Lessons for picking a manager

1010

Back in January we discussed Mauricio Pochettino, who yesterday left Southampton to become manager of Tottenham Hotspur.  He is without question the hottest management property in the most bloated league in football.

He was also an unemployed flop a little over a year ago.

In reality, Pochettino is a good manager but he is also the latest in a long line of faux guru-managers, the aura of divinity around him is illusionary.  He was sacked by Espanyol in December 2012 with the club bottom of La Liga after 13 games, after propelling them up the league from a similar position two years earlier.  Espanyol’s problems were not Pochettino’s problems.  The club strategy had been failing for years, Pochettino was not the first manager to suffer as a consequence, in fact, he was the club’s third manager in a season when he took over.

He joined Southampton, who were on a different trajectory.  Southampton have been producing some of the best youth talent in the UK for a decade but a series of self-harming boardroom battles saw the club competing in the third tier of English football.  In Nigel Adkins the found a man who won two consecutive promotions and had them comfortable in the Premier League.

Then, in January last year, Southampton made one of the ballsy-est decisions in football history.  They sacked the successful Adkins and replaced him with the aforementioned unemployed flop.

Chairman Nicola Cortese, who was an outsider to the football industry, figured that Adkins could only take the club so far and that, with the appointment of a man in-tune with the new strategy, Southampton could make a real breakthrough at the top of the Premiership.

Pochettino did what Cortese wanted, not through obligation, but through instinct.  Unfortunately for Southampton, Markus Liebharr, who appointed Cortese, died, and his daughter-and-heir, Katharine, figured the family had spent enough of their fortune on an English football club.  With strategy tending towards a breakeven point, Cortese resigned.  It was inevitable that Pochettino would follow.

What are the lessons for us?

Forget looking for a guru, it’s all about the strategy.  Get the strategy right, only employ people who are instinctively aligned to it, and employ an intelligent, tactical student, even if he can’t speak the language.

CQN Event in London

Lisbon Lion John Hughes is joining Brogan Rogan, Auldheid and Angela Haggerty for a CQN Question and Answer evening at the Manor Club, Wimbledon, on 21 June.  The event is ticket only, so let me know if you would like to attend, celticquicknews@gmail.com

Visit the CQN Bookstore to get Tommy Gemmell to sign your personal copy of his tome, All the Best.

[calameo code=000390171873c910154bd lang=en page=106 hidelinks=1 width=100% height=500]
Click Here for Comments >
Share.

About Author

1,010 Comments
  1. Pages:
  2. 1
  3. ...
  4. 7
  5. 8
  6. 9
  7. 10
  8. 11
  9. 12
  10. 13
  11. ...
  12. 27

  1. Greensideup is also Neil Lennon and supports Wee Oscar

     

     

    19:23 on 28 May, 2014

     

     

    Why was the sharp suited man in Holland on the weekend, signing Virgil to a new contract or seeing one of the deBoer’s, hmmmm

     

    =================================================

     

     

    Is that rhyming slang?

  2. !!Bada Bing!! on

    greensideup is also neil lennon and supports wee oscar

     

     

    19:23 on 28 May, 2014

     

     

    Why was the sharp suited man in Holland on the weekend, signing Virgil to a new contract or seeing one of the deBoer’s, hmmmm

     

     

    HH

     

    gsu

     

     

    Trying to get the charges against the Dam Bhoys dropped?

  3. Good evening friends.

     

     

    Tell me I’m not the only one settling down in front of the telly with a Scotland jersey on. Scotland at minus 1, 7/1. Brown and Mulgrew start with Leigh on the bench. I assume Big Efe’s in Nigeria’s starting line up unless he’s currently responding to ACGR’s last email…

  4. http://www.fifpro.org/en/news/new-guide-to-tackle-match-fixing-in-football

     

     

    This is a real issue in the professional game in Scotland.

     

     

    Just as England are about to tighten the rules on players betting on matches (http://www.theguardian.com/sport/2014/may/21/footballers-betting-worldwide-ban-football-association), the Scottish msm, following on from the Ian Black cheating, were suggesting the rules were too tight in Scotland.

     

     

    “The relatively large number of players (32% – 27) who have knowingly bet against the rules is a cause for concern, especially as this may be an under-reported figure. More work needs to be done to address this issue.”

     

     

    I don’t think so. There should be no betting by those involved in professional football in Scotland. There are plenty of other outlets for them to lose their money.

  5. !!Bada Bing!! on

    Boyd ,who refused to play for Scotland,co-commentator on BBC1 @ 7.55,another hun in the media,just what we need…….

  6. At this stage I am not looking to be overwhelmed by the new managerial appointment. I do not want to be underwhelmed. I will settled for being simply whelmed when he arrives.

  7. twentyfirstofmaynineteenseventynine on

    Off topic

     

     

    Anyone feel we’ve let ourselves down with goalkeepers down the years ?

     

     

    In my time

     

     

    Simpson I wasn’t quite old enough, but obviously a legend

     

    Fallon Same as above, without the legendary status

     

    Williams Seemed ok, but again, I was young

     

    Connaghan Remember him saving pens v them in Dryburgh Cup Final, thought he was a good keeper

     

    Hunter Wasnt the worst but think he fecked up for Scotland

     

    Latchford Loved the big man, always remember him and Conroy at end of 77 Final

     

    Bonnar No doubt have a lot of fans on here, cost us too many big games (84 Cup Final for one) and couldnt manage one save in 90 Final v aberdeen yet got hero status with Ireland v Romania. Sorry Im still trying to get over that one

     

    Mcnight(mare) enough said

     

    Ian Andrews even worse than above

     

    Alan Rough If we could have got him sooner ?

     

    Gordon Marshall never a great keeper and proved his true colours in 2003

     

    Carl Muggleton Surely someone was noising us up

     

    Stewart Kerr ordinary at best

     

    Jonathan Gould Didnt mind Gould , thought he was ok

     

    Tony Warner Big guy had one really good season

     

    Rab Douglas 2003, cost us the league and the uefa, I know he has a lot of apologists on here but if you think of the 3-3 game at CP and the Final in Seville, to name just two then I think you have to admit that he cost us big time

     

    Magnuss Hedman Bayern Munich

     

    Broto Still think we’d have won in Seville, and won the League if MON hadnt taken the hump with him, for whatever reason it was. I love MON but I feel his biggest mistake was sticking with RD

     

    David Marshall £15m ?

     

    Boruc Love the Holy Goalie

     

     

    Sorry for the boring goalies post

     

     

    HH

  8. theglasgowcelticway on

    Roy Keane? Not totally overjoyed if that is the case but I wasn’t delighted either when Lennon was appointed.

  9. 7.04pm

     

     

    Cowie ‘You Heard it Here First’ Bhoy strikes an early blow in the CQN Telt Yeez stakes.

     

     

    ;-)))

     

     

    HH jamesgang

  10. My take on this – I’m confused. I can’t make my mind up

     

     

    The trouble with any young, ‘foreign’ coach is that they will be destroyed by the dark forces at work here – media, SFA, refs, Sevco etc.

     

     

    Rules out Morten et al, sadly. I also think it rules out the Quiet Man, Steve Clarke, who I think is the best coach. What we need is a manager with balls as big as Lenny’s and going by the way DD does business, someone who he knows the bones of. MON, WGS etc. Malky would understand the lie of the land, but he will wait for the EPL. £1m + salary at Cardiff (guessing here) to £300,000 with us up the road? Dunno.

     

     

    Enter Roy Keane. Never takes a backward step, and someone who DD will be able to control. Would he relocate his brood (and Trigger) to Glasgow? Doubtful.

     

     

    Therefore, I conclude, I have no idea who it will be….

     

     

    Does anyone think Neil will be left on the shelf in the current merry-go-round? Possibly. West Brom say no, and I doubt he’ll get Southampton. Shame really, as I think he’s a good manager and a good guy

  11. ....PFayr supports WeeOscar on

    21stMay

     

     

    MON didn’t take the hump with Broto …he wasn’t allowed to sign him …financial reasons

  12. valentinesday on

    twentyfirstofmaynineteenseventynine

     

     

    Boruc was the most talented goalie I’ve seen

     

    playing for the hoops…..still in utter shock and

     

    disbelief he never made it into the CQteN side.

  13. Jamesgang

     

     

    Believe me, nothing but a pure guess,

     

     

    Now how is our friend ACGR doing in the £5 gamble :-)

     

     

    Hail Hail

  14. Efe not in the starting XI as he’s been up all night trying to Google ACGR’s mother’s maiden name

  15. blantyretim is praying for the Knox family on

    Stewart kerr was another keeper who came through the ranks

  16. the long wait is over on

    Given that DD will ultimately decide who the next manager is Roy Keane would seem the most likely candidate.

     

     

    As far as being a Celtic / Manchester utd fan it’s irrelevant but , at the same time , perfectly possible that he’s both.

     

     

    He did speak highly of us in his autobiography and chose to play for us when he could have gone pretty much anywhere he wanted.

     

     

    Whether it was a success for us and or him is another matter but , personally , I loved seeing him in the hoops , especially at Ibrox when he took the entire rangers midfield to school.

     

     

    And he was at Seville. I saw him myself after the game right outside the ground. He looked as gutted as the rest of us.

  17. Cowiebhoy

     

     

    He’s been stung by his son!

     

    That would be the perfect end to this hilarious tale!

     

    Reckon the big ghuy’s radio silence means he’s taken it to new level and had gone Rambo to find him!

     

     

    Jobo. When you come onto CQN and say hello to everyone it’s a bit like norm arriving in Cheers. Albeit a far slimmer, meteorlogically-aware version!

     

     

    HH jamesgang

  18. twentyfirstofmaynineteenseventynine on

    CelticRay knew I’d forget some and he’s definitely one I’d have liked us to hang on to

     

     

    PF Ive always been under the impression that MON had a fall out with him, I’m glad to hear its not the case

     

     

    valentinesday He could still come back (Celtic or CQteN) ?

     

     

    HH

  19. Bada

     

     

    you did know Celtic let Given leave and kept Stewart Kerr?

     

     

    I think that was definitely a case of letting ourselves down on GK position.

  1. Pages:
  2. 1
  3. ...
  4. 7
  5. 8
  6. 9
  7. 10
  8. 11
  9. 12
  10. 13
  11. ...
  12. 27