Great teams can defend anywhere

779

Good teams can score anywhere.  Great teams can defend anywhere.  Celtic have set a modern time record for lowest goals conceded in a league campaign of 17, beating the record jointly held by Martin O’Neill’s Celtic 13 years ago, and by Alex Ferguson’s Aberdeen in the 80s, by a single goal.

This is a remarkable achievement but the bald fact hides another story.  We conceded 12 times in their first 17 league games of the campaign, but conceded only five in the remaining 21 games:

St Johnstone scored with a rebound after Gordon saved.
St Johnstone scored when Danny Swanson fired unstoppable shot.
Inverness scored with a rebound after Johansen blocked on line.
Kilmarnock scored a deflection from shot from outside box.
Dundee scored from a move which opened Celtic defence.

Unstoppable shots, or deflections, from outside the box are, from a defensive organisation perspective, irrelevant.  If someone ‘buys a lottery ticket’ with a low percentage shot and it ends up in the net, you’ve no remedial action to worry about.

Two rebounds ended up in the net.  We don’t make many goal-line clearances, by keeper or defender, so reacting to the second ball is worth doing when opponents get inside the Celtic box.  Dundee scored an 87th minute consolation in a game they were completely out-thought.  Perhaps a momentary lapse from a Celtic team who thought their work was done for the day.

That 17 goal tally, a record which stretches back 96 years, is largely a story of the last six months, but it’s been a different story in cup games over the same period, where we’ve conceded eight in eight games.

The roof fell in over in the first half against Inter Milan at Celtic Park.  While the three goals could be put down to bizarre mistakes I suspect the real story is that we didn’t have the game-plan right for an opponent of that standard.  The remaining game and a half against Inter was different, where we conceded only a single ‘lottery ticket’ goal.

Dundee United scored with a disputed penalty (let’s not get started) and Inverness scored three against 10 man Celtic.  Those three Inverness goals contrast so sharply with the rest of the season that you could conclude that we don’t have a robust game-plan for playing with 10 men against domestic opposition.  The earlier 10-man performance at the San Siro was a different (much better) story, but tactics for Inter Milan and for Inverness will always be so different they are not worth comparing.

The loss of Jason Denayer and potential loss of Virgil van Dijk provides Ronny with a real challenge to maintain or improve the defence next season, but as you will know if you’ve been paying attention for the last 10 months, it’s all about systems, not players, so there’s a lot to be hopeful about going forward…….. apart from the fact that the only goals we’ve conceded since the middle of December in all competitions were to players wearing blue or orange!

Happy Lisbon Lions Day!

Click Here for Comments >
Share.

About Author

779 Comments

  1. 67Heaven .. CHALLENGING THE LIE ..I am wee Oscar...... Ipox belongs to the creditors on

    tonydonnelly67

     

     

    11:42 on 26 May, 2015

     

     

    Naw, Motherwell will hump them, and I will need a sedative….!!!!

  2. celticforever on

    karma is when scott macdonald scores the winning goal for motherwell against sevco this sunday

  3. LiviBhoy 09: 58

     

     

    Someone (I think it was thunder road apols if not) said they admire when people say what they wanted to but more eloquently(or something like that)

     

     

    your post made me feel like that……….exactly what I would like to but could never write

     

     

    HH

  4. Livibhoy

     

     

    You’re probably right about the cost of Boruc. Would have been nice to see him come home.

     

    Not sure about a replacement for Zaluska, maybe just give him another deal for a year?

  5. Thunder Road on

    Not seen petec on since our game.

     

    He got a Paradise windfall ticket just before we went through the turnstiles but his ticket had 666 in the code!

     

    Got a picture in my head of him locked in a room filled with candles and sitting cross legged on the floor inside a pentagram. lol :)

  6. Ernie Lynch

     

     

    Celtic have no authority on the matter.

     

     

    There is no point it being pointed out that the FIFA magazine carries no authority to make any statement they issue either factual or an official FIFA ruling, then using another non authority to support the opposite case.

     

     

    Same applies to ECA, ASA etc, even to the CQN SH advert. So whilst Celtic making a statement would no doubt satisfy supporters that Celtic support their view, in the grand scheme of putting the record straight it would matter not one jot.

     

     

    Weighing up the benefit of such a statement that would change nothing in real terms and the cost in terms of how it would be used to portray Celtic who have no authority on the matter, I can understand why Celtic say no more on than they did (via the SLO I believe).

     

     

    The SFA have the authority if the member clubs mandate them to make a statement (you see the problem there) that would carry weight but, in the absence of any will for the commercial reasons you state to do so, the SFA will say nothing.

     

     

    UEFA’S stance on clubs suffering as RFC did is contained in Art12 of UEFA FFP where clubs have to have at least three years national association membership to be an eligible club AS UEFA DEFINE A CLUB to play in a UEFA competition.

     

     

    Now if somehow an answer could be solicited from UEFA with regard to from when TRFC would become eligible to play in Europe should they qualify on sporting merit then we might get somewhere.

     

     

    As I recall Phil Mac tried this approach only to get a stock referal to UEFA rules because UEFA would not comment on a specific club.

     

     

    I think that a better understanding of the overall governance system within which Celtic have to operate would be beneficial in adding balance to some of the criticisms Celtic face but that is something for the Celtic PR to address.

     

     

    However if I were them I would counter with the question what difference would it make? Some attitudes are set in concrete.

     

     

    Someone mentioned a question at the AGM. A question would carry no real weight.

     

     

    It would require a resolution to be tabled to get an answer.

     

     

    I think I have just given it at the start.

  7. BOBBY MURDOCH'S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS on

    AULDHEID 1202

     

     

    Celtic are damned if they do and damned if they don’t.

     

     

    IMO they genuinely believed that there was no need for them to voice any disapproval of their zombification. Due process would take care of that.

     

     

    There was and is a raft of legal obstacles barring their way from becoming what the want to be. Which is Continuity Rangers(!)

     

     

    Whodathunk that the Scottish Establishment would permit such a travesty of justice?

     

     

    Tbh,I didnt. And I don’t think Celtic did either.

  8. BMCUWP

     

     

    Scottish football went through the looking glass after RFC were liquidated.

     

     

    Same club.

     

     

    Did nothing wrong but one long series of clerical error

     

     

    No sporting advantage.

     

     

    Things like illegal ebts and their impact airbrushed from history.

     

     

    Documents witheld . Read this

     

     

    http://www.sfm.scot/sfm-the-next-steps/comment-page-14/#comment-55545

     

     

     

    You would think none of this happened in Scot La La land.

  9. Auldheid,

     

    You say that RFC withheld the letters, have you considered they were instructed to do this by the SFA ?

  10. up_over_goal on

    name              number             number

     

     

    longer name              number             number

  11. up_over_goal on

    name              number             number

     

     

    longer name         number             number

  12. up_over_goal on

    name              number             number

     

     

    longer name       number             number

  13. up_over_goal on

    name              number             number

     

     

    longer name     number             number

  14. up_over_goal on

    name              number             number

     

     

    longer name   number             number

  15. up_over_goal on

    Player              Minutes per goal/assist             Minutes played/goals & assists

  16. up_over_goal on

    Player            Minutes per goal/assist           Minutes played/goals & assists

  17. up_over_goal on

    Player           Minutes per goal/assist        Minutes played/goals & assists

  18. up_over_goal on

    Player         Minutes per goal/assist      Minutes played/goals & assists

  19. up_over_goal on

    Player         Minutes per goal/assist      Minutes played/goals & assists

     

     

    Pukki             67             200/3

     

    Guidetti        79             1965/25/3

  20. up_over_goal on

    Pukki             67             200/3

     

    Guidetti         79             1965/25

  21. up_over_goal on

    Pukki             67             200/3

     

    Guidetti         79             1965/25/3

     

    Fisher          79             1965/25/3

  22. up_over_goal on

    Player         Minutes per goal/assist      Minutes played/goals & assists

     

     

    Pukki             67             200/3

     

    Guidetti         79             1965/25

     

    Fisher           98             195/2

     

    Griffiths        100            2295/23

     

    Stokes           113            2610/23

     

    Commons          128            2945/23

     

    Berget           135            405/3

     

    Scepovic         150            1050/7

     

    Mackay-Steven    167            1000/6

     

    Johansen         187            4850/26

     

    Forrest          195            1560/8

     

    Mcgregor         222            2000/9

     

    Wakaso           245            735/3

     

    Henderson        258            515/2

     

    O’Connell        270            270/1

     

    Lustig           290            1160/4

     

    Armstrong        303            1210/4

     

    Van Dijk         320            5120/16

     

    Matthews         365            2920/8

     

    Brown            389            4280/11

     

    Tonev            495            495/1

     

    Izaguirre        507            5070/10

     

    Denayer          547            3830/7

     

    Bitton           668            3340/5

     

    Mulgrew          770            1540/2

     

    Ambrose          798            3190/4

     

     

    Players with no goals/assists     Minutes played

     

     

    Gordon              4560

     

    Zaluska             515

     

    Kayal               500

     

    Forster             360

     

    Mcgeough            90

     

    Boerrigter          70

     

    Tierney             70

     

    Twardzik            45

  23. up_over_goal on

    Player         Minutes per goal/assist      Minutes played/goals & assists

     

     

    Pukki                         67                         200/3

     

    Guidetti                     79                         1965/25

     

    Fisher                        98             195/2

     

    Griffiths                   100                        2295/23

     

    Stokes                     113                        2610/23

     

    Commons                   128                        2945/23

     

    Berget                      135                        405/3

     

    Scepovic                   150                        1050/7

     

    Mackay-Steven 167                        1000/6

     

    Johansen                  187                        4850/26

     

    Forrest                     195                        1560/8

     

    Mcgregor                  222                        2000/9

     

    Wakaso                    245                        735/3

     

    Henderson                258                        515/2

     

    O’Connell                 270                        270/1

     

    Lustig                      290                        1160/4

     

    Armstrong                 303                        1210/4

     

    Van Dijk                   320                        5120/16

     

    Matthews                  365                        2920/8

     

    Brown                      389                        4280/11

     

    Tonev                       495                        495/1

     

    Izaguirre                  507                        5070/10

     

    Denayer                   547                        3830/7

     

    Bitton                       668                        3340/5

     

    Mulgrew                   770                        1540/2

     

    Ambrose                  798            3190/4

     

     

    Players with no goals/assists     Minutes played

     

     

    Gordon                          4560

     

    Zaluska                           515

     

    Kayal                              500

     

    Forster                            360

     

    Mcgeough                         90

     

    Boerrigter                        70

     

    Tierney                            70

     

    Twardzik                         45

  24. up_over_goal on

    Player         Minutes per goal/assist      Minutes played/goals & assists

     

     

    Pukki                         67                         200/3

     

    Guidetti                     79                         1965/25

     

    Fisher                       98                    195/2

     

    Griffiths                   100                         2295/23

     

    Stokes                    113                        2610/23

     

    Commons                128                        2945/23

     

    Berget                     135                         405/3

     

    Scepovic                 150                         1050/7

     

    Mackay-Steven     167                         1000/6

     

    Johansen                187                         4850/26

     

    Forrest                    195                         1560/8

     

    Mcgregor                222                         2000/9

     

    Wakaso                  245                          735/3

     

    Henderson             258                         515/2

     

    O’Connell               270                          270/1

     

    Lustig                     290                         1160/4

     

    Armstrong              303                         1210/4

     

    Van Dijk                 320                         5120/16

     

    Matthews               365                          2920/8

     

    Brown                    389                          4280/11

     

    Tonev                    495                           495/1

     

    Izaguirre                507                          5070/10

     

    Denayer                547                          3830/7

     

    Bitton                     668                          3340/5

     

    Mulgrew                770                          1540/2

     

    Ambrose               798                      3190/4

     

     

    Players with no goals/assists     Minutes played

     

     

    Gordon                                    4560

     

    Zaluska                                     515

     

    Kayal                                         500

     

    Forster                                      360

     

    Mcgeough                                  90

     

    Boerrigter                                   70

     

    Tierney                                       70

     

    Twardzik                                     45

  25. up_over_goal on

    Player         Minutes per goal/assist      Minutes played/goals & assists

     

     

    Pukki                         67                                     200/3

     

    Guidetti                     79                                   1965/25

     

    Fisher                        98                                  195/2

     

    Griffiths                   100                                   2295/23

     

    Stokes                     113                                  2610/23

     

    Commons               128                                  2945/23

     

    Berget                     135                                    405/3

     

    Scepovic                 150                                   1050/7

     

    Mackay-Steven      167                                   1000/6

     

    Johansen                187                                   4850/26

     

    Forrest                    195                                   1560/8

     

    Mcgregor                222                                   2000/9

     

    Wakaso                   245                                    735/3

     

    Henderson              258                                    515/2

     

    O’Connell               270                                    270/1

     

    Lustig                     290                                   1160/4

     

    Armstrong              303                                   1210/4

     

    Van Dijk                  320                                   5120/16

     

    Matthews               365                                    2920/8

     

    Brown                    389                                    4280/11

     

    Tonev                     495                                     495/1

     

    Izaguirre                507                                    5070/10

     

    Denayer                 547                                    3830/7

     

    Bitton                     668                                    3340/5

     

    Mulgrew                 770                                    1540/2

     

    Ambrose                798                                   3190/4

     

     

    Players with no goals/assists     Minutes played

     

     

    Gordon                                              4560

     

    Zaluska                                               515

     

    Kayal                                                  500

     

    Forster                                                360

     

    Mcgeough                                            90

     

    Boerrigter                                             70

     

    Tierney                                                 70

     

    Twardzik                                              45

  26. up_over_goal on

    Player         Minutes per goal/assist      Minutes played/goals & assists

     

     

    Pukki                         67                                     200/3

     

    Guidetti                     79                                   1965/25

     

    Fisher                       98                                     195/2

     

    Griffiths                   100                                   2295/23

     

    Stokes                    113                                   2610/23

     

    Commons               128                                  2945/23

     

    Berget                     135                                    405/3

     

    Scepovic                 150                                  1050/7

     

    Mackay-Steven       167                                   1000/6

     

    Johansen                187                                   4850/26

     

    Forrest                    195                                   1560/8

     

    Mcgregor                222                                   2000/9

     

    Wakaso                  245                                     735/3

     

    Henderson             258                                     515/2

     

    O’Connell               270                                     270/1

     

    Lustig                     290                                   1160/4

     

    Armstrong              303                                   1210/4

     

    Van Dijk                 320                                   5120/16

     

    Matthews               365                                   2920/8

     

    Brown                    389                                   4280/11

     

    Tonev                     495                                     495/1

     

    Izaguirre                 507                                   5070/10

     

    Denayer                 547                                    3830/7

     

    Bitton                      668                                    3340/5

     

    Mulgrew                 770                                    1540/2

     

    Ambrose                798                                    3190/4

     

     

    Players with no goals/assists               Minutes played

     

     

    Gordon                                                        4560

     

    Zaluska                                                         515

     

    Kayal                                                             500

     

    Forster                                                          360

     

    Mcgeough                                                       90

     

    Boerrigter                                                        70

     

    Tierney                                                            70

     

    Twardzik                                                          45