Lack of consistency haunts Celtic again

748

Celtic have been completely dominant in Scottish football on many occasions but only once did this result in a domestic treble (the treble was won another two occasions when Celtic were only marginally ahead of the competition but were ruthlessly focussed).

At all other times we have had a morning like this, tossed out of one of the cup competitions by a vastly over-performing team.  Little more than a handful of games against weaker opponents stood between us and a treble in each of the last two years, but as we have noted for many years now, Celtic are not consistent enough to win the treble.  The evidence is substantial.

There are parallel ways we should react to this.  In the middle of a Champions League campaign we should be focused on little else, players should be rested for the challenge ahead, even if there are resultant risks, but there will be disappointment that we didn’t see a recognisable performance from those drafted into the team.  It wasn’t until Matthews, Commons and Stokes arrived last night that we looked anything like the Celtic we know.  On no occasions should we lose at home to a Championship team looking for their first away win since April.

That domestic treble from a dominant position was achieved by Martin O’Neill in season 2000-01, a time when Martin scarcely made a substitution before 85 minutes, never mind rested players.  This drew criticism, of course, as his ‘feeder’ players were denied opportunities to grow.  Despite last night’s reversal I would still rather use these games to develop the wider squad.

I also don’t subscribe to the belief that ‘every game is a cup final’.  Motivational strategies lose effectiveness if you roll them out too often.

Credit to Allan Moore and his “boys with desire and work-rate”.
[calameo code=000390171853d2bfc4f69 lang=en page=10 hidelinks=1 width=100% height=500]

Click Here for Comments >
Share.

About Author

748 Comments

  1. 21nov2006

     

     

    21:06 on 25 September, 2013

     

     

    I couldn’t give a damn about the cardigans record in the CL I was only correcting your post about NFL getting to the last 16 at the first attempt

     

    As some are quick to point out in here

     

     

    “If you know your History”

  2. PFAyr

     

     

    What were your thoughts for the future of Celtic like after the ICT game? Compared to todays thoughts about our future. No comparison imo.

  3. Pfayr.

     

     

    “The gulf in class between CFC and ICT was smaller than the gulf in class between the teams last night”

     

     

     

    I think you’ve been on the cooking sherry mate :)

  4. Tricolured Ribbon

     

     

    Not such an inaccurate description these days!

     

     

    Jimbo67 supporting Oscar Knox

  5. Jimbo67

     

     

    Haw haw, yes I can relate to ‘going to the fitba’ grief.

     

    That was my era for going regularly too.

     

    Live in Germany now- still miss it.

     

    Miss being young tae!

  6. ....PFayr supports WeeOscar on

    Watching the Americas Cup

     

     

    Refreshing to see sportsmen bursting the hump employing maximum effort

     

     

    That type of attitude is in short supply at times with CFC

  7. Tictaewin

     

     

    Aye. That’s true. Still my midlife crisis isn’t buying myself a Porsche Boxter and going out with a blonde 22 year old called Stacey. No it’s going to Milan and Barcelona on a supporters bus.

     

     

    Jimbo67 supporting Oscar Knox

  8. Good Evening Fellow CQN Predictors,

     

     

    I made it into the qualifier, just, commiserations Weißbier X, it was a good contest.

     

     

    On to the qualifier, the following ties will have the same format as the last round, home and away, team in the left hand column home first week.

     

    Away points count double in the event of a draw.

     

    But take comfort in the knowledge you have European Football until Christmas.

     

    the format of the Champions League and Europa League will be sent out soon(ish).

     

    I’m away for a lie done now! If you spot any mistakes feel free to reply, email please

     

     

    Good luck and get your predictions in soon, some players are out because they didn’t get them in.

     

     

    Gohome Yahuns v Green and Whiteley

     

    Koln Hoops v Evergreen

     

    Bayern Bru v ruggyvogue c.s.c.

     

    Giffnock Old Bhoys v Rodfathers Rovers

     

    Kikinthenakas v Meiklehill Rovers

     

    Celtic Under Ninety Team v The NoNames

     

    We’re on the one road Colts v Hail Hail Rain or Shine FC

     

    Del Monte Shamrock v EK Green & White Army

     

    Chocolate Bhoys v The Exiled Tim

     

    Kiwinning Dangers v MARCELONACELTIC F C

     

    McDowells Bhoys v Imrans Maw

     

    Hillend Rockies v Hopeful Hoops

     

    Kayal33 v lubosleftpeg

     

    celtic1888 v Bada Bing

     

    Norfolk Enchants v Donny Gaels

     

    Looney Tunes v Acacia Milan

     

    Nitrams 11 v Heaven

     

    Maybe Next Year………. v Frank’s Frantic Eleven

     

    Roughrigg Brushers v epl overated

     

    Jessica Rabbit v Dim Sam’s Tims

     

    Billys Boots v Celtic rose

     

    Thom’s Sellick v Bannockburn Bhoys

     

    Set Phasers to Malky v LennysBhoys

     

    Minx1888 v FC Pasch(ing)

     

    7-1 4-2 6-2 v Googys Globetrotters

     

    iPaddys Plodders v Setting Free the Bears

     

    Diamonds v Rossini

     

    celtic 67 v Athenry bhoys

     

    Angola CSC v Lennys Lions

     

    Dougies Donkeys v Dan City

     

    micktic v Sipsini

     

    Hurdlers Huddlers v The Dukes of Montrose

  9. 16 roads - Wee Oscar the Celtic warrior. on

    Milan now 3-3.

     

     

    Two goals in the final two minutes of normal time.

  10. ....PFayr supports WeeOscar on

    A Brit wins the Americas Cup off the Yanks

     

     

    Wonder how long it’ll take them to airbrush his contribution

  11. delaneys dunky

     

     

    21:25 on 25 September, 2013

     

    PFAyr

     

     

    What were your thoughts for the future of Celtic like after the ICT game? Compared to todays thoughts about our future. No comparison imo.

     

     

    My thoughts from all those years ago was there was no chance that ICT would ever challenge us for league titles. However after last night my opinion has changed

  12. Bologna lose two late goals to AC Milan in Bologna and it finishes 3:3.

     

     

    I presume the Bologna coach was a naive eejit who made two attacking subs when he should have put on defenders.

     

     

    Let me check

     

     

    One non-scoring midfielder subbed by another non-scoring midfielder on 65 minutes

     

     

    A defender came on for a midfielder in 78 minutes

     

     

    A non-scoring midfielder for a non-scoring midfielder in the 85th minute

     

     

     

    This is surely inexplicable??

     

     

    This manager did just what Captain Hindsight recommended as a no-brainer last week.

     

     

    Surely, this guarantees you will hold the result you have???

     

     

    Or could the stoics have been right all along. Stick or twist? It’s a gamble either way.

  13. 67Heaven ... I am Neil Lennon, supporting WEE OSCAR..!!.. Ibrox belongs to the creditors on

    Generally speaking, we should be playing our best team in every game, with changes for suspension, injuries and loss of form only…..IMO it’s the only way to get consistency, and for the team to gel into a unit….changing formations all the time is not the way forward….the fringe players then know they have to take their chance when they get their chance….

  14. Pfayr ,

     

     

    Go on then. What was caleys form going into the game? League position??

     

     

    Ours was same.

     

     

    Scottish cup game in February with no euro distraction……

  15. 21Nov2006

     

     

    Well it is two different squads for one thing. They have rejigged the nextgen tournament to a mirror of the CL so a tough call there. To qualify in whatever form would be a terrific achievement. As discussed frequently it’s what happens to our young players post development level that is raising questions.

  16. ....PFayr supports WeeOscar on

    Geordie

     

     

    Our form going into the game …very good …won four drawn one

     

     

    Morton second bottom of second tier ….wretched form

     

     

    ICT game …we weren’t joint top of the league and unbeaten and ICT weren’t second bottom of the second tier

  17. 67Heaven ... I am Neil Lennon, supporting WEE OSCAR..!!.. Ibrox belongs to the creditors on

    Can’t believe the SFA don’t ‘recognise’ sevco …. As far as they are concerned, sevco aren’t called sevco…..strange ……here we have a wee new team struggling it’s way through the Divisions to no avail… hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahzhahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha

  18. Tricoloured Ribbon

     

     

    That is great. Complete with Mr Cholmondley Warner talking about the Kelts. Official attendance 48349. A mere 86000 inside capacity. Must have been a helluva lot of wee boys let in for free

     

     

     

    Jimbo67 supporting Oscar Knox

  19. Think there’s been an over reaction to last night. In the cold light of day we are actually doing not too bad with a team that is still getting used to each other. We are joint top of the league and in the CL group stage.

     

     

    The one other observation I’d make is our tendency to write new players off too quickly. I’m not too sure why this happens but we do. Give the new guys some time to settle, if you need an examples remember Stilian? or more recently VW ?

     

    Imagine the trials facing Balde just now, unable to converse in a period of major adjustment at a new club in a new country.

     

     

    Give the guys a chance.

  20. Kojo,

     

    I am not saying anything to denigrate Pukki.I have no doubt the boy is a fine player,but a main striker?.Everything about the way he plays tells me no.Playing alongside a striker,looks his position to me.Hope I am wrong,we need a hero.