Madden semi-final ref, what were the odds?

1107

What were the odds of Bobby Madden being appointed referee for our Scottish Cup semi-final against Newco?  Fairly short, I would imagine.  All we want from Bobby is a fair crack of the whip.  When a Newco player lunges with both feet off the ground at Patrick Roberts, we don’t expect him to be distracted by checking his watch.  When Leigh Griffiths is taken down, waist high, inside the box, before his opponent can get near the ball, we expect a penalty.

Such expectations were not on the coupon previously but are not too much to ask.

Click Here for Comments >
Share.

About Author

1,107 Comments

  1. Watching the Rangers game v Dundee ( and other away teams ) it seems to me the away teams believe they have a chance at Ibrox therefore play a different style than when they visit Celtic Park .

     

    They know if they leave space in behind Celtic have the capability and quality to tear them apart .

     

    Tomorrow will most likely be another tight game ……hopefully get a win , my usual wee bet of 4-1 the Tic it has to come up soon …shoorly :)

  2. Aidans game is cancelled Tomorrow, although I’m a bit disappointed about that it means we get to see the Glasgow Celtic on a Sunday.

     

     

    I’m hoping for a bit more intent in our play. With the cameras there *LIVE* Celtic will be Free to do what they wanna do.

     

     

    Loaded.CSC

  3. What is the Stars on

    As I said perhaps a lonely guy who has issues

     

     

    Surely we can find it in our hearts to tolerate him.

  4. Gerryfaethebrig on

    Well that’s the Voice finished, after watching Dec & … Dec

     

     

    what’s happening in Celtic cyber space, 6ts fae a Henrik of league titles

     

     

    I take it that MIT is one of the 10 LMSers that plumped for the Sevs today :-)

     

     

    Philbhoy you might have let us know you had “am empty” could have had a Bo’ness boot :-)

  5. WITS

     

     

    Agree completely!

     

     

    If he comes to the next Hoot we can have a manly hug and a good chat.

  6. mike in toronto on

    Gearoid

     

     

    How ya keeping?

     

     

    What happened with the BAC? Shame … as I really enjoyed watching the games there.

     

     

    Glad you sorted out the Rory thing for me … it was what I had thought, but someone posted he was a Tim (or I may have misread it). I can now happily go back to hoping he loses! Cheers!

  7. Huns have scored 67, we’ve scored 62. Brendan’s message to the players to tomorrow….don’t come off the pitch with less than 5 goals scored. We’ve scored 7 in our last 2 matches there, pitch isn’t an issue.

  8. BMCUW/BIG PACKY…

     

     

    Pub should have been ludge;))

     

     

    Ask Marspapa or ACGR about the size of Caesar, he eats more than us and is forever boxing with the magpies.

     

    M I’ll let you know by the end of the week about Belfast mate. HH

  9. mike in toronto on

    JNP

     

     

    Good thing for you guys we no longer get paid by the word, or my already long-winded posts would be even longer!

  10. Phyllis Dietrichson on

    WITS – got a strong shout for Darling du Large in the last at Aintree on Thursday.

  11. BOBBY MURDOCH'S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS on

    WHATISTHESTARS

     

     

    Is the lovely TW letting you off the leash for Belfast on 9/6,or are you on a tight rein?

     

     

    There’s a few women coming along,she won’t be on her own.

  12. Evenin’ all. I don’t know if this has been commented upon already, and I can’t be bothered reading back to find out… but, the comparative stats from this week’s home matches for Sevco and Celtic at home to Dundee are as follows:

     

     

    Possession:

     

    Sevco 49% – 51% Dundee

     

    Celtic 66% – 34% Dundee

     

     

    Shots at goal:

     

    Sevco 14 – 12 Dundee

     

    Celtic 26 – 1 Dundee

     

     

    Shots on target:

     

    Sevco 6 – 3 Dundee

     

    Celtic 7 – 1 Dundee

     

     

    Corners:

     

    Sevco 6 – 4 Dundee

     

    Celtic 11 – 2 Dundee

     

     

    Result:

     

    Sevco 4 – 0 Dundee

     

    Celtic 0 – 0 Dundee

     

     

    Am I the only one who thinks there is something seriously awry there?!!!

     

     

    Moussa Dembele has been widely touted for a £30M transfer to some of Europe’s top clubs, while Celtic are said to be seriously considering paying £7M for Odsonne Edouard in the summer… and Leigh Griffiths was until recently a 40 goals-a-season striker, yet Celtic set up against Dundee with just one striker.

     

     

    Sevco meanwhile put out a team with three strikers, the readily ridiculed Morelos, much maligned Murphy and 38 year old Kenny Miller.

     

     

    It surely isn’t that surprising then that Sevco scored four times whilst Celtic failed to breach the normally porous Dundee defence (the SPL’s 3rd highest goals conceded per game).

     

     

    There appears to be something seriously wrong with Celtic’s strikers at the moment and it needs fixing soon, or we won’t be getting anywhere near the CL groups next season. Perhaps we should just let Dembele and Edouard go at the end of the season and sign Alex Schalk and Alfredo Morelos to replace them!

  13. What has Ernie done that is so wrong ?

     

     

    Ok we don’t agree with him , but hey , has he broken any blog rules ? IMO the blog needs some debate on quiet days like today.

     

    Sometimes its like a form of McCarthyism on here. It’s a blog; live and let live.

     

     

    Anyway as a side issue , I would wager that there are many posters on here today who have a substantial CQN “ disciplinary “ record . And Mr or Mrs Ernie is not one of them.

     

     

    HH bring on the Accies

  14. Glendalystonsils.

     

    You nearly had me there. After you saying last night you were desperate to see one.

     

    Big Packy. Thanks buddy. I posted to you at 9.31, don’t know if you seen it about your dog’s.

     

    As for health issues, I just have to keep on going on as D.D correctly says.

     

    If any of you are interested enough, I won’t be offended in the slightest if you are not, you can Google my illness, it’s called Mast Cell Activation Syndrome.

     

    Seriously, last time the new G.P. said to me, I know nothing about your illness, you will have to educate me. I genuinely admired her honestly but it can be a lonely old illness.

     

    Right I’m away. I will scroll back in the morning.

     

    Hail Hail and thanks to all for their kind words and support.

  15. DD

     

     

    Garry try and relax mate, don’t get upset with clowns like, well you know who.

     

    Family are enjoyable, Celtic are enjoyable, friends are enjoyable and CQN is enjoyable so let’s enjoy each other’s company and anyone who try’s to poo poo any of the aforementioned can feck off.. Hail Hail mate.

     

    Only my opinion mind

     

     

    D. :)

  16. DAVID 17…

     

     

    Reckon Brendan knows the score.

     

    We have been sloppy lately but I’m sure we will see a lot sharper performance tomorrow.

  17. BOBBY MURDOCH'S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS on

    MIKEINTORONTO

     

     

    No payment by the word? That’s pish,man. I’d just sent you my year-end bill for reading yer bollox.

     

     

    See lawyers and accountants,make poor people of us all.

  18. Delaneys Dunky on

    BMCUW

     

     

    Any single ladies in Belfast. Had a dream last night that I met a colleen and moved to Belfast to live. Vivid. :)

  19. Jimmynotpaul

     

     

    Try and stay strong fella, I know that is easy for me to say.

     

    I will say a wee prayer tonight (hope I don’t offend you) for you and all the sick cqn’rs.

     

    GNAGB

     

     

    D. :)

  20. SIPSINI on 7TH APRIL 2018 10:16 PM

     

    DAVID 17…

     

     

    ——-

     

    Hope so. anything else will concern.

  21. Ernie disclosed many year’s ago he was a twitcher…

     

     

    His line that Occam’s Razor is the best explanation of the Skripals and UK Govt is on the money has been the most convincing argument put forward so far.

     

     

    Howevah

     

     

    What happens if you apply Occam’s Razor to Scottish Football refereeing?

     

     

    Dougie Dougie made an honest mistake

     

     

    McLean missed a hand ball and so did his assistants

     

     

    Lennon never fouled in the hun box

     

     

    Same argument would suggest referees are either honest mistakers or just poor

     

     

    There is no collusion at SFA towers

     

     

    Our understanding now is that far from being paranoid internet bampots we were not in fact paranoid enough

     

     

    So, is there any merit in not being paranoid enough in relation to the Skripals?

     

     

    Mmmmm

  22. BOBBY MURDOCH'S CURLED-UP WINKLEPICKERS on

    JIMMYNOTPAUL

     

     

    Seriously,your acceptance of your condition and refusal to let it define you cheers me up in one or two not as bad as yours and grow up moments that I get these days.

     

     

    Thanks,T. Perspective is indeed everything.

  23. Incidentally, I just checked the BBC match report from our away game against PSG. They had 63% possession and 24 shots at our goal, both figures lower than ours against Dundee, and PSG won 7-1! All we have to do is spend 400M euros on a couple of strikers and a half decent midfielder and we’ll have it sorted, I reckon.

  24. JNP, sort to hear you are under the weather again; I’ll light a candle for you tomorrow!

     

     

     

    KTF

  25. Greenpinata on 7th April 2018 10:14 pm

     

     

    What has Ernie done that is so wrong ?

     

    Ok we don’t agree with him , but hey , has he broken any blog rules ? IMO the blog needs some debate on quiet days like today.

     

     

    Sometimes its like a form of McCarthyism on here. It’s a blog; live and let live.

     

    ———–

     

    Agree, this site is dull as hell these days (including match days) only gets interesting when there’s a barney. And it must be the only site on the internet that’s so tightly policed, I hope some of the more sensitive souls on here don’t venture elsewhere :O)

  26. BIGCHIPSUK – 10 IN A ROW (2001-2010) on 7TH APRIL 2018 10:14 PM

     

     

     

    Is there any way of finding the corners to goals ratio for teams in the SPFL?

     

     

    I suspect it would be quite interesting.

  27. Gordon

     

     

     

     

    Hendry

     

    Ajer

     

    Boyata

     

     

    Brown

     

     

    Ntcham

     

    Armstrong

     

    Mcgregor

     

    Roberts

     

     

    Griffith’s

     

    Dembele

  28. Jist gie Jeremy the keys

     

    As of then, there will be no more….

     

    Illegal wars

     

    Warmongering arms sales

     

    Homeless

     

    Or,….

     

    Poverty

     

    Or,…

     

    Social inequality

     

    Or,..

     

    Illegal Isreal

     

    Or,….

     

    Illegal six counties annexed in Ireland

     

    Or,….

     

    Under the radar operatives from ibrokes

     

    And,…..

     

    Scottish folk will be offered the right to vote for independence from what will by then be referred to as, former cruel England

     

    And,….

     

    Irish folk will also be granted the same

     

    Don’t ask me to explain how Jeremy Corbyn will do all of the above, because, he jist wull. That’s awe ye need to know. K.

     

    …….oot.

  29. What is the Stars on

    Phyllis Dietrichson

     

    Saw your earlier post thanks.

     

    Ger Lyons (trainer) has made a great start to the flat season in Ireland. Him and stable jockey Colin Keane are well worth following at the moment.

     

     

    BMCUWP

     

    Hoping to make Belfast. Problem is we are invited to a 40th in London on same night.

     

    The Belfast Agreement talks being held in the WITS house could rival the real thing.

  30. Bigchipsuk

     

    Those stats are not surprising ( and thanks for the football post :-)))

     

    I honestly think Brendan is using this season trying to get Celtic used to keeping possession, and in tight situations

     

    This has stifled our creativity in moving forward and creating opportunities up front for our 1 striker – hence the 9 draws this season

     

    Think we need to revert to our style of last season, with better movement and creativity up front

     

    And for playing in the SPFL, we should easily playing 3, 5, 2 in vast majority of games

     

    Need to change some players for fluency in this structure next season

     

     

    Hail Hail

     

    &

     

    FtSFA