Another dysfunctional league

644

The Football League in England have woken up to the notion that they do not have a working business model.  Solidarity payments from the FA Premier League’s new TV deal will earn Championship clubs £2.3m a season (considerably more than Celtic will receive from TV for winning the SPL), with League One sides earning £324k and League Two sides earning £250k.

Unfortunately, for those hoping to establish a well-balanced and competitive structure, parachute payment to those relegated from the Premier League will earn each club £69m (£23m in year one, £18m in year two and £9m in years three and four).

The Guardian report that today Championship clubs are expected to warn the Premier League that they risk permanently damaging the “integrity of the Football League” by increasing parachute payments to the proposed level.  An unusual case of a group asking for some of its members to receive less money.

The Football League doesn’t have a viable business model.  Clubs spend unsustainable amounts of money trying to attain the riches of the Premier League, where they can add zeros to both income and expenditure.  Most fail and many of them plummet down the divisions.  Even those who drop into the Championship with parachute payments (albeit at the old level) find deleveraging too difficult.

The SPL doesn’t have a viable business model either.  They should be talking to the Football League and see what benefits could accrue from working together.

10 years ago tonight:

Liverpool 0-2 Celtic

Bang! Celtic are in a European semi final.
[calameo code=000390171e93e6000b08d lang=en page=1 hidelinks=1 width=100% height=500]

Click Here for Comments >
Share.

About Author

644 Comments

  1. jude2005 is Neil Lennon \o/ on

    Andy said Alloa wd give up their place if the money was right! Bribery??

  2. TET

     

     

    I have been ever more negative about the future of Scottish football since the LNS verdict.

     

     

    You will know that I am not a natural conspiracy theorist and I do not credit the masons with as much power and influence as some do. That said, the FTT majority verdict and the glibly naive conclusions of LNS have discouraged me that there is any official and purposeful regulations working against them.

     

     

    I understand that old rangers cannot and will not pay back all that they owed. The consequence of that for me is that they are treated the same as Gretna, Airdrieonians and Third Lanark. If you are liquidated you cease to exisst and start again. Simplicuty itself. Plus that has the benefit of discouraging other clubs from playing fast and loose with their futures. There was no need for Dundee, Dunfermline, Hearts, Aberdeen, Motherwell, Killie and Livingston to buy players they could not afford. They cheated well run clubs like Celtic, united, Hibs and St. Johnstone who accepted the sporting consequences of only assembling a squad they could afford.

     

     

    Unless the Scottish football authorities confirm that they are a new club with no established sporting record, I am finished with the game. I don’t want corruption back at the table.

     

     

    I genuinely fear that this season may be my last unless this situation changes.

     

     

    starry plough

     

     

    I do not know if Andy is telling lies or not. That is why I ask the question- how do we at Celtic benefit from letting this lie spread? I am not asking them to say anything provocative about Sevco. I am asking them to call out Walker & Keevins so that they do not stand a chance of being believed.

     

     

    BTW, Andy Walker has one thing in his favour. He is one of the few pundits who meets my minimal challenge in that he always refers to them as a new club with a discontinued timeline. After saying that, mind you, he wants them back in the top flight because he feels we cannot afford sporting integrity.

     

     

    If things can be shown to be as dire as Andy says, I would accept his line. Let Rangers back in a top division but confirm that they are a new club with no official history of achievmeent. I don’t care if all the Rangers fans, Charles green and Ally go on believing otherwise so long as the official football record of this country states the truth i.e. Sevco will have one trophy to their name at the end of this season making a grand total of one trophy in their overall history.

  3. tommytwiststommyturns

     

    23:02 on

     

    20 March, 2013

     

    St Stivs – maybe they mixed us up?! Happy burfday to you!

     

     

    ———–

     

     

    some coincidende though eh.

     

     

    i dont think they mixed us up, particularly with me being chinese.

  4. Ntassoolla

     

    great idea

     

     

    why hasnt there been a fans survey conducted.similar to last years one..that told the chairmen of scottish football where to shuv yir sb’s if sevco are fast tracked??surely now is the time before this meet on 15/4..or isnt there the same feelings as last time…got away with a poxy transfer ban..haaaa

     

    got away with fft…haaaa

     

    got away with lns…bigger haaaa

     

    i dont understand cfc

  5. setting free the bears

     

     

    Walker wouldn’t be on there if he was saying what most Celtic fans think, indeed most football fans in Scotland think about Sevco. I never usually listen to SSB but have caught it for the past few nights – they have tried everything they can from touting Neil Lennon for the Blackburn job to putting forward the notion that they should only agree to being fast tracked IF the transfer ban is lifted.

     

     

    Walker is entitled to his opinion but it is tainted because he is being paid to be part of their propaganda machine which since their demise has become increasingly blatant and partisan. It is with this in mind that I am a little surprised at you falling into one of their traps.

     

     

    Celtic are not the establishment club. Our enemies understand that one way to weaken our collective resolve is to attack us in ways that they have done for generations. The Green Brigade have come under severe pressure this season from the forces of the establishment. Why?

     

    Because they wish to provoke a reaction. Remember their Poppy tactic. They wish to have Celt arguing with Celt. Get the Green Brigade annoyed and they will sooner or later hit out at the Directors and provoke a fissure that will be difficult to heal. Pro Green Brigade, anti Board etc when before they started all this we were pretty happy with both!

     

     

    We have talented people at our club. The manager who the board stood by when people on here wanted him gone, the players who have taken us to the last 16 in the Champions League and even on the board. And the support.

     

     

    I put a post on the CQN Magazine Facebook page yesterday asking if supporters booed Fergus the day he raised the flag that stopped TIAR. The answers are fascinating but most if not all accept that they were wrong and were played by the MSM – the very people who were playing with you tonight by buying in Walker’s “on message” opinions.

     

     

    We mustn’t pull defeat from the jaws of victory. We are miles ahead of Sevco and they are in danger of never catching us. In Fergus’ day he never had the likes of CQN, where supporters could discuss these issues – the support probably read hard hitting anti Fergus pieces in the Daily Record all summer and subsequently did Traynor’s booing for him. He must have been delighted, uttering on the phone to Murray, “job done boss!”

     

     

    I heard Walker. I don’t believe him but I think I know why he said it. We need to repel these people – they have shown they are powerful – look at the recent verdicts they have managed to achieve. Listen to their sense of entitlement on these phone-ins. From what I believe the Celtic directors wanted them exactly where they are and don’t want them back any quicker. And I personally am happy to go along with that view as it has been consistently expressed and it all adds up. I hope we as Celtic fans are able to recognise that we, whether we like it or not, are being dragged into their desperate fight for fast tracking/survival. If we can be undermined our club at the same time then it will be all the sooner they are back where they believe they belong.

     

     

    So when I read about them trying to shift Joe Ledley to Cardiff I don’t believe them. And when I see helicopters, and hundreds of Polis bullying young boys going to the game, I try to get my head around what they are really trying to achieve. I suggested to Paul today that we gather questions from the blog and put these to the Board and use on the blog and in the magazine. At least we will have these answers “for the record” and there will be no hidden anti-Celtic agendas.

     

     

    By the way I presume we both agree that Walker has talked himself out of any chance he had of making the CQN team of the 80s! Did you read the new magazine yet? We are very proud of that issue!

     

     

    Celtic are almost out of sight – let’s not waste it.

  6. celticrollercoaster loves Wee Oscar, our Celtic Warrior on

    setting free the bears

     

     

    just sent u link for 5s tomorrow

     

     

    HH

     

     

    CRC

  7. ArranmoreBhoyLXV11 on

    HH

     

     

    I love going to bed a Celtic supporter and waking up a Celtic supporter!!

     

     

    HH

  8. Andy Walker tonight said that it wasnt “bribery” it was just a commercial arrangement between two parties for the possible good of scottish football,

     

     

    tonight its been confirmed that Paris Saint German are the 2013 European Champions having agreed a commercial arrangement with all other clubs left in the competition.

     

     

    Walker sounds more like a paid employee with every broadcast.

  9. tommytwiststommyturns on

    St Stivs – aye, you’re about the right size for Kung Fu Panda! :-)

     

     

    T4

  10. celticrollercoaster loves Wee Oscar, our Celtic Warrior on

    tommytwiststommyturns

     

    23:02 on

     

    20 March, 2013

     

     

    CRC – her indoors will boot your erse!

     

     

    T4

     

     

    ———————-

     

     

    She is meant to make your wishes come true, not mine :-)

     

     

    HH

     

     

    CRC

  11. T4

     

    Your just a wean

     

     

    Oldtim

     

    After reading your response I nipped out to tesco… been thinking of swiching deodorant for a while… hoping this new stuff works ;)

  12. EK Bhoy

     

     

    I kinda expected a reply along those lines.

     

     

    For clarity, I do not want Celtic responding to every kite flown by a journo or pundit commenting on Sevco or the League. That would be daft.

     

     

    That is why I limited my request to only those statements where pundits and journos are stating that Celtic personnel have “confirmed” to them that this is their secret viewpoint.

     

     

    The Board do not have to confirm that what the pundit represented as their viewpoint is not actually their viewpoint. They merely need to confirm that the person has had no official or unofficial briefing from any Celtic Board insider. Then it is up to Andy Walker to prove otherwise.

     

     

    Let me give my clear unequivocal view. I do not believe that Andy is lying. I do believe that there are some on the Celtic Board who have expressed some views about accelerating the return of Sevco. These pundits are just too damn confident in their statements for me to believe otherwise.

     

     

    Here’s another prediction- I do not expect to hear a peep from Celtic officially on this matter. Which, for me, is sad.

  13. winning captains

     

    23:06 on

     

    20 March, 2013

     

     

     

    Excellent post – all Bhoys need to realise, we are in a war, and our enemies are trying to divide and conquer.

     

    Now more than ever we need to stand United, and we shall never be defeated..

     

     

    HAIL HAIL

  14. Winning Captains

     

     

    Apologies but… can you expand on following paragraph as I can’t quite determine whether it is a dig at MSM or GB?

     

     

    “Celtic are not the establishment club. Our enemies understand that one way to weaken our collective resolve is to attack us in ways that they have done for generations. The Green Brigade have come under severe pressure this season from the forces of the establishment. Why?

     

    Because they wish to provoke a reaction. Remember their Poppy tactic. They wish to have Celt arguing with Celt. Get the Green Brigade annoyed and they will sooner or later hit out at the Directors and provoke a fissure that will be difficult to heal. Pro Green Brigade, anti Board etc when before they started all this we were pretty happy with both!”

     

     

    MWD

  15. right offski,

     

     

    its all got to personal on here,

     

     

    i am away to cry into my pillow

     

     

    “i am not a panda, i am not a panda”

  16. celticrollercoaster loves Wee Oscar, our Celtic Warrior

     

    23:12 on

     

    20 March, 2013

     

    tommytwiststommyturns

     

    23:02 on

     

    20 March, 2013

     

     

    CRC – her indoors will boot your erse!

     

     

    T4

     

     

    ———————-

     

     

    She is meant to make your wishes come true, not mine :-)

     

     

     

    You must have really have pushed those bikes out at the weekend, and spoiled her

     

    Well done and enjoy

     

     

     

    Hail Hail

  17. Sftb

     

     

    I keep reading people on here talking about sevco returning to the spl

     

     

    You cant return to somewhere you aint been before

  18. sftb

     

     

    That was the answer I thought you would give, and was the answer I was hoping you wouldn’t give, sad that things have come this far.

     

     

    Oh for a juro that has the slightest bit of integrity, a juro that is looking to make a name for himself, how easy it would be to bring it all down if the infrastructure was in place to facilitate it, an honest editor and a couple of honest jurnos, that in this day isd obviously too much to ask.

     

     

    Maybes an alternative publication is called for, a paper that prides itself in telling the truth, a paper that investigate corruption, I would imagine it would do no bad in scotland.

  19. SFTB

     

     

    Mr Walker will just protect his source but state they are in a senior position, you can’t win because MSM deal with whispers, perception, what was not said, a colleague of 20 years assured me …..

     

     

    … it is all bananas …..

     

     

    By drawing attention to it, you become the target and the MSM’er the hero … even though there version of events is at best flawed and partial.

     

     

    Would you want Andy Walker in the celtic boardroom? Who do you trust more the Celtic Board or Andy Walker? if you believe it is the latter then we’ll call it a score draw.

     

     

    HH

  20. When DD gave the huns words of encouragement a few months ago was he being diplomatic or………i’m not sure.

  21. celticrollercoaster loves Wee Oscar, our Celtic Warrior on

    winning captains

     

     

    I think that SPLoB(Lawell) has blood on his hands re GB and if he has any scruples he will sort this out, one way or another.

     

     

    The sword is being sharpened, but he has the opportunity to play fair as does the GB.

     

     

    HH

     

     

    CRC

  22. winning captains

     

     

    23:06 on 20 March, 2013

     

     

    setting free the bears

     

     

    By the way I presume we both agree that Walker has talked himself out of any chance he had of making the CQN team of the 80s!

     

     

    Hasn’t even made the 25 man starting squad!

  23. Margaret McGill on

    It’s looking more and more likely that Celtic will play the NEW rangers in a competitive game one day. When that day occurs I am done with Celtic. A 125 year opportunity to instill integrity and honesty in the beautiful game by my life long love the beautiful Celtic is done. The symbol of all that is honest and just. When that day happens there is no alternative but to accept that there is nothing beautiful with Celtic anymore. They would have just become another bunch of money grabbers exploiting the faithful for a few quid.

     

    They should sue the SFA now. Finish Sevco off.

  24. 67Heaven ... I am Neil Lennon..!!.. Ibrox belongs to the creditors on

    sipsini

     

     

    21:09 on

     

    20 March, 2013

     

     

    Well, you never know…..hahahahahahaha

  25. SFTB 23.06

     

     

    You are bang on.

     

     

    Officially there needs to be a statement from the SFA that they are a new club with only one SFL title.

     

     

    Celtic should be pushing for this.

     

     

    TT

  26. tommytwiststommyturns on

    CRC – hmmm I think it will be Mrs CRC kicking your erchie when she reads that!!

     

     

    Cowiebhoy – at heart, I’m just an auld romantic! :-)

     

     

    St Stivs – I actually thought that you were in same year as GF, WH, etc., so assumed you were younger….with a tough paper round !

     

     

    Time for bed. Night folks.

     

    TTTT

  27. celticrollercoaster loves Wee Oscar, our Celtic Warrior on

    Cowiebhoy

     

    23:15 on

     

    20 March, 2013

     

     

    Problem is that it appears that there is a war within as well.

     

     

    Where Egos dare!!

     

     

    HH

     

     

    CRC

  28. praecepta and winning captains

     

     

    I am fully aware that Andy is a favoured Scottish media “Celtic” man but he does not fit the profile of a full “backside in the air” Uncle Tim character who buys all their pash (Hugh Keevins fits that bill)

     

     

    Andy, as I said, calls them a new club. That earns him some minimum respect in my eyes because that is very far from the accepted narrative for commentating on current football. Speirs will not go that far nor will Pat Nevin. Everything else he may say is suspect but to say that is brave when it would be easier to go with the flow.

     

     

    I do not want responses from CP re every kite that is flown by a journo. I do want no credence given to leaks or people purporting to having inside information. I do have some cause for concern from the initial statements from Mr. Bankier, for example, re Tartan Army superiority over the Celtic support, to think that we have a few Board members who are, at least naive about their customers or, at worst, actually conspiring against our interests and taking us for granted.

     

     

    P.S, I did read most of the magazine and loved the articles by Bryce Curdy and BRT & H. Let me know if you have got an 80s article coming from praecepta or one of the other more regular stalwarts. Give me some notice if you do not get one and I will try to step into the breach instead but I’d be very much a 2nd best option there

  29. 67Heaven ... I am Neil Lennon..!!.. Ibrox belongs to the creditors on

    sipsini

     

     

    21:09 on

     

    20 March, 2013

     

     

    Wrong reply……..correct reply………who the heck is going to buy his shares…?…LOL

     

     

    The bhoy jinky

     

     

    Well, you never know…..hahahahahahaha

     

     

    (It’s been a long day, Folks……..well, that’s my excuse..!!!!!!!!)

  30. tet.

     

     

    I think green will wait and see if they get the jump that they are trying for before making a decision on sandaza.

     

    Like yourself, i believe the cabal is working overtime to ensure they do.

     

    As they have been doing and getting away with for years.