January window – the fundamental problem with Hooper transfer

2027

Two players arrived during this transfer window: Rami Gershon and Tom Rogic, with no first team players leaving the club.  I don’t know what Neil has planned for Rami but his loan deal and stats at Standard Liege suggests he is here as cover.  I expect to see as much of him as we saw of Pawel Brozek last season.

20-year-old Tom Rogic is different.  He joins the club on the same runway as Victor Wanyama, Beram Kayal, Adam Matthews, Mikael Lustig and Emilio Izaguirre.  I’ve refused to watch his YouTube clips but there is every reason to hope he will be as successful a recruit as our other recent acquisitions of a similar profile.

I’ve been banging on about Asset Management for years.  The mantra being – they all have their price and if any club fails to grasp this reality they will underachieve.  Against this backdrop, Gary Hooper will either sign a new contract in the coming weeks or there is a good chance he will leave for nothing when his contract expires in June 2014.

A fundamental problem prevented a deal being done for Gary last month.  His value to Celtic, not necessarily in this season’s Champions League, but in the same tournament’s qualifiers in July and August, is far greater than his value to any suitor. In other words, his value as an asset is not measured by transfer fee alone. This squad should have enough to reach the Champions League group stages next season, worth the best part of £20m to Celtic. Any deals have to be measured against this target.

The kind of transfer decision Celtic made yesterday, a profitable club holding onto a player and at the risk of losing him leaving for free, is so much healthier than the scenario we previously faced, in an arms race with a rival who was prepared to spend money they could not afford in order to beat us. What a mistake that whole ‘Old Firm’ thing was. Glad to see the back of it.

The ‘big clubs’ in England didn’t come looking for Gary.  Instead, a well-run club made several attempts to acquire a good player on a price appropriate for their income.  No harm in that, you have to give Norwich the respect any yokel deserves trying to hook up with a beauty queen (nothing implied about people from Norwich, or Gary as a queen!).

There is no guarantee the same club will be playing top-flight football when he becomes available, or that a club with a greater income, or with a more flamboyant approach to spending, will move for him, so there is every chance that Gary and his new agent will figure out that an extra year on his Celtic contract for a hefty wage rise is a decent option.

There is an interesting side plot to the Hooper non-transfer.  Victor Wanyama is sitting on an offer of a substantial wage increase to extend his contract from 2015 to 2016.  Unless someone comes in with an offer greater than his value to Celtic in Champions League campaigns he’ll be here until 2015.

Chances of both players signing new contracts in the coming months has to be a wee bit higher today. All those meaningless scripts about Celtic being a selling club floating around various places will have to be shelved for another time. We are a selling club, but only at the right price and the right time, just as it should be.
[calameo code=00039017168219582ffc8 lang=en page=84 hidelinks=1 width=100% height=500]

Click Here for Comments >
Share.

About Author

2,027 Comments

  1. The lad McKay-Steven looks a prospect and has a good 1st touch, trouble is its his last touch that needs attention. I’m glad we didnt sign Russell, purely so he could do what he did today.

  2. Sheils should have saw a straight red aswell.

     

     

    I wonder what the score would have been on a level playing field and Utd had bothered to get out of second gear…

  3. A Ceiler Gonof Rust on

    Favorite Uncle, I hope not. Mrs ACGR is there getting my dinner sorted out. Hopefully it wont be pre-cooked:-)

     

     

    I told her to be careful as there will be circa 500 marauding angry huns spoiling for trouble.

     

     

    Maybe they’ll just take it on the chin like they normally do…….. Oh Oh!!!.

  4. What a cup manager Super Ally is

     

     

    2011/2012 Champions League qualifier Malmo——Lost

     

    2011/2012 Europa League qualifier Maribor———–Lost

     

    2011/2012 Scotish League Cup, Falkirk—————-Lost

     

    2011/2012 Scottish Cup Dundee United—————-Lost

     

    2012/2013 Scottish Ramsdens Cup QOS—————Lost

     

    2012/2013 Scottish League Cup ICT——————Lost

     

    2012/2013 Scottish Cup Dundee United—————Lost

     

     

    Dundee United first home win in ten

     

     

    Ally Must stay, Ally must stay

  5. We’RE Back!!!!!! That was very long adverts there. Anyway, That was very funny, Black chuck something at the crowd? Had snide on, sick fm. still Alli not touched.

     

     

    KLV

  6. Anyone answer why ref did not add on the usual injury time. Remember wee Collum did same at Easter Road when we were humping them 4-0 a season or so ago.

  7. A Ceiler Gonof Rust on

    KLV, fat boy mccoist is getting it tight on rm and it’s causing a bitch fest among their right wing posters.

     

     

    Smashing……………………….so it is:-)

  8. 67Heaven ... I am Neil Lennon..!!.. Ibrox belongs to the creditors on

    Might be that the ref was getting worried about a riot…lol

  9. George G having a swipe. funny. JR will be a Hoop when Hooper leaves. Great player. Utd never out 2nd gear all game and could have been worse. 5 yellows red 3 goals and no extra time. strange. 3 mins announced and not played.

     

     

    KLV

  10. twomacaroons,

     

     

    That was my fear, that Utd. would have transferred those players this week, to anybody.

     

     

    However, I don’t think Mc.Namara would have taken the job if they had.

     

     

    Best scenario is to leave them where they are and see if J.Mc.N can develop them further.

     

     

    If so, he will get better money for them and, I imagine,will try and cherry pick some of his old Thistle players.

  11. A Ceiler Gonof Rust

     

     

    well done for going on there mate, you are 1 tough hombre, Its there for everyone to see its him. even his pals must be struggling to defend him after today, 6 players from the SPL last season in the squad and some where in POTY short lists.

     

     

    KLV

  12. I honestly have never saw a ref give ET and then not play it. EVER! He Threw the towel in for his team almost. Hurtin tonight and keep the rm updates coming should be funny

     

     

     

    KLV

  13. Good to see the Blog discussing its favourite subject

     

    FFS some on here could tell you more about a certain other team than they could tell you about Celtic

  14. Ole Steakbakes’s aversion to silverware is getting right funny.

     

     

    An excellent start to the day.

     

     

    Congrats to Jackie and all you bhoys that had bets on.

     

     

    Rangers version 2.00 are still in beta I believe.

     

     

    They don’t quite work yet.

  15. Not been on blog since 4pm yesterday as i was at Gullem Balague and gaizka mendieta talk in walkabout last night , og rafferty had posted he was hearing of

     

    trouble for deadco ( before todays drubbing ha ha ha ) can anybody update me bout og’s post

  16. If Black had been dealt with correctly for his earlier fouls he’d ave been sent off after an hour

  17. Got dragged shopping to East Kilbride, * Aarrghhh*

     

     

    Enjoyed the mismatch, not only are they rotten, they’re also indisciplined.

     

     

    Happy Days no huns on the horizon only football can win.

  18. Offt jinky Bhoy, Bad taste mate, I know your joking but it is pretty common the ER and Causalties will be busy tonight because of that game,

     

     

    ; (

     

     

    KLV

  19. Mickbhoy

     

     

    Only an eejit or a Hun wouldnt find the Hun game today entertaining and worth comment

  20. It was nothing Raven, he said it wasnt his story to break, It could have been stock market related. Who knows.

     

     

    KLV

  21. Scott Brown right after the final whistle

     

     

    @ ScottBrown8

     

    No Celtic v rangers games this season then

  22. Would the cheatin zombie sypathicing referree have blown at ninety minutes if the rangers were chasing an equaliser. Jackie isn’t the sort to raise the question but if I was a its fan I would be raging at that.

  23. ….Pumped by a younger team……And from a younger manager, who’s only just stepped in the door.