarter fholk than I.
With you on the commitment to do better.
Could be my OpTIMismtic outlook but I’m more…
…we’ll see
Than I won’t hold my breath.
Hail Hail
ADVERTISEMENT
Taurangabhoy on
Stop it Auldheid, this sensible argument will never catch on. Is there a vaccine for the Pedrovirus 😉. We were lucky with some of Ange P recruits, mainly from the Japanese bhoys, who he had seen first hand. We will get lucky again, pick the right development players, the laws of nature say that some years we will hit gold other years brass. Thank god we have a proffesional board in charge and not a bunch of old Glasgow university trendy lefties playing at committee . Wolfe Smith for CEO would rip my knitting. No doubt pistol Pete will leave on his own terms soon, and like the bunnet who was hated in his own time, he will be better thought of looking in the back mirror.
I wonder if Mr TAVPEN is somewhat concerned ( Bricking it ? ) at the thought of facing ” SEB THE REB” at Hamdump ?
LOL
HH.
Chairbhoy on
Taurangabhoy @ 8:24 am,
Yes, some folk like Auldheid and your immunity to Pedrovirus is very impressive.
Me – I’m sick as a dog…
Seriously, if the man had left ten years ago he may well have reached legend status by now.
Hail Hail
Taurangabhoy on
Thank you Chairbhoy, not usually mentioned in such exalted company but I will take it in the good grace that it was given. Hopefully we will all be over any ill effects on 1/2 November at Hampdon. Hail Hail.
ADVERTISEMENT
lionroars67 on
Good Morning CQN
If Celtic co-opted Big Jimmy onto the board (stay with me )
Allowed him a reasonable portion of the spare cash given his success at the bookies
Boom we could be billionaires next year (only fools and horses)
360 Comments- Pages:
- «
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- 6
- 7
- 8
- 9
- 10
- »
!!Bada Bing!! on 21st September 2025 9:39 pm
John Stapleton RIP,great journalist and presenter
………
He pushed the covid vaccine and for people being banned from society, losing their jobs, etc, etc, if they even asked what was in this vaccine that makes a lot of people very ill soon after getting it.
I hope it didn’t blow back on him.
Kev is a tit
!!BADA BING!! on 21ST SEPTEMBER 2025 9:57 PM
GM-you must be happy with the Board and the way the Club is run?
This is an amazing comment that conflates someone questioning the point of holding up bits of paper for a minute, then scrunching them up and throwing them on to the pitch with being “happy with the Board and the way the Club is run”.
Kev, you are a wee weirdo. Been outside recently?
Was it the Blantyre mini man butcher’s apron celebration this weekend?
The Blogger Formerly Known As GM on 21st September 2025 8:57 pm
TM – cheers. I didn’t realise the HCTS covered European tournaments, I thought it was only domestic competitions
I explained to you hours ago how HCTS op-out works. There may be non ST individuals who will take the opportunity of getting tickets which normally would not be available to them, good they can see the Hoops.
Bear in mind disillusioned celtic fans with this board are not exclusively ST holders 🙃
Just ignore the boring barsteward…he’s sad…he’s got nothing else….
timmy7_noted on 21st September 2025 10:19 pm
Kev, you are a wee weirdo. Been outside recently?
Was it the Blantyre mini man butcher’s apron celebration this weekend?
……..
Seems like it was the hoomza useless floot bawn in an empty hospital, during the plandemic.
https://video.twimg.com/tweet_video/G07a8ojW0AATSe7.mp4
AN DÚN on 21ST SEPTEMBER 2025 10:02 PM
Had we made the £5.2 million bid before the Kairat tie, I think we’d be playing in the CL this season. Let’s learn.
I think it might be a bit more complex than that.
Who knows when they decided they’d cash in and when his wishes changed? Who knows when he decided to push for the move? Who long it took to change their minds?
Maybe it all came after they went out of the conference league, four days before we had to register a player for the knock out tie?
He looks good, he look a like the sort of player who will do well for us, but he’s played against Kilmarnock and Partick Thistle so far. To expect him to walk off the plane, take Maedas place in the team and win us a game in the qualifiers is expecting quite a lot.
I think youre being a bit simple
Simplistic even
I do also think we could have had anyone on the wings for those two games and still not scored, never mind a guy with his pedigree who wouldnt have had time to say Hej to his teammates
celtic40me on 21st September 2025 11:03 pm
I can see where you are coming from but there was no service to the centre fowards. He may, if available to purchase, made the difference.
Personally those two games bored me to death, made the tea for the next day during it…..
The Celtic board have for years failed to prepare for vital champions league qualifiers. Examples have been highlighted but playing centremids and kids at centre back, wingers as forwards and most recently just not having enough wingers/ forwards are just a few examples. The board punt any quality players as soon as the chance arrives whilst drawing out negotiations that lead to missing out on players and/ or said players coming to late to the party.
The shite facilities around the stadium for supporters and lack of vision regards growing the club has also been of significant concern. All of which is only worsened by their apparent inability to communicate effectively with supporters, and in some cases simply being obnoxious when they do speak.
The above failings have been exposed on numerous occasions. The folk that protest against the board are simply a reflection of their frustration about continued failures on and off the pitch. Those who point to having 77 million in the bank (technically 86 million as there is a another 9 million owed to the club vs what club owes out) as an example of success need to ask themselves, how many businesses and/ or wealthy folk have millions in an account collecting interest under inflation? The answer is none, money is invested to secure better returns.
We all want celtic to be the best they can be. We can continue on our current path or we can change things up. It does not need to be complete change or radical change but it cant be tokanistic change.
The noise mongerers just don’t get it. Celtic ain’t just for Christmas, dominance ad infinitum. Ave Ave
FSR only applies in serious, legal countries, were the footballing authorities don’t allow [fake] clubs to participate in their associations.
That can’t be claimed in Scottish football were Sevco were smuggled off of the back of a lorry, and presented as a different club entirely, and every club in SPL level Scottish football accepted this fraud without blinking a side-clicking-eye-lid.
Scottish football leaders are officially bandits, gangsters, mafia, and other flavours of Tories like PLC boards.
So take your fake rule book pish to blogs full of double speaking fearties of season ticket boycotts, “AS CELTIC WILL DIE” they say.
The thing is, Kev Jungle does make some valid points in a sea of balderdash.
HH.
The Battered Bunnet on 20th September 2025 12:52 pm
Amongst other things, what the accounts demonstrate is that there are too many folk running around like their trousers are on fire.
==/====
I only just caught comments on the previous blog from others but pleased to see most got the point about FSR that I was trying to make
Income down = Players sold to raise income (Khuns sale is probably for the highest price we will get, Maeda’s departure might be next highest or maybe Alstr Johnston all to be replaced by lesser players to develop) but your post makes it abundantly clearer Celtic are a house where the ceiling has been lowering and the basement rising for years.
Only CL money and good prices on some player sales have acted like a hydraulic jack to stop the house collapsing.
Hyper wages pushed the ceiling down and lower income has slowly pushed the floor up.
The financial reality has either not been put as bluntly as you did in your post or if put, has been seen through a happy clapper filter or infected by the Pedrophobia virus.
Having said that the house can be more stabilised by sticking to the living within our means policy, but much better execution of that policy when it comes to player trading in and out, balancing football needs by being swifter to meet them but also taking the financial benefit of finding more diamonds in the dust.
The days of the Celtic I and many grew up believing in are heading for the sunset, but that does not mean a new and better day will not follow as the misconceptions that create the current divide pass with the setting of the same
sun.
Good Morning Fholks – Grand Day To Be In The League Cup Semi Final.
Noticed a lot of talk about our UCL peers FC Brugge recently.
Awe Naw – previously of this parish did an interesting comparison that he posted on SC t’uther day…
Awe Naw – September 20, 2025 1:49 pm,
Comparing how Club Brugge and Celtic FC operate to highlight differences between them. You can draw your own conclusions. My own personal conclusion is that a fundamental change has to happen for me to financially contribute to Celtic PLC.
Anyway here goes;
Ownership & Governance
Club Brugge (Belgium)
Ownership: Privately owned by Bart Verhaeghe, who holds a majority stake.
Governance: Operates under a non-profit foundation model, with a supervisory board overseeing the club’s activities.
Key Leadership:
President: Bart Verhaeghe
CEO: Bob Madou
Managing Director Sport: Dévy Rigaux
Managing Director Professional Football: Maarten Dedobbeleer
Sports Director: Maarten Dedobbeleer
Focus: Emphasis on sporting performance, player development, and community engagement.
Celtic FC (Scotland)
Ownership: Publicly traded on the London Stock Exchange as Celtic PLC.
Governance: Operates under a public limited company model, with a board of directors and shareholders.
Key Leadership:
Chairman: Peter Lawwell
CEO: Michael Nicholson
Chief Financial Officer (CFO): Chris McKay
Senior Independent Director: Tom Allison
Independent Non-Executive Directors: Sharon Brown, Dermot Desmond, Brian Rose, Brian Wilson
Focus: Emphasis on financial performance, shareholder value, and maintaining a competitive edge in European football.
Executive Roles & Responsibilities
Club Brugge
President (Bart Verhaeghe): Oversees the strategic direction and long-term vision of the club.
CEO (Bob Madou): Manages day-to-day operations, including financial management and operational efficiency.
Managing Directors:
Sporting Operations: Dévy Rigaux handles all aspects related to the first team, youth development, and performance analytics.
Professional Football: Maarten Dedobbeleer focuses on the senior team’s performance, match preparation, and tactical planning.
Sports Director (Maarten Dedobbeleer): Leads various sporting units such as coaching staff, scouting, analysis, and sports sciences.
Celtic FC
Chairman (Peter Lawwell): Provides strategic oversight and ensures the club’s activities align with shareholder interests.
CEO (Michael Nicholson): Responsible for the club’s day-to-day operations, including financial health and implementing the board’s strategic vision.
CFO (Chris McKay): Oversees financial planning, risk management, and financial reporting.
Senior Independent Director (Tom Allison): Acts as a liaison between the board and shareholders, ensuring effective governance.
Independent Non-Executive Directors: Provide independent judgment and oversight on various aspects of the club’s operations.
Ownership & Financial Structure
Club Brugge
Ownership Model: Privately held, allowing for more centralized decision-making.
Financial Transparency: Less public disclosure due to private ownership.
Revenue Sources: Primarily from matchday income, sponsorships, and player transfers.
Celtic FC
Ownership Model: Publicly traded, with shares listed on the London Stock Exchange.
Financial Transparency: Required to publish detailed financial reports, providing transparency to shareholders.
Revenue Sources: Diverse income streams including matchday revenue, broadcasting rights, sponsorships, and player trading.
Comparison
Both clubs operate within different governance frameworks, with Club Brugge emphasizing a centralized, private ownership model focused on sporting success and community ties.
In contrast, Celtic FC operates as a publicly traded entity, balancing the demands of financial performance with the expectations of shareholders and supporters.
Hail Hail
Auldheid @ 3:50 am,
Here is a response mainly taken from my response to you et al on SC.
Yet let me add, it hopefully will help nullify your scaremongering in your reply to TBB.
We have for a long time now being selling HVPs.
Did we know when Ange left how much we would get for Jota?
When BR came did we know how much we’d get for Matt O’Riley?
When we bought Kuhn did we know how much profit he would get us in 18 months?
As long as we have good recruitment and UCL football we will have HVPs…
Now to tackle the subject in general.
We have a dozen years of the Peter Lawwell recruitment strategy, it was originally a Scottish football emulation of the Yanks’ Baseball moneyball approach.
We have lots of data and lots of examples of what works and what doesn’t, it was eventually honed as a working model after Peter Lawwell left as CEO, Ange, working firstly with Dominic McKay, then with Micheal Nicholson got our recruitment working well.
Interestingly enough when PL came back as Chairman, the recruitment approach changed but when he wrote about our official strategy in the 2023 annual report this is what he said…
”Our successfully proven strategy has delivered stability and footballing success over many years and remains the same. We must balance the signing of players that can be developed and sold when conditions are optimal alongside the need to sign players who are able to make an immediate impact and deliver footballing success. The execution of this strategy is increasingly challenging owing to wage and transfer inflation, but this formula has underpinned both our footballing success and financial stability over a number of years now and it is vital that we adhere to it.”
Peter T Lawwell, Chairman
September 18, 2023
So in the debate about selling high, buying low, or Rodgers likes oven ready players, or the FSR impacts our recruitment strategy – these are all partial arguments.
The strategy has always been a mix of “oven-ready” players and “development” players.
The Club has always needed financial stability.
Celtic knew that transfer inflation and wage inflation were going to be a challenge going forward.
The Board prefer development players because it’s a business strategy; they’re cheaper, they’re prepared to gamble and any losses can be borne by the football club’s strong cash flow position, any gains make the Board look like shrewd operators.
The football coaches and managers prefer oven ready players who can impact the team with the necessary experience and ability in the positions that they need covered or improved.
It doesn’t have to be a battle of wills though and when we have implemented the mix approach well, under Ange and in 2024 under BR, the team has improved, the results have improved and financial stability maintained.
I’ve broken down to Academy players, bought in development players, progressing players, loanees, bought in first team players.
Doohan – Academy/Free
Murray – Academy
Ralston – Academy
Donovan – Academy
Tierney – Academy/Free
McGregor – Academy
Forrest – Academy
Development Players…
Inamura – 1 mn
Osmand – Compensation
Yamada – 1.5 mn
Kenny – 150K
Players progressing down our development path
Sinisalo – 1 mn
Scales – 500K
Paulo Bernardo – 3.5 mn
Engels – 11 mn
HJ Yang – 2 mn
Loanees
Simpson-Pusey
Sarrachi
Bought in First team players
Schmeichel – Free
A. Johnston – 3 mn
Trusty – 6 mn
Carter-Vickers – 6 mn
Hatate – 1.5 mn
McCowan – 1 mn
Nygren – 1.5 mn
Jota – 9 mn
Maeda – 1.5 mn
Tounekti – 5.5 mn
Balikwisha – 5 mn
Iheanacho – Free
It is very clear, especially when you take into account we sell HVPs
MF Matt O’Riley
FW. Kyogo
FW. Nic Kuhn
FW. Adam Idah
That since Brendan Rodgers returned well over thirty first team squad players have left and that the team and recruitment has been managed within the parameters of our stated strategy.
The challenges of wage and transfer inflation as highlighted two years ago has been met by more players leaving the squad, than was added, these players have brought in well over £100mn in transfer fees.
We currently have a squad we paid £ 54 mn for and is valued at over £ 130 mn, with well over £ 77.3 in the bank and making £ 45.7 mn before tax in profits last season.
So look back “our successful proven strategy” and the challenges highlighted two years ago by our Chairman and you will find the football department has not only stuck to the strategy but met and bested the challenges.
The Board by it’s dogmatic attachment to their moneyball business model and the Executive who have been incompetent in executing the recruitment strategy are where the current issues lie.
Do we need to get better at identifying recruits – yes, is diligence necessary on the financial stability front – always, yet this is normal business as usual.
Any criticism of player identification or scaremongering on FSR compliance is simply hyperbolic smoke and mirrors to deflect away from a dysfunctional Boardroom
Well done to our CEO for not only understanding this but making a commitment to improve.
Our objective each year is to compete in the Champions League. Unfortunately this season, we suffered a loss on penaltiesin the tie against Kairat Almaty, which resulted in Europa League entry instead. As a Board, we take responsibility for thefailure to achieve that key objective and commit to improving going forward.We now look ahead to our Europa Leaguefixtures against FK Crvena Zvezda, SC Braga, SK Sturm Graz, FC Midtjylland, Feyenoord, AS Roma, Bologna FC 1909 and FCUtrecht, where we will hope to perform strongly and progress in the competition
Micheal Nicholson CEO
That is the sort of communication and approach we need to improve the situation, not scaremongering like the last statement did.
Hail Hail
Celtic40me
Who knows when they decided they’d cash in
///
I do.
They decided to cash in when we made them a £5.2 million offer.
An Dún @ 6:19 am,
These excuses really won’t wash…
It is up to the Executive, supported by the Board to make this recruitment happen.
Kyogo went in the January and was not replaced.
A not fully fit Jota came in on the wing, did well but was long term injured.
We needed a quality striker and a winger to replace those two.
In the summer, in terms of first team players, Taylor, Kuhn, Yang, Idah, Meada were scheduled to leave.
That’s seven first team players that needed replacing, mostly in forward positions, and we needed more quality in midfield and defence as was evident from our exertions in 2024.
Bringing in most of the ten players needed in a timely manner was key.
Low balling Clubs through the summer and not caring if players were in or not, in a timely manner or not was just totally unacceptable.
Waiting for a month to pay the money required for Tounekti was crazy.
Not the worst, actually not getting a striker in at all and selling Idah was the worst.
How anyone can defend that window is nonsensical.
Hail Hail
Good morning CQN.
Grand day to be a tim.
Mid September.
Frost !
Have a good one.
“How anyone can defend that window is nonsensical”
Agree Chairbhoy.
I’ve just not seen anyone defending it.
The transfer window just closed looks like a very bad organisational failure compounded by heel digging and positioning.
Ridiculous that it came to that.
The catalyst for the angst was defeat to #318 in the rankings.
For which several key figures at Celtic should take responsibility.
So far, two have done so publicly. CEO and manager.
PS – the CEO’s statement on the matter didn’t cut much ice with me.
When he explains HOW he is (and then the organisation are) going to improve … I’ll sit up.
As for his hopes?
No disrespect intended but big deal.
I hope for world peace.
You learn something new every day and it’s not even 8 oclock.
Courtesy of Kev (😯) I now know the SFA are responsible for implementing and ensuring compliance with FSR rules in Scotland.
Someone tell me this is wrong.
eratic on 21st September 2025 10:07 pm
Just thought it was a bit pathetic considering our most promising player was using that wing …
maybe they thought it was better to hamper our promising players playing football on what was already a difficult pitch to play on…..
Brainless morons !!
—–
Totally agree. So much for back the players, criticise the Board. This was straight out of the Govan playbook from the day before. At least we now know what the agenda is – draw as much attention to ourselves as possible. Toddlers for Change.
Greenpinata 2.07
Good post. Really true and easy to dismiss without thinking if that is ones mindset.
Greenpinata @ 2:07 am,
“The thing is, Kev Jungle does make some valid points in a sea of balderdash.”
True…
Interestingly, his valid points seems to be the stuff I agree with and the balderdash is the stuff I don’t agree with;))
Hail Hail
Bhoys Town
Absolutely spot on.
No clarity over objectives
No vison
No plan
No idea
Wound up by a self egotistical party who simply wants to deflect from a dire performance in every recent major game. Except a backs to the wall in Munich which we ultimately lost anyway.
5 Rangers games without a win
Young Bhoys last minute against a very poor side already eliminated and just back from winter break
Aberdeen Cup Final shambles
Kairat Almaty
All games where we had advantage of a far superior squad and against weaker opponents.
Weirdly our manager actually takes zero blame and responsibility ???
But his faithful sheep like following jump onto a bandwagon and give the media all they need to destabilise Celtic.
Michael Stewart was a disgrace yesterday.
Bhoys Town @ 7:57am
“Toddlers for Change”
🤣🤣🤣
… followed by Calamity Jane style realisation
“Come to think of it, that ain’t so funny”
🤔🤔🤔
Back to Basics – Glass Half Full @ 7:13, 7:20 am,
Hiya….
Well you are lucky.
You have not heard Clubs won’t let players go, good players don’t want to come to Scotland, the player was off piste… his mammy was worried about him.
For me the Executive is an unknown
Yet the Board’s first mea culpa in twenty years is huge for me.
The Boardroom as a whole needs gutting though, that’s for smarter fholk than I.
With you on the commitment to do better.
Could be my OpTIMismtic outlook but I’m more…
…we’ll see
Than I won’t hold my breath.
Hail Hail
Stop it Auldheid, this sensible argument will never catch on. Is there a vaccine for the Pedrovirus 😉. We were lucky with some of Ange P recruits, mainly from the Japanese bhoys, who he had seen first hand. We will get lucky again, pick the right development players, the laws of nature say that some years we will hit gold other years brass. Thank god we have a proffesional board in charge and not a bunch of old Glasgow university trendy lefties playing at committee . Wolfe Smith for CEO would rip my knitting. No doubt pistol Pete will leave on his own terms soon, and like the bunnet who was hated in his own time, he will be better thought of looking in the back mirror.
PARTICK THISTLE – 0 V CELTIC- 4.
I had the 0 – 4 Correct Score on Two Bookie lines at odds of 10/1.
NAE LUCK to whoever took Celts to win 5 – 0 with Denis Law scoring Twice ???????
LOL…TEE…HEE LOL.
HH.
Celtic v Huns Semi Final at Hamdump.
I wonder if Mr TAVPEN is somewhat concerned ( Bricking it ? ) at the thought of facing ” SEB THE REB” at Hamdump ?
LOL
HH.
Taurangabhoy @ 8:24 am,
Yes, some folk like Auldheid and your immunity to Pedrovirus is very impressive.
Me – I’m sick as a dog…
Seriously, if the man had left ten years ago he may well have reached legend status by now.
Hail Hail
Thank you Chairbhoy, not usually mentioned in such exalted company but I will take it in the good grace that it was given. Hopefully we will all be over any ill effects on 1/2 November at Hampdon. Hail Hail.
Good Morning CQN
If Celtic co-opted Big Jimmy onto the board (stay with me )
Allowed him a reasonable portion of the spare cash given his success at the bookies
Boom we could be billionaires next year (only fools and horses)
have a good day
Cantona
https://www.instagram.com/reel/DOvwcAKjMHc/?igsh=MXF6ZDRoMncxaDJoag%3D%3D
Saddened to read of the passing of EC67.
Rest in peace, Sir.