Transfer window position and spend review

786

The transfer window closed yesterday with Celtic bringing in 10 players in total, six purchased and four season-long loan signings.  Positions filled were:

A Goalkeeper
Left and right backs
Three central midfielders
One winger
Three strikers, one of whom has already played on the wing

Only central defence was not added to.  Maik Nawrocki, who was out on loan last term, got a great move to Lens, although he suffered an ACL injury this week.  This leaves us with four central defenders, which sounds light, although to be fair, five sounds too many to keep happy (ask Maik).

We have a glut of players who will compete for the No. 8 role: Mika Baur, Oliver Sorensen, Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain and Luke McCowan, although some can fill other roles, including the No. 6.  This position, occupied by Callum McGregor since the departure of Scott Brown five years ago, is the strategic gap I am sure the club are keen to fill.

For several seasons, Callum played more football than anyone else in the world game.  He is almost always fit and a succession of managers have wanted him on the field whenever possible.  Celtic need to bridge two competing demands: Callum to control as much of our game as possible, while giving enough time to bed-in a successor.  That job has to start soon.

ADVERTISEMENT

I could not be happier with the acquisition of Camilo Duran (24) and Kasper Hogh (25).  Both in their prime with established Champions League credentials.  It’s still early days, but how we managed to acquire Camilo for less than £5m is incredible.  I get Kyogo-type vibes from him.  Kasper gives us a dimension to our play that’s been missing for some time.  What Martin does tactically when everyone is fit, will be interesting.

When early in the summer Martin talked about wanting Kelechi Iheanacho back at the club I was in despair.  Kelechi’s cameos were crucial for us last season, but he offered no development and no up-surprises; the opposite of a coherent strategy.  The embarrassment of then failing to land a player we had just allowed an option to expire on, gave a shambolic impression.  Fortunately, that was not the whole picture.

I watched Argentina-Egypt at the World Cup with disappointment as I was sure Haissem Hassan’s outstanding display would take him beyond our reach.  On the game’s highest stage and against the finalists, he stole the show.  He is the most direct winger we have had in years (which will not always work for him).  Fans of all colours are frustrated when wingers recycle the ball and the attacking team reverts to a horseshoe of doom.  You will not seem much of that from Haissem, he will commit defenders more than anyone in Scottish football; watch them double-up on him.

Tactically it might not fit, but a line-up with Hassan on one wing, Jota on the other, with Hogh in front and Duran just off him would be interesting.

The central mid position looks to be where we have been most strategic.  Sorensen (24) is the oldest and most experienced recruit.  Baur is 22 and still has scope to develop.  Joel van den Berg’s exclusion from the European squad indicates his limited game-time thus far.  He is 19, away from home for the first time and will learn his trade in the Scottish Premiership.

ADVERTISEMENT

Kieran Tierney needs a deputy and we need Liam Scales to be playing in central defence, so the addition of loanee Landon Emenalo (18) is certainly required.  He’s young and like Joel, needs to be deployed carefully.  One of Jordan Lotomba’s main assets is that he can play left back, as well as his more regular right back role.  Liam will hopefully be fourth choice left back now and will remain in the middle.

Sam Johnstone (33) collected a runners-up medal with England at the Euros two years ago.  After a traumatic season with Wolves, when they were cannon fodder in the EPL, Celtic offer the goalkeeper a chance to reset.  It’s not clear if he will replace Viljami Sinisalo, I suspect Martin has an open mind of the subject right now.

Out went our beloved Daizen Maeda and Reo Hatate, together, key architects of Celtic’s current five-in-a-row run.  They leave having given us lifetime memories and our eternal thanks.  Arne Engels brought in £22m.  This surprised many, but he is still only 22 and like Mika, has plenty of road ahead.  We got £3m for Johnny Kenny (23).  I predict he will move gain for double this price.  Honourable mention too for Stephen Welsh, especially for that last minute equaliser for 10-man Motherwell on a Wednesday night in February.

A couple of points on transfer business.  Sales brought in a reported £46m, while we spent £30m (plus unreported loan fees).  These figures do not and should not equate.  Total spend over a business cycle should equate to total earnings.  A healthy model for clubs like Celtic is to earn from transfers to spend on wages.  You do not need to look too far away to learn what happens when clubs our size are net spenders.

Also, we lost the Champions League qualifier, which was a failure on the club.  It was not because “we did not sign players before then”, as I heard repeatedly on the radio on my way to the game on Wednesday.  Signing players before these games, then signing players after them, is good.

ADVERTISEMENT

Did we do enough to win the title again?  We’ll see.  As we discussed above, it is early days, but if feels like the best window we have had since Ange was doing his thing.  It is coherent and aligned to a strategy I recognise.

Newco ran us close last season and, like a half-arsed parent over-compensating for a lack of love by buying the kids expensive gadgets, out-spent us.  I am not convinced by their work, but money has been deployed and we must recognise the threat.

Hearts are a latent worry.  They upgraded their coach and will continue to challenge.  Their win at Hibs last night is a portent of how well-prepared they are.  More immediately, St Mirren also have a better manager than they had a year ago and host a top-of-the-table clash against Celtic tomorrow.  It already feels like a significant game.

Click Here for Comments >
Share.

About Author

786 Comments

  1. I was probably too harsh in Tounetki last night. St Mirren broke in us several times after Tounetki coughed up possession but having slept on it…

     

     

    Wingers will lose the ball. The fact opposition can break on us so quickly and directly points to a problem with our set up.

     

     

    I’d still drop Sinasalo, he parries the ball into dangerous areas far too often and he’ll never be a top keeper until that’s fixed.

  2. A hard fought victory for the Bhoys , excellent football at times ,scrappy at times . Some bizarre decision making , by a fairly new ref (?) .

     

    Wullie vision will explain it all in the fullness of time .

     

    Var not working in hun game , var useless in Celtic game , a review of var incoming with a view ( see what I did there ) of stopping it until it can be sorted ?

     

    Up the Hoops

  3. Re the 2nd disallowed goal , seemed to me the published still photo showed the ball had already travelled a (very) short distance from our players foot (Benji?) ….

     

     

    Saw last nights ref at EKFC a few years back OK at that level but he did have a habit of letting players away with things then the game would sort of randomly erupt. Like Wednesday nights ref can’t seem to spot a forward tugging a defenders shirt , a Euro ref would have booked the entire Saints defence last night , for simply coming through the back of players.

     

     

    Still valuable lessons for Camilo and Sorensen last night , I suspect the young Chelsea fella will be a star

     

     

    HH

  4. the still photo of the first disallowed goal had the defenders leg from the knee down to his foot blurred completely blurred out of focus but camilla’s foot was as clear as anything , it was if someone tried to removed the defenders lower limb.

  5. ADVERTISEMENT
  6. the second disallowed goal the defender tried and realised he was the last man to foul the Celtic attacker , never offside , anyway 3 pts won and poor var decisions they say even themselves out over the season.

  7. What happened to the chance to the offside rule which said that there had to be daylight between the attacking player and the last defender to be deemed offside? For both disallowed goals last night there was barely a millimetre (if even that!) between the players.

  8. going up to do tour of CP today with family and baby…whats the nearest car park, given the terrible.

  9. bournesouprecipe on

    VAR World Cup or the Ferguslie Park version?

     

     

    Decisions robbed us of a goal and a possible penalty, and that was only the first half. Still haven’t seen a good game in that stadium, where the Buddies could boo for Scotland. Duran was onside as the ball was played, camera lines come later. We don’t have joined-up technology or officialdom.

     

     

    Baur, Calmac and Nygren did just enough to win the midfield, but MON’s system left us as open as Linz. Donovan is a talent but was exposed too often and was on a tightrope after an early caution. Scales & Trusty held firm, while CCV, fully fit, is by far and away still the best CB in Scotland.

     

     

    Yang had a tremendous game again, even scoring via the Celtic App before he did on Sky. If only Seb Tounekti, at twice his price, had half his pace to go past his marker? Our bench is better, there are options. Mheuka looks greedy and confident of goals — that’s why he’s here for the year.

     

     

    Team spirit in this Celtic squad is second to none, but MON and co must fill the gaps that appear in Parkhead, Paisley, Perth or anywhere else.

     

     

    MOM Yang

     

    🇨🇮🇨🇮🇨🇮🇨🇮🇨🇮

  10. ADVERTISEMENT
  11. I mentioned the officials prematch and sadly they are the main take away after another they are just making it up as they go along the clubs must make the governing bodies known after a few years the Temu version used and deployed here isn’t fit for purpose pay the money and het the right VAR kit in.

     

    I won’t metion Ryan Lee like Duncan Nicholson we know what they are.

  12. Back to Basics,

     

     

    Good summary of what Don Robertson did and mentioning Alan Muir was caught out for similar. This time it had the feeling of deliberate action by Robertson to impact Celtic whereas Muir was more of a reaction. The way Robertson placed the referee in no mans land to make a decision was shocking for the third goal. The ref should have refused it and stuck with the goal decision; his inexperience and deference to the time served Robertson made this impossible for him. Robertson knew what he was doing when he stitched up the younger ref and Celtic.

     

     

    Celtic should be all over this — would love to hear the audio !!

     

     

    24 hours earlier Motherwell players watched a rerun on the controversial penalty awarded by Nicholson to the Ibrox club. Motherwell players adamant it was a foul on Sparrow. Scottish media especially Radio Sevco with cheerleader McIntyre were delighted to be given a penalty for a foul by Gassama.

     

     

    Club need to set the tone with the different refereeing standards being applied especially with the false narrative the media are still carrying with our disgusting title win from last season.

     

     

    The narrative needs to be about the present and several obvious decisions against Celtic ( and against VAR rules) and Ibrox club getting help to keep them in the title.

     

     

    They are getting their practice in early for the cup/league double header —- needs to be stopped in its tracks !!

  13. We must as fans put our club under pressure to hilight these unconscious biased decisions & that is me being kind as these instances are occurring every match day.

  14. ADVERTISEMENT
  15. Seems to me that Gogic need sorting out early on in last nights game, a 40-60 sliding tackle to take out his standing leg and if possible fall on top of him , may have made him think twice about his carry on the entire game.

     

     

    Alternatively aim a few corners directly at him and wipe him out … either works for me.

     

     

    HH

  16. The offside rule was introduced to football to stop players from gaining an advantage by goal-hanging in front of their opponent’s goal while play was going on elsewhere on the pitch. It was not intended to be applied as it is today to try to rule out almost every goal that is scored (especially by players representing Celtic FC).

     

     

    For the disallowed Duran effort, even IF an outer electron of a cell on his big toenail was 1mm closer to goal than one on the defender’s foot for 1 nanosecond (which wasn’t actually proven), when he knocked them ball into the net he was BEHIND the defender and made contact with the ball with his trailing leg from BEHIND his own body. So he actually had to let the defender get ahead of him and then still had to stretch backwards to hit the ball. As such, any distance ahead of the defender (even that 1mm) was more of a disadvantage than an advantage to him.

     

     

    He was certainly not gaining an unfair advantage by goal-hanging, and the he goal should have stood.

  17. garygillespieshamstring on

    Fourstonecoppi

     

     

    There is a car park on the site of the old school on London Road that is close to the tour entrance.

  18. ADVERTISEMENT
  19. For much of last season we were toothless up front and required Nygren to push forward and bail us out on a number of occasions (and often this was in games where he contributed little else). This season we have much more firepower up front but Nygren continues to play the same role which means he provides very little support for the defence. If MoN continues to play 433, would it not be better to tell Nygren to play this season in a more traditional midfield position? Or play a different format (442)? Playing two wingers, a CF and Nygren is equivalent at times to playing 424. Our defence is getting badly exposed by the opposition advancing on them with next to no resistance from midfield. I think Yang did more defensive work yesterday than Nygren.

  20. DENIABHOY

     

     

    Nail on head!

     

     

    Have a good day all

     

     

    C’MON THE CELTS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  21. I am wondering if the longer our winning run continues ,the more we will see more yellow cards , good goals disallowed and opponents` fouls ignored.

  22. Funny how football works.

     

     

    Around a year ago Sebastian Tounekti was wining a man of the match award on his debut and we were being told that he was what Celtic were missing. It was proof that had we done our business in the window earlier we would have qualified for the Champions League.

     

     

    Yang was out of the picture, shipped out to Birmingham then called back because we couldn’t get in a replacement. He didnt get a start on the left wing until the end of November when Tounekti hadn’t proved to be the signing some though he would be.

     

     

    Forward a year Yang is probably our most consistent performer and one of the first names on the team sheet. A really important player, he’s become excellent defensively, and he seems to be prepared to learn.

     

     

    He’s a big success story for the management, and proof that development of what you have already got will trump expensive “quality” enough times for it to the worth pursuing.

     

     

    He’s miles ahead of Tounekti, even Sebastians biggest fans a year ago have turned on him.

  23. lets all do the huddle on

    you can park on the stadium concourse on nonmatch days can you not?

     

     

    just drive round the back of the north stand from springfield road round to the front

  24. ADVERTISEMENT
  25. A win away against 2nd placed team, 3 points, 2 goals & no injuries, all good.

     

    But…that ref & his cohorts were abysmal. Our game has slanted officiating that manifests in risible decisions (& ridiculous outpouring of erroneous rhetoric) in our matches. It’s glaring.

     

    Suppose we’ve had a century+ to get used to it but it still irks.

     

    Without being brilliant we deserved the win, thought they were quite average & very limited, was expecting better tbh (should know better in our league).

     

    I am a MON worshipper & reckon he walks on water so I can only assume Tounekti is amazing in training.

     

    Anywho, we keep winning. 👍🍀

  26. lets all do the huddle on

    my take on how the offside should work –

     

     

    if the first frame shows the ball not having left the players boot, and the next frame shows it having left his boot, and the offside-ness of the receiving player has changed in those 2 frames, then it is impossible for them to tell exactly when that happened, so you either go with the onfield decision or give the benefit to the attacking team (to be decided at the start of the season obviously)

  27. MON continues to puzzle with his selections.Why keep a guy,Lotomba on the bench,who can play LB,or RB,and end up,once again with 4 CHs as a back 4.Forgotten Lask so soon?Anyone know why?Big Scales is a Trooper,we all know that,but he is never a LB.Never.Again,when Saints were pushing for an equaliser,we still never put Sorensen on to plug the middle.On to replace Baur,who was doing that role anyway.Hsd a very good game.Just strange decisions for me.

  28. lets all do the huddle on

    and also about offside,

     

     

    if we are going to get really technical,

     

     

    when you see a frame of the ball against the players boot, that is not the exact moment it leaves his boot and goes forward.

     

     

    the ball compresses against the players boot, before effectively springing.forward, so it is ‘stuck’ to his boot for a non-zero length of time,

  29. ADVERTISEMENT
  30. And our in situ left back getting the much delayed equaliser……

     

    After getting slaughtered on here…..

     

    Mmmm

  31. glendalystonsils on

    Hot Smoked on 6th September 2026 11:22 am

     

     

    We deservedly got away with the 3 points last night . All well and good , but poor or disgraceful (take your pick) officiating will rob us of points if it continues . We must push our case strongly with Willie Collum or it will only get worse .

     

    After what happened last season ,they definitely see us as needing our wings clipped .

  32. lets all do the huddle on

    Lot of Donovan fans about these days……

     

    —

     

     

    Mellow Yellow my favourite

     

     

    😁

  33. Last night was a very entertaining game with some real quality from Celtic.

     

     

    Listening to Calmac and Martin after our recent games it looks to me like we’re in for a season of football like we saw under Ange.

     

     

    I thought we played well in the first half, we had plenty of control and except for the penalty we didnt concede a single shot on goal. St Mirren hardly got in our half. We had less control in the second and while we created more chances we conceded 6 or 7 on goals and looked far more likely to concede a goal. Lots of mad chasing back and 3 on 3s or 4 on 4s.

     

     

    After the game Martin said that he was disappointed with our first half preformance and that we were much better in the second, Calmac said pretty much the same.

     

     

    When Martin was asked what he said at half time he said that Calmac had done a lot of the talking. In the interview post match when he was asked about how many chances we gave away second half Calmac talked about how important it is to commit numbers forward in attacking areas and that there would be occasions when the defence would have to be relied on to deal with the counter attacks on their own.

     

     

    Calmac made some noises about the players not being brave enough to go on and win the game away to LASK.

     

     

    I also don’t think how much we concentrated on attacking payers in the transfer window and that a defensive midfielder was left to last is a coincidence. Defensive mids aren’t a priority in our system at the moment.

     

     

    Games like last night are probably the norm for us this season, even in the Europa League, I reckon. We’ll probably be having the same discussion about our European performances that we had when Ange was at Celtic.

     

     

    It’s not so good for the ticker but winning 2-1 away to the other form team in the SPL suggests that something is working. We were a baws hair away from two more goals, we’re creating masses of really good chances from open play and we have three really good finishers in the squad now.

     

     

    I think once Hassan starts playing how Martin seems to want him to we’ll get better as well. He’s got masses of natural ability, if he can mix it up and play to more of a pattern we’ll create more better chances. Always going outside and crossing in is great as long as that’s what the centre forward is expecting. Sutton talked about no one making a run to the near post for a cross last night but if the CF isn’t expecting the ball to go there he can’t make the run in time to get on the end of it.

     

     

    I reckon we’re going to have some difficult moments this season but if the football is as enjoyable as Martin, Shaun and Calmac Aseem to be trying to make it, on balance I’m for it.

  34. ADVERTISEMENT
  35. Celtic Mac…

     

    The same story will repeat with the oft maligned Dane Murray.

     

    He will soon have lots of fans.

  36. CELTIC MAC on 6TH SEPTEMBER 2026 11:37 AM

     

    Lot of Yang fans about these days……

     

     

    Wasn’t always thus…..

     

     

    Quite. Some of us have been though

  37. Yang was 21 when he came to Glasgow and had hardly played any football, but, apparently enough for our scouts to see something.

     

     

    Its not a huge surprise that he’s taken so long to become the player he is, especially when he was obviously not wanted by the manager he was playing for.