Why a change of shape is necessary on Thursday

140

Clearly concerned by form, Martin O’Neill changed formation to three-at-the-back at home to Newco in September.  The performance and result did not inspire, so the experiment was not repeated, but when a team is in a hole, experiments should be encouraged.

Celtic only have four central defenders and at least one of them has been unavailable for most of the season, so we are not well placed to play three as a standard setup this term.  Other formations are available.

We have two strikers, one can win and retain a long ball in order to bring others into play, one who has excellent movement off the ball and has proven to be generous at slipping the ball to others in a better position.  Can we play Hogh and Duran in a two-pronged attack?

Three defeats in, the Europa League is getting to the burdensome stage, but there is a freedom in adversity.  I have never cared less about the result of a European game than Thursday’s against Besiktas. Experiment.  Try whatever you would not try in a crucial league game.  Lay down tracks that protect the middle of the park.  It will probably not go smoothly, but the players and coaches will learn things.

This side of the transfer window, nothing much can be done about the personnel.  The only thing that can change outcomes is a change of shape. So let’s have it.

ADVERTISEMENT
Click Here for Comments >
Share.

About Author

140 Comments
  1. Pages:
  2. 1
  3. 2
  4. 3
  5. 4

  1. ADVERTISEMENT
  2. Villa decide to play out of their own 18 box from their own goal kick, couple of passes later

     

    Lamal shows them that you do not do that around him….bang

     

    1-0 Barca

  3. Interesting to see Iwata performing well as a defensive Mid in the 3rd ranked team in a league well above SPL level.

     

     

    Viewed as a dud and sold for £800k by our manager at the time.

  4. ADVERTISEMENT
  5. bigrailroadblues on

    My old mate who lives in Mayfair would like to know what a handsome hun looks like. Prestonpans set him right.🤣🤣🤣🤣

  6. B78

     

    You’re carrying a lot of hate for BR – too much to be anything less than a personal grievance. Can’t just be about a football team.

  7. Last few years team has been declining

     

     

    This year hopefully is rockbottom

     

     

    Regardless of petty barbs at previous managers (we know who you are – confused about why tho, you never explained that)

     

     

    We need to get a grip of the management/director structure and start planning our transfers

     

     

    Before we get to the last days of the window

     

     

    This requires the executives to recruit the right team (before we start spending our bank)

     

     

    Make plans and execute

     

     

    This needed to happen round about this time 2 years ago

     

     

    The next best time is right now

  8. ADVERTISEMENT
  9. Burnley78 on 3rd November 2026 8:53 pm

     

     

    We are seeing clearly that Lask were not the walkover that Slovan were in CL.

     

     

    ——-

     

     

    rodgers again??? (or lennon, nancy, oneill????)

     

     

    Or the fecking board for the terrible recruitment both at board, mangement and player levels

     

     

    I know where my money aint on….

  10. When Hebcelt was waxing lyrical about Hebridean black pudding, I took his advice and went on to the butcher’s website that he recommended. I ordered a whole black pudding. The problem was, when I got to the payment section, the postage was exactly the same price as the black pudding! It wasn’t cheap, so I cancelled the order. Tonight I’m wishing I had just gone ahead and bought it to see if all he said about it was true. RIP Hebcelt.

  11. Lets hope the Democrats do well in both Houses of Congress. They will win control of the House, and could win control of the Senate if they have got the vote out. Need to hold all their own seats and add 4 (from 35 up for grabs) to get to 51, from I think 4 Rep. States. Alaska-Texas-Maine. who are about as far from each other as to be foreign countries, and Ohio plus maybe North Carolina. Of course if he does lose control of the Congress Trump may unleash hell, not in the US but in Cuba and Iran, do not rule out anything in the latter. Inc nukes.

  12. ADVERTISEMENT
  13. we got enough shite in the UK before we need to worry about hoping the Democrats do well in both Houses of Congress

  14. ADVERTISEMENT
  15. Looking @ the results for the US mid-terms looks like I underestimated the Democrats chances……

     

    Took the Senate, taking the House and many more victories in the State elections

     

    Now predict that the Celtic Board will win every vote @ the next AGM…..

  16. spikeysauldman on

    trump on yesterday saying that the aid for isreal will end at the end of the year – 4 billion ?

     

    who really stole the binance money ?

  17. ADVERTISEMENT
  18. I don’t think it matters what shape we deploy. Back 4, back 3, back 5 – it’s a case of go out lads and figure it out. The coaching isn’t there.

     

     

    We changed for the hun match at CP and I still maintain that was the worst performance I’ve ever seen from a Celtic side given the circumstances.

     

     

    Martin is not up the job.

  19. bournesouprecipe on

    BURNLEY78 on 3RD NOVEMBER 2026 8:42 PM

     

     

     

    Interesting to see Iwata performing well as a defensive Mid in the 3rd ranked team in a league well above SPL level.

     

     

     

    Viewed as a dud and sold for £800k by our manager at the time.

     

     

    —————-

     

     

    Mate

  20. BIGRAILROADBLUES on 3RD NOVEMBER 2026 7:39 PM

     

    And central London is still cheaper than Dublin for a pint.

     

     

    —-

     

     

    But the Guinness in London will never reach Dublin standards 😂

  21. So from the Greenock meeting, I hear the old ‘trust me bro’ chat is being used to attack BR again. Legal issues prevent them from saying more but the same legal issues don’t apparently apply to Dermot Desmond and his 2 bottles of vino statement.

     

     

    This is a man who resigned. He wasn’t sacked. Despite being a cross between Hitler and Trump according to some…

     

     

    What they’re saying is they were too weak to sack a man they blamed for running the club into the ground, and they think this is a line of defence for them ?!

     

     

    Their incompetence is laid bare now that we don’t have a world class manager to carry this team and overcome their shambolic running of the club.

  22. ADVERTISEMENT
  23. The Blogger Formerly Known As GM on

    After seeing B78 trigger a few yesterday morning by mentioning “He who cannot be named”, I spent a spare couple of hours last night poking around Leicester’s accounts from FY19 – FY23.

     

     

    They make for fascinating reading.

     

     

    Fun fact: in addition to the book value of it’s playing squad as per the balance sheet, the directors of Leicester also provide an assessment of the market value of its playing squad.

     

     

    In May 2019 it was estimated at £481.6m.

     

     

    By May 2023 it was estimated at £226.3m.

  24. BRRB

     

     

    lol.

     

     

    Gene

     

     

    Re BR

     

     

    For clarity I loved what the guy did for us when he first came.

     

     

    His work professionalism, experience, dedication and work ethic were incredible. Friends and family members who were involved in the football department at that time could not have praised him highly enough.

     

     

    He gave my mum her last great Celtic day when we beat Aberdeen at the Invincible Cup Final. We had a great night back at CP after a really fantastic week of Celtic celebrations in a season when the Huns were returning to top tier with momentum.

     

     

    Lots to be thankful for and I was gutted when he had to go but knew that time would come. I recall hearing rumours he was going when I got on a flight in Houston and by the time I got to London he was gone. I wasn’t bitter like many then and tbh felt it was likely at some point. Lenny built on decent foundations the guy left and saw us to treble 3 and 4.

     

     

    The second coming was a very different one and his entire MO was very different.

     

     

    Divisive, Defensive and nothing like the energy and work ethic.

     

     

    Perhaps this was because he was inheriting a Celtic team from a manager who was successful playing a high energy high tempo style and who had just won a treble doing so. Perhaps it was because he hadn’t evolved as a coach and got complacent buying success at Leicester. Perhaps his ego was a wee bit bruised.

     

     

    Whatever the reason his second term has destroyed our club in driving deep division and mistrust into a club which had experienced a sustained peak of its potential (in such a small backwater) for 2 decades.

     

     

    I see both DD and BR as equally culpable.

     

     

    Of course much about the club is wrong beyond this and a modernisation of coms and upgrade of stadium should not have to be dragged out of the club leadership. An evolution of board members should be a no brainer and a proper recognition of the breadth of PL role and need for planned succession should have been in place from end of Ange season 1 but these things were missed and it is easy to say them from the outside.

     

     

    Fundamentally though I believe BR 2 divided the club and his primary motive was himself. I do hope that detail on this emerges in the public domain. Although in also realise that as with the unequivocal facts I shared re our CL opponents in 24/5 many will chose to disbelieve.

  1. Pages:
  2. 1
  3. 2
  4. 3
  5. 4