Transfer window position and spend review

786

The transfer window closed yesterday with Celtic bringing in 10 players in total, six purchased and four season-long loan signings.  Positions filled were:

A Goalkeeper
Left and right backs
Three central midfielders
One winger
Three strikers, one of whom has already played on the wing

Only central defence was not added to.  Maik Nawrocki, who was out on loan last term, got a great move to Lens, although he suffered an ACL injury this week.  This leaves us with four central defenders, which sounds light, although to be fair, five sounds too many to keep happy (ask Maik).

We have a glut of players who will compete for the No. 8 role: Mika Baur, Oliver Sorensen, Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain and Luke McCowan, although some can fill other roles, including the No. 6.  This position, occupied by Callum McGregor since the departure of Scott Brown five years ago, is the strategic gap I am sure the club are keen to fill.

For several seasons, Callum played more football than anyone else in the world game.  He is almost always fit and a succession of managers have wanted him on the field whenever possible.  Celtic need to bridge two competing demands: Callum to control as much of our game as possible, while giving enough time to bed-in a successor.  That job has to start soon.

ADVERTISEMENT

I could not be happier with the acquisition of Camilo Duran (24) and Kasper Hogh (25).  Both in their prime with established Champions League credentials.  It’s still early days, but how we managed to acquire Camilo for less than £5m is incredible.  I get Kyogo-type vibes from him.  Kasper gives us a dimension to our play that’s been missing for some time.  What Martin does tactically when everyone is fit, will be interesting.

When early in the summer Martin talked about wanting Kelechi Iheanacho back at the club I was in despair.  Kelechi’s cameos were crucial for us last season, but he offered no development and no up-surprises; the opposite of a coherent strategy.  The embarrassment of then failing to land a player we had just allowed an option to expire on, gave a shambolic impression.  Fortunately, that was not the whole picture.

I watched Argentina-Egypt at the World Cup with disappointment as I was sure Haissem Hassan’s outstanding display would take him beyond our reach.  On the game’s highest stage and against the finalists, he stole the show.  He is the most direct winger we have had in years (which will not always work for him).  Fans of all colours are frustrated when wingers recycle the ball and the attacking team reverts to a horseshoe of doom.  You will not seem much of that from Haissem, he will commit defenders more than anyone in Scottish football; watch them double-up on him.

Tactically it might not fit, but a line-up with Hassan on one wing, Jota on the other, with Hogh in front and Duran just off him would be interesting.

The central mid position looks to be where we have been most strategic.  Sorensen (24) is the oldest and most experienced recruit.  Baur is 22 and still has scope to develop.  Joel van den Berg’s exclusion from the European squad indicates his limited game-time thus far.  He is 19, away from home for the first time and will learn his trade in the Scottish Premiership.

ADVERTISEMENT

Kieran Tierney needs a deputy and we need Liam Scales to be playing in central defence, so the addition of loanee Landon Emenalo (18) is certainly required.  He’s young and like Joel, needs to be deployed carefully.  One of Jordan Lotomba’s main assets is that he can play left back, as well as his more regular right back role.  Liam will hopefully be fourth choice left back now and will remain in the middle.

Sam Johnstone (33) collected a runners-up medal with England at the Euros two years ago.  After a traumatic season with Wolves, when they were cannon fodder in the EPL, Celtic offer the goalkeeper a chance to reset.  It’s not clear if he will replace Viljami Sinisalo, I suspect Martin has an open mind of the subject right now.

Out went our beloved Daizen Maeda and Reo Hatate, together, key architects of Celtic’s current five-in-a-row run.  They leave having given us lifetime memories and our eternal thanks.  Arne Engels brought in £22m.  This surprised many, but he is still only 22 and like Mika, has plenty of road ahead.  We got £3m for Johnny Kenny (23).  I predict he will move gain for double this price.  Honourable mention too for Stephen Welsh, especially for that last minute equaliser for 10-man Motherwell on a Wednesday night in February.

A couple of points on transfer business.  Sales brought in a reported £46m, while we spent £30m (plus unreported loan fees).  These figures do not and should not equate.  Total spend over a business cycle should equate to total earnings.  A healthy model for clubs like Celtic is to earn from transfers to spend on wages.  You do not need to look too far away to learn what happens when clubs our size are net spenders.

Also, we lost the Champions League qualifier, which was a failure on the club.  It was not because “we did not sign players before then”, as I heard repeatedly on the radio on my way to the game on Wednesday.  Signing players before these games, then signing players after them, is good.

ADVERTISEMENT

Did we do enough to win the title again?  We’ll see.  As we discussed above, it is early days, but if feels like the best window we have had since Ange was doing his thing.  It is coherent and aligned to a strategy I recognise.

Newco ran us close last season and, like a half-arsed parent over-compensating for a lack of love by buying the kids expensive gadgets, out-spent us.  I am not convinced by their work, but money has been deployed and we must recognise the threat.

Hearts are a latent worry.  They upgraded their coach and will continue to challenge.  Their win at Hibs last night is a portent of how well-prepared they are.  More immediately, St Mirren also have a better manager than they had a year ago and host a top-of-the-table clash against Celtic tomorrow.  It already feels like a significant game.

Click Here for Comments >
Share.

About Author

786 Comments

  1. Just watched the Duran ‘goal’ again.

     

     

    Not convinced he was offside.

     

     

    However, what’s not in doubt is Gpgic’s 2 footed attempt to stop Yang.

     

     

    Had Yang not leapt over the ‘challenge’ he could have been seriously injured.

     

     

    Maybe VAR should have been looking at that.

  2. One thing that confuses me, we all know about the refereeing in scotland is a joke, it’s always been so since our inception, I can understand our suits not saying anything to rock the boat as they are steering it together with the hun to keep the OF sailing on course, they for some mistaken IMO belief that they need the hun to survive, the support are a different matter, we all know that they are about, the establishment I mean, what I am confused about is why the Green Brigade never mention the corruption re the referees, just wondering why that would be.

  3. The returnof weeron on

    Hearts v Dundee….

     

     

    I watched most of it.

     

     

    The handball was legit.

     

     

    The red card a few minutes later was not a red card. It was a tackle from behind. But the leading foot didn’t make contact. The contact was the thigh of the Hearts player.

     

     

    It was VAR that called the ref over, and he did their bidding.

     

     

    Weeron

  4. ADVERTISEMENT
  5. Good Evening Celts….

     

     

    Thought we played well yesterday, we moved the ball about with purpose, St Mirren made a game of it, so it was a good watch, never doubted the three points though.

     

     

    Lots of candidates again for POTY nominations, yet winging it’s near belated way to sencelpoty@gmail.com

     

     

    – Duran

     

     

    – Peak Yang

     

     

    – Scales

     

     

    See the groupies out again, got some brass neck after what their toxic campaign managed to do to our club from the heights of the Allianz Arena.

     

     

    Why are they still gunning for a legendary manager!?

     

     

    Remember the 42 Laws of Power…

     

     

    Law 15: Crush Your Enemy Totally: Crush your enemy completely. If you leave even one ember smoldering, it will eventually ignite. You can’t afford to be lenient.

     

     

    Aff oooot

     

     

    Hail Hail

  6. After reading on here,I had a quick look on FF.Incredible,but very difficult to tell both apart when it comes to refereeing,VAR,corruption.Both sides saying the exact same.

  7. From jobo

     

     

    *SENTINEL CELTS PLAYER OF THE YEAR 2025-26*

     

    *RESULTS FROM GAME #8 ST MIRREN 1 CELTIC 2 (SCALES, YANG)*

     

     

    Good evening, friends.

     

    Our first real test of the domestic season saw a 2nd v 1st clash in Paisley. A pity that only around 6,500 fans were in the ground to see it.

     

    It turned out to be a game of very fine margins with 3 big decision – a penalty and 2 disallowed goals – being decided on centimetres rather than being of the clear cut varieties. All 3 decisions went St Mirren’s way and we learned that, in Scotland, the VAR can encourage the referee to have a guess at what the correct outcome should be! Grrrrr…

     

    Celtic started very brightly and completely dominated the opening stages, despite Donovan picking up another very early yellow card. Our front line were very positive and Camillo isn’t just a fine footballer, but a male model in the making, displaying the whitest teeth ever seen on a Celtic player!

     

    The first goal came in the 19th minute. St Mirren’s corner was cleared to the edge of our box but the volleyed strike towards goal hit Scales’ outstretched hand right on the edge of the box and a penalty was awarded. Sinisalo guessed right but the shot had enough power to hit the net and Celtic were behind in a domestic game for the first time this season. Consequently, St Mirren now had it in their own hands to secure the 2027-28 Champions League qualifying spot.

     

    After half an hour it looked like Celtic had equalised. Good work from Baur released Yang on the left and his ball into the box was put home by the outstretched boot of Duran. I wasn’t totally convinced by the VAR angles but anyway the goal was disallowed for offside and Celtic went into the break one down.

     

    Celtic came flying out of the traps for the second half and had a couple of decent chances right after half time. The best had come from good work from Hassan on the right when his whipped inswinging cross wasn’t rewarded with a goal from Yang at the back post.

     

    But in the 50th minute we did draw level and there was a degree of satisfaction involved here. St Mirren’s opener came from a corner unnecessarily conceded due to Sinisalo’s poor decision making. Celic’s equaliser also came from a corner that the St Mirren keeper could have easily avoided. But when the ball was crossed in we shouldn’t fail to appreciate the brilliant run to the near post by Scales and the excellent glancing looping header across to the far corner. Liam concedes a penalty, then gets the equaliser and so sits at level par with 40 to play!

     

    The next 15 minutes saw play shift repeatedly from end to end but a moment of magic from Duran was to prove significant. Camilo did very well to steal the ball inside Celtic’s half and he then progressed into the opposition half before releasing Yang in the inside left position to calmly slot the ball home. Wait a minute, didn’t I just type more or less the same for our 3rd goal against Aberdeen? It’s déjà vu all over again! And 2-1 Celtic meant that another Saturday night tin of beer could be poured!

     

    The game remained in the balance for the remainder, not least when in the 85th minute the limping Donovan was left for dead in a St Mirren counter attack. The ball across Celtic’s 6 yard box looked a certain goal but the attacker ballooned it over the bar. I cheered loudly and poured another!

     

    Right after that, Donovan was replaced by Murray which meant that Celtic’s back line consisted of 4 centre backs – The right footed Murray and CCV along with the left footed Trusty and Scales. Total football?

     

    The final talking point came in stoppage time. A ball through to Mheuta, playing on the shoulder of the last defender, saw our loanee striker in on goal and a composed, well struck finish seemed to seal the points. Admittedly, whether he was onside or offside was a matter of inches but neither the linesman nor the referee thought he was offside. The automatic VAR lines couldn’t be drawn and so, surely, the onfield decision stands? But, no, the VAR calls the referee to the monitor to have a look. Now, I accept that it does look as if Mheuta was just offside. But that’s not the point here. As there was no definitive proof of offside (i.e. the ‘lines’ couldn’t be drawn) then surely the onfield decision must stand? But not in Scotland – goal disallowed!! If I were paranoid (which I am!) I’d say that many folk in Scotland are still not able to accept how the final week of the 2025-26 league season played out!

     

    Fortunately that incredible sequence of events didn’t affect the outcome of the game and Celtic continue with a 100% win rate in the league.

     

     

    Celtic have now played 8 games, winning 7 and losing 1. We have scored 21 and conceded 8. We sit 3 points clear of last season’s runners up, and 5 clear of the mob who finished third.

     

     

    Another excellent turnout of voters, so thank you for that. For this latest game, 104 provided their nominations, meaning we have again hit the 100+ target, for the 7th time in 8 games. £15 was sent to the Glasgow City Mission last weekend and that’s now another £6 sitting in the pot.

     

     

    The total votes cast for each player (with my own nominations asterisked) are as follows –

     

     

    Sinisalo*: 3

     

    Donovan: 11

     

    Carter Vickers: 7

     

    Trusty: 0

     

    Scales: 34

     

    McGregor: 18

     

    Baur: 31

     

    Nygren: 3

     

    Hassan*: 38

     

    Duran: 69

     

    Yang*: 98

     

    Forrest: 0

     

    Sørensen: 0

     

    Tounekti: 0

     

    Mheuka: 0

     

    Murray: 0

     

    Unused subs: Johnstone, Lotombo, Oxlade-Chamberlain, Van den Berg

     

     

     

    And so, the POINTS earned by each player for the game against St Mirren are as follows –

     

    25 – Yang

     

    22 – Duran

     

    19 – Hassan

     

    16 – Scales

     

    14 – Baur

     

    12 – McGregor

     

    11 – Donovan

     

    10 – Carter-Vickers

     

    9 each – Nygren and Sinisalo

     

    5 each – Forrest, Mheuka, Murray, Sørensen, Tounekti, Trusty

     

    1 each – Johnstone, Lotombo, Oxlade-Chamberlain, Van den Berg

     

     

    And the CUMULATIVE POINTS after 8 games played are as follows –

     

    151 – Duran

     

    109 – Donovan

     

    108 – Yang

     

    106 – McGregor and Nygren

     

    89 – Carter-Vickers

     

    83 – Tierney

     

    73 – Sinisalo

     

    71 – Baur

     

    60 – Høgh, Scales and Trusty

     

    59 – Hassan

     

    53 – Oxlade-Chamberlain

     

    51 – Tounekti

     

    38 – Forrest

     

    30 – Engels

     

    26 – McCowan

     

    21 – Murray

     

    18 – Hatate

     

    17 – Johnston

     

    13 – Osmand

     

    10 each – Mheuka and Sørensen

     

    9 – Ralston

     

    6 – Doohan

     

    3 – Kenny

     

    2 – Balikwisha and Johnstone

     

    1 – Kennedy, Lotomba and Van den Berg

     

     

    We only have to wait 3 more sleeps until our next league game, an away trip to St Johnstone on Wednesday evening, kick off 8.00pm.

     

    Hail Hail!

  8. The Blogger Formerly Known As GM on

    LoL, charlatans trying to be profound by quoting charlatans trying to be profound by ripping off the work of others.

     

     

    “Upon this, it is to be remarked that men ought either to be well treated or crushed, because they can avenge themselves of lighter injuries, of more serious ones they cannot; therefore the injury that is to be done to a man ought to be of such a kind that one does not stand in fear of revenge.”

     

     

    So wrote Machiavelli in ‘ThePrince’, published in…………1532.

  9. ADVERTISEMENT
  10. While we’re quoting The Prince, I always remember this bit…

     

     

    “An earthquake is erupting, but not in Orange street,

     

    A ghost-dance is preparing, You got to help us with your feet,

     

    If you’re not in the mood to dance, step back, grab yourself a seat,

     

    This may not be uptown Jamaica, but we promise you a treat”

     

     

     

    MadnessCSC

  11. Prestonpans,

     

    That’s not the expected reaction. Get back to cowering in the shade of the towering intellect. When he and the confirmed liar team up we should all accept our fate as inferior beings.

     

     

    Know your place.

  12. Mixed bag of results for our Europa rivals this weekend but in general most are doing pretty well so far. Interesting also to note that it is clear that most really do value competing in this competition rather than viewing it as a downgrade which appears to be how we see it. Ferencvaros, Benfica, Omonia and Besiktas all came through tricky multiple game qualifiers to get to this stage.

     

     

    Celta improved on their poor start in Spain on Thursday, although only slightly better, with a 0-0 draw at Sociedad. They stay in the drop zone in La Liga and go again at Getafe tomorrow night. This should have been a pretty straight forward period for them playing weaker teams but a loss tonight would mean the next 4 (on paper) easier domestic games would assume huge importance just as they begin their Europa campaign. Malaga / Elche / Santander / Alaves should all be winnable but they are running out of rope before facing the big guns domestically.

     

    They have Omonia and Juventus to face in Europa before they come to us game 3. Personally hoping our Celtic cousins (including our old friend Carl Starfelt) are fighting at the wrong end domestically when they come to Celtic park.

     

     

    Ferencvaros have had a positive start but a 2-2 draw after leading 2-0 in the big derby with our old pals (from the early 70s) Ujpest was disappointing today. They have dropped points in 3 out of 6 domestic games this season. In Europa qualifiers they have had 4 notable wins v Vojvodina, Twente, Gornik and Trabzonspor. A strong outfit they are keen to wipe out the memory of last seasons loss of the championship to Eto Gyor.

     

    Having already played 8 Euro ties and 6 domestic games they are well into their rhythm. Also unlike Celtic they have 2 very straightforward domestic matches either side of our match at Celtic Park. Personally I am gutted we will miss Yang for this critical first match. This will be. A huge challenge for us.

     

     

    Benfica are far from straight A’s this season (post Jose) but they have comfortably came through 3 Europa ties. St Gallen, Hearts and AGF (Danish Champions) all dispatched to an average of more than 3 goals per game. They have only dropped points in one league game to date.

     

    They do go to Milan on game 1 before hosting us in game 2.

     

     

    Torreensee are struggling. 14th out of 18 in 2nd tier in Portugal with 1 win in 5. It seems the bubble has burst although they held Porto to a 1-0 defeat in their ‘Super Cup’ final. They beat Benfica second string 2-0 this weekend.

     

     

    Omonia Nicosia have had a crazy time of it but won 3 games to get to this stage. STVV of Belgium, Red Imps of Gibraltar and our old pals Kairat Almaty. They lost narrowly to Pafos in the Super Cup Final and drew their only league game so far. Tomorrow’s match with Aris Limassol should be interesting.

     

     

    Besiktas did well to come through qualifying in Europa beating a strong Mitdjyland, Czech side Hrladec Karlovie and then Kaunas. They have also just beaten Fenerbahce away 2-1. A capable outfit including Oh, Cerny and Yilmaz who have Glasgow experience. Trossard is one of a handful of big names. Not an easy tie with another team who have shown by results that they want to be in this tournament.

     

     

    Union St G are tucked in between Brugge and Gent at the top after 5 games in Belgium. Narrowly lost by the odd goal (in 117 minutes of second leg) in 11 over 2 legs to Bodo in CL play off. A great mix of youth and experience. Hopefully we go there in January already confident of qualifying.

     

     

    Marseilles are struggling a bit in the league after 3 games although the whole table is a bit upside down right now. 1 win and 2 defeats after 3 games. Loss 3-2 at home to Paris FC was a sore one this weekend. It’s a few months until we play them and Union but hopefully they will be distracted a bit when they come to Celtic Park for the Final game. They are at Lille a few days before they come.

     

     

    Overall whilst it is good we miss English German and Italian sides in Europa we are up against some clubs who will be both very keen to compete and also who have real capability and experience. How some do initially might just determine how committed they are in rounds 6,7 and 8. Likewise how they are doing domestically.

     

     

    The first match at home to Ferencvaros probably comes too soon for us and splits 2 Glasgow Derbys which is not ideal. Winning that really would set us up for a good campaign.

  13. Same three Chairbhoy …fools seldom never haha.

     

     

    We need to start looking forward. We have largely a new first team. They need our support. Those young lads thrive on praise wither on tennis balls and banners. Hail Hail. Bring on the next saints.

  14. Burnley78 on 7th September 2026 7:31 am

     

     

    Thanks for that . Very informative and balanced.

     

     

    PS I just noticed we are no longer third n Paul`s League table….we are actually top !!

     

     

    Cheerio for now.

  15. ADVERTISEMENT
  16. Good Morning CQN

     

     

    Has there been polling done or in depth research that hasn’t been published, that’s quite a definitive statement (below) to make or make up

     

     

    Interesting also to note that it is clear that most really do value competing in this competition rather than viewing it as a downgrade which appears to be how we see it.

     

     

    Over the course of a European campaign vagaries such as form, injuries, suspensions and confidence from results will all play a major part in determining how successful Celtics Europa League campaign can be, MO’N Shaun and team will largely focus internally, making sure that despite the tight schedule we are involved at the time that week the EL tie is on Celtic totally focus on what Celtic do rather than be concerned what’s happening elsewhere

     

     

    Wanted to Celtic to be in C/L most competitive sports people and supporters want to be in the very best competitions, now we are in the E/L looking forward to it got my Ticket package sorted, now I want Celtic to finish as high up the E/L table as we can do, I will be at Paradise cheering the boys on where it matters most

     

     

    Have a good day

  17. Surprised to see Chairbhoy use such intemperate language on this dear green place, quoting some obscure rule book that nobody has ever heard of, he’s better than that, but not surprised so much to see Tangerine Tam – noted; back from his hols trying and failing as always to make a sentient contribution. Still you’ve gotta love a trier….albeit a lonesome one, out there on his own…..no direction known…..

  18. Back to Basics - Glass Half Full on

    Good morning CQN

     

     

    Another fine day to be a Celt

     

     

    Top of the league with a 100% record, Martin is playing it cute with his “this team has miles to go” routine.

     

     

    Bachman Turner Overdrive stuff.

  19. Back to Basics - Glass Half Full on

    Time on my hands this morning so watched short sky highlights package with plenty of freeze frames of Duran goal.

     

     

    The VAR image with lines drawn does not show when Yang kicks the ball.

     

     

    … but, from looking at the goalkeeper’s stance and lining up this stance with images from other camera angles which DO show the ball being played by Yang?

     

     

    It is CLEAR the VAR frame used is before the ball is kicked.

     

     

    Goalie’s right leg is the giveaway.

     

     

    Bent at the knee in VAR frame.

     

     

    Stretched much straighter at point of ball being played.

     

     

    This version of VAR technology has gaps.

     

     

    I get it and accept it.

     

     

    So, even more important a consistent process is used.

     

     

    Bad enough if VAR teams in different matches differ in approach.

     

     

    Totally unacceptable for the same VAR team in the same game taking two different approaches both of which favour one team.

  20. the EL is a downgrade on the CL – fact

     

    most folk will still enjoy the EL when it comes around

     

    the fashionable statement these days seems to be “2 things can be true ate the sametime”

     

    the same folk will still feel that that there was a lot of things wrong at the club from top to bottom which prevented is being in the CL – so i suppose thats 3 things that can be true at the same time

  21. ADVERTISEMENT
  22. For clarity I was not saying that the opponents were ‘up for it’ and we appear less so as any criticism of anyone but merely a statement of logic really based on the fact that only one other team we will face are in Europa because of losing their CL qualifier…that being USG who lost to Bodo. Most others battled through a few qualifiers to get there. Come the night hopefully we are all up for it also.

  23. When I read MoN comments on the Europa squad announcement I thought they were at best ill judged.

     

     

    Of course the league will be our priority but for me, I’d like a Celtic manager to say the league and Europe was the priority.

     

     

    I fear there’s an attempt to set expectations re the Europa and I don’t like that.

     

     

    MoN and Shaun are very well paid. The bar is not set at beating St Mirren. Let’s give the Europa a real go.

  24. BBC Scotland football page with the usual anti Celtic headlines …. Celtic lose out etc etc , it is getting really comical , Rangers win 3 in a row , Hearts win 10 in a row ( home games) on and on it goes ……

     

     

    HH

  25. ADVERTISEMENT