More warning signs for Celtic

268

Fair play to Newco, a 3-0 win after a 2-0 defeat is an achievement.  Anyone who thinks this season will be easy has not been paying attention.  Whatever they do in the Champions League playoff round, they will arrive at Celtic Park three weeks on Saturday battle ready.

The circa £5m they earned last night will go towards supporting their structural deficit for the coming season, pending the outcome of their tie against PSV.  There is real opportunity, or jeopardy, in those games.

Celtic have to consider whether they are ready to overcome the challenge.  Despite early season good form and a manager who delivered spectacularly last season, it is far from clear we are.  Newco changed manager mid-term, suffered a midseason wobble, but finished strong, arguably the strongest.

We await to competitively deploy Alexandro Bernabei, Moritz Jenz may, or may not, be used when Carl Stafelt is fit and we are yet to find out what Aaron Mooy can deliver.  In short, we can only offer an aspirational opinion on whether our first choice 11 is stronger than last term, or we simply have more cover.

It is reassuring that we continue to be linked with quality players.  If our business this month is close to as effective as last August’s, you will enjoy 3 September.

Click Here for Comments >
Share.

About Author

268 Comments

  1. How much money have Porto made in transfer sales in last 25 years? Mourinho gave them ridiculous money for a couple of players, when he went from there to Chelsea

  2. An Dún,

     

     

    Not complicated. They expect Huns to win home game but lose the tie overall.

     

     

    I’m delighted Huns are at home first game, It’s a huge advantage having second game at home,

     

    With away goals rule gone, you know exactly what needs to be done with a huge home crowd roaring you on, anything is possible.

     

    I am more confident than ever that Huns will be knocked out.

  3. ‘Looks like’

     

    ‘Sound like’

     

    ‘Should have’

     

    ‘You have to wonder’

     

    ‘A lot will be revealed…’

     

    ‘We are looking’

     

    ‘My thoughts are’

     

    ‘We seem to be’

     

     

    Hmmm, no evidence then.

  4. C40 @ 5.40

     

     

    With DD involved — we will never ask.

     

     

    If we were to build a new Main Stand I would be on to the SG for cheap finance / loan guarantee support / investment subsidies to push the boundary of the design and its facilities.

     

     

    £100mill private sector investment in the East End would be transformational especially if it came with our name on it — if you were really cute you could go to Westminster for some funding and shame Not-Jacinda into supporting the plan.

     

     

    The other angle is the Avenues fund — multiple millions to tart up streets put in bike lanes / plant trees.

     

     

    And guess what none of the money is being spent east of Moir Street.

     

     

    I would prefer the Gallowgate to be done up but London Road would be good for our neighbours in Bridgeton — streets getting done up to support / mark the route our ground.

     

     

    They would be that sick that they wouldn’t want to march on them.

     

     

    Now that would be a result.

  5. SFTB,

     

     

    Thank you for your comments, however I disagree.

     

     

    Getting people away from the box ( Terrestrial tV ) and travelling to a game is a major achievement.

     

     

    Many of the families who attend woman’s football will also purchase merchandise and attend mens football.

     

     

    This is not the 1970’s where we learned the ” art ” of opening a beer can. Times have changed and we must embrace the change or be left behind.

     

     

    Cheers and HH.

  6. SFTB @ 5.46

     

     

    You really do know how to suck the air out of the room.

     

     

    Have you read “A Christmas Carol” too many times?

     

    Sounds as if you have.

  7. Avenues Fund — put in fancy / middle class bike lanes.

     

     

    We already have the cooncil spec bike lanes causing havoc with the traffic.

  8. bournesouprecipe on

    Aye we need to buy more players and invest more money,

     

     

     

     

    1990 – Martin Hayes (Arsenal) – 650,000 –

     

    1991- Tony Cascarino (Aston Villa) – 1.1M –

     

    1991 – Gary Gillespie (Liverpool) – 925,000

     

    1991 – Tony Mowbray (Middlesborough)

     

    1992 – Tom Boyd (Chelsea) – Exchanged for Cascarino

     

    1992 – Andy Payton (Middlesborough)

     

    1992 – Stuart Slater (West Ham) – 1.5M

     

    1992 – Frank McAvennie (Aston Villa) – Free

     

    1992 – Paul Byrne (Bangor City) – 70,000

     

    1993 – Wayne Biggins (Barnsley) – 100,00

     

    1994 – Carl Muggleton (Leicester City) – 100,000

     

    1994 – Lee Martin (Man Utd) – 350,000

     

    1994 – Willie Falconer (Sheffield Utd) – 375,000

     

    1994 – Andy Walker (Bolton Wanderers) – 550,000

     

    1995 – Declan Boyle (Sligo Rovers) – 65,000

     

    1996 – Alan Stubbs (Bolton Wanderers) – 3.5M

     

    1997 – Tommy Johnson (Aston Villa) – 2.3M

     

    1997 – Craig Burley (Chelsea) – 2.4M

     

    1997 – Jonathan Gould (Bradford City) – Free

     

    1998 – Regi Blinker – (Sheffield Wednesday) – Undisclosed

     

    1998 – Tony Warner – (Liverpool) – Loan

     

    1998 – Scott Marshall (Arsenal) – Loan

     

    1999 – Dmitri Kharine (Chelsea) – Free

     

    1999 – Olivier Tebily (Sheffield Utd) – 1.25M

     

    1999 – Bobby Petta (Ipswich Town) – Free –

     

    1999 – Eyal Berkovic (West Ham) – 5.75M

     

    1999 – Ian Wright (West Ham) – Free

     

    1999 – Stephane Bonnes (FC Mulhouse) – Undisclosed

     

    2000 – Michael McGovern (Enniskellen Town)

     

    2000 – Chris Sutton (Chelsea) – 6M

     

    2000 – Alan Thompson (Aston Villa) – 2.75M

     

    2000 – Ramon Vega (Spurs) – loan

     

    2000 – Neil Lennon (Leicester City) – 5.75M

     

    2001 – Steve Guppy (Leicester City) – 350,000

     

    2001 – John Hartson (Coventry City) – 6M

     

    2002 – Magnus Hedman (Coventry City) –

     

    2003 – Darren O’Dea (Home Farm) – Free

     

    2003 – Stan Varga (Sunderland) – Free

     

    2003 – Michael Gray (Sunderland) – Loan

     

    2004 – Danny Milosevic (Leeds Utd) – Free

     

    2004 – Henri Camara (Wolves) – Loan

     

    2004 – Juninho (Middlesborough) – Free

     

    2005 – Stephane Henchoz (Liverpool) – Free

     

    2005 – Craig Bellamy (Newcastle Utd) – Loan

     

    2005 – Mo Camara (Burnley) – Free

     

    2005 – Jeremie Alliadiere (Arsenal) – Loan

     

    2005 – Adam Virgo (Brighton) – 1.5M

     

    2005 – Paul Telfer (Southampton) – 200,000

     

    2005 – Roy Keane – (Man Utd) – Free

     

    2006 – Dion Dublin (Leicester City) – Free

     

    2006 – Jiri Jarosik (Chelsea) – 2M –

     

    2006 – Kenny Miller (Wolves) – Free

     

    2006 – Lee Naylor (Wolves) – 600,000

     

    2008- Georgios Samaras (Man City) – 1.2M

     

    2008 – Andreas Hinkel (Sevilla ) – 2M

     

    2008 – Ben Hutchinson (Middlesborough) – Undisclosed

     

    2008- Glenn Loovens (Cardiff City) – 2.5M

     

    2009 -Shaun Maloney (Aston Villa) – 2.5M

     

    2008 – Niall McGinn (Derry City) – 200,000

     

    2009- Willo Flood (Cardiff City) – 150,000

     

    2009 -Danny Fox (Coventry City) – 1.5M

     

    2009 – Josh Thompson (Stockport) – Free

     

    2010 – Diomansy Kamara (Fulham) – Loan

     

    2010 – Robbie Keane (Spurs) – Loan

     

    2010 – Joe Ledley (Cardiff City) – Free

     

    2010 – Daryl Murphy (Sunderland) – 1.5M

     

    2010 – Gary Hooper (Scunthorpe) – 2.4M

     

    2010 – Fraser Forster (Newcastle) – Loan

     

    2010 – Olivier Kapo (Wigan) – Free

     

    2011 – Kris Commons (Derby County) – 300,000

     

    2011 – Kelvin Wilson (Notts Forest) – Free

     

    2011 – Adam Matthews (Cardiff City) – Free

     

    2011 – Andre Blackman (Wimbledon) – Free

     

    2013 – Steven Mouyokolo (Wolves) – Free

     

    2014 – Leigh Griffiths (Wolves) – 1M

     

    2014 – Joe Inge Berget (Cardiff City) – Loan

     

    2014 – Aleksander Tonev (Aston Villa) – Loan

     

    2014 – Jason Denayer (Man City) – Loan

     

    2014 – John Guidetti (Man City) – Loan

     

    2015 – Michael Duffy (Derry City) – Undisclosed

     

    2015 – Dedryck Boyata (Man City) – 1.5M

     

    2015 – Saidy Janko (Man Utd) – Undisclosed

     

    2015 – Tyler Blackett (Man Utd) – Loan

     

    2015 – Carlton Cole – Free

     

    2015 – Patrick Roberts (Man City)

     

    2016 – Moussa Dembele (Fulham) – 500,000

     

    2016 – Kolo Toure (Liverpool) – Free

     

    2016 – Scott Sinclair (Aston Villa) – 3.5M

     

    2016 – Dorus DeVries (Notts Forest) – Undisclosed

     

    2016 – Christian Gamboa (WBA) – 1M

     

    2017 – Kundai Benyu (Ipswich Town) – Free

     

    2017 – Olivier Ntcham (Man City) – 4.5M

     

    2018 – Charly Musonda (Chelsea) – Loan

     

    2018 – Filip Benkovic (Leicester City) – Loan

     

    2019 – Oliver Burke (WBA) – Loan

     

    2019 – Luca Connell (Bolton) – Free

     

    2019 – Jonathan Afolabi (Southampton) – Free

     

    2019 – Moritz Bauer (Stoke City) – Loan

     

    2019 – Mohamed Elyounoussi (Southampton) – Loan

     

    2019 – Lee O’Connor (Man Utd) – Undisclosed

     

    2020 – Albian Ajeti (West Ham) – 5M

     

    2020 – Shane Duffy (Brighton) – Loan

     

    2021 – John-Joe Kenny (Everton) – Loan

     

    2021 – Liam Shaw (Sheffield Wednesday) – Free

     

    2021 – Osaze Ugoghide (Sheffield Wednesday) – Free

     

    2021 – Bosun Lawal (Watford) – Free

     

    2021 – Joe Hart (Spurs) – 1M

     

    2021 – James McCarthy – Free

     

    2021 – Liam Scales – 500,000

     

    2021 – Cam Carter-Vickers (Spurs) – 6M

     

    2022 –

     

    2022 – Johnny Kenny (Sligo Rovers) – 100,000

     

    2022 – Reo Hatate

     

    2022 – Daizen Maeda 1.5M

     

    2022 – Kyogo Furahashi

     

    2022 – Yosuke Ideguci – Osaka – Undisclosed

     

    2022 – Jota – Benfica 6M

     

    2022 – Bernabei – Lanus – 3.75M –

     

    2022 – Matt O’Riley (MK Dons) – 1.5M

  9. BOURNESOUPRECIPE on 10TH AUGUST 2022 5:59 PM

     

     

    You’ve missed out out two most expensive signings I think.

     

     

    OE and CJ.

     

     

    IHH.

  10. MM

     

     

    “You want evidence — then we have a 20 year history of transfer dealings / forced sales / selling club vibe to look back on. This is not our first PL inspired transfer rodeo.

     

     

     

    A lot will be revealed in Sept but until them we can just read the runes in true CFC style.”

     

    ————————————————

     

     

    I asked for evidence and you have told me that we’ve been a selling club for 20 years (arbitrary number). Every Scottish club has been a de facto selling club since the Bosman Rolling and TV steroid money for the big 5 leagues came in. We were even selling Kenny and Charlie and Yogi and Wispy before then.

     

     

    Your final sentence addresses the question you were asked and you say you do not know which is why you should be a little less assertive and certain about your assertions until you have evidence to support them.

     

    ——————————————————

     

    MM

     

    “For your information — we have not bought AM / BS / MoJ.

     

     

    The fact that you need to big up these players suggest you know that you case is weak.”

     

    ——————————–

     

     

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/61889407. Is he playing for free?

     

     

    https://www.footballscotland.co.uk/spfl/scottish-premiership/aaron-mooy-completes-celtic-transfer-24516474 Is he playing for free? Did he pay off his Chinese club totally out of his own re-imbursed pocket?

     

     

    Only Moritz Jenz is on a loan to buy basis- we signed, bought and paid for the other two.

     

     

     

    P.S. mentioning them is not “begging them up” – suggests your rebuttal might have some weak reasoning behind it

  11. AD @ 5.29

     

     

    The odds look strange.

     

     

    Two separate markets?

     

     

    Game — win / lose / draw — 6/4 is the win.

     

    A draw could be a favoured result?

     

     

    Tie — win / lose — 5/4 is the win for the tie?

     

    No draw allowed?

     

     

    Or — our friends in Govan have more confidence that they will get through the tie than they have about any particular game.

     

     

    Specifically that they will win at home?

     

     

    They know that a special ref will be involved — just a case that they do not know which game?

     

     

    One to watch — in a DR style — follow the money.

     

    DR — he of the known unknown vibe.

  12. MM

     

     

    “You really do know how to suck the air out of the room.

     

    ———————————-

     

     

    You have the same grasp of irony as Alan’s Morisette.

     

     

    I am confident that I can meet with 95% + of our contributors and be either welcomed or tolerated.

     

     

    What do you think your percentage would be?

  13. SFTB @ the 18th century.

     

     

    We do not buy players — that is slavery.

     

    We buy out existing contracts.

     

     

    Paying transfer fees is squad investment which is amortized through the accounts.

     

    Paying wages is current expenditure which is expensed through the accounts.

     

     

    So you are still wrong..

  14. BSR @ the madam

     

     

    I hope that was a copy and paste job.

     

     

    My main point still stands — we are a bit undercooked at the moment.

     

    We need another couple of starters added to the squad.

     

     

    Our spend this transfer window is less than the resources we have available.

  15. MM

     

     

    Disappearing into a semantic dead end.

     

     

    We bought these players to play for us. Buying them is not slavery but neither is it free money. We had to invest money in their wages.

     

     

    You cannot spin your way out of it by saying it’s 2 different areas of expenditure; they are both still expenditure/buying.

  16. !!BADA BING!! on 10TH AUGUST 2022 5:46 PM

     

     

    Since Mourinho left it’s nearly £400m in profit but with part-ownership who knows how much of that Porto would see

     

     

    They’re fortunate to be able to sell players who’ve come through the youth ranks for big money – nearly £130m in the last two seasons and this.

     

     

    Outside of Mcgeady and KT we haven’t sold a home-grown player for more than £2m in our history. Porto have sold 5 home-grown players for more than what we receive for KT.

  17. Greenpinata

     

     

    “Times have changed and we must embrace the change or be left behind.”

     

    ——————————————

     

     

    What has changed and what are we embracing?

     

     

    Should we be paying more to our Ladies Team because we believe it will, at some unspecified time in the future, be worth that financial input? Or should we keep paying them at a level roughly akin to what they bring into the club?

     

     

    Can you foresee no dangers in paying any team, men or women or other, more than they earn for the club?

  18. SFTB,

     

     

    Lots has changed and we need to embrace the change

     

     

    Your an intelligent guy, you know what has changed. Its self explanatory and I don’t need to go into detail what was was previously acceptable and is now not acceptable.

     

     

    At Parkhead I see lots of families around where I sit. We need to continue our efforts to make the match day experience as family friendly as possible. There is a massive largely untapped audience out there.

     

     

    HH.

  19. My friends in Celtic,

     

     

    Amounts shirts sold

     

     

     

    Bayern Munich 3,250,000

     

    Real Madrid 3,050,000

     

    Liverpool 2,450,000

     

    Manchester United 1,950,000

     

    Juventus 1,420,000

     

    Barcelona 1,340,000

     

    Chelsea 1,310,000

     

    Borussia Dortmund 1,222,000

     

    Paris St Germain (PSG) 1,180,000

     

    Manchester City 1,087,000

     

     

    We have some work to do, but it’s possible with aggressive marketing in various countries encapsulating all genders.

     

     

    HH.

  20. 442 park the bus on

    Dizny matter how much we spend – if we don’t park the bus in Europe we will be handed our asses in crunch games!

     

    Even the great Barca team struggled vs the Celtic parked bus.

     

    A Celtic team driven by NL`s warrior psychology, just off the phone to MON!

     

    NL parked the bus vs the best Barca team ever, and we won 2-1 thanks to a long ball, Tony Watt peach of a winner.

     

    NL also parked the bus in the Camp Nou, in the same CL group, with Efe Ambrose and Kelvin Wilson as centre halfs, and a long ball, Sammi, peach of an opener, and Barca scored their winning goal with just 20 seconds left to play, 1-2 we lost, vs the Barca Galactico’s.

  21. Great debate guys need to shoot.

     

     

    Phone is running out and the beer garden is out of chargers.

     

     

    HH to all.

  22. It is almost as if the guy knows nothing about real estate investment funds, private equity, pension funds or gevernment infrastructure masterplans.

     

     

    avenues in the east end.

  23. an avenue from Brigton to celtic park.

     

     

    dearie me.

     

     

    government money to build a PLC infrastructure , aye right.

  24. Tom McLaughlin on

    SFTB

     

     

    MADMITCH

     

    So where is the evidence that this is a TIGHT budget and not an AVERAGE or a SPENDTHRIFT/GROWTH budget?

     

     

    He got it from the Daily Mail who reported it about a month ago.

  25. I dont kow why the pessimism around things,

     

     

    we are best shape for start of the season for many years.

     

     

    in all departments and in all things.

  26. Greenpinata,

     

     

    I may be set in my ways, Ladies fitba, even Celtic teams just don’t get me excited.

     

     

    Deelighted howeeeevaaaah so many Gals are frequenting Celtic Park.

     

     

    The Olde Jungle toilet did they even cater for Ghirls anywhere?

     

     

    Fergus.CSC.HouseofSteel.

  27. Club Revenue

     

    1. Man City €644.9m

     

    2. Real Madrid €640.7m

     

    3. Bayern €611.4m

     

    4. Barcelona €582.1m

     

    5. Man Utd €558m

     

    6. PSG €556.2m

     

    7. Liverpool €550.4m

     

    8. Chelsea €493.1m

     

    9. Juventus €433.5m

     

    10. Tottenham €406.2m

     

    11. Arsenal €366.5m

     

    12. Dortmund €337.6m

     

    13. Atletico €332.8m

     

    14. Inter €330.9m

     

    15. Leicester €255.5m

     

    16. West Ham €221.5m

     

    17. Wolves €219.2m

     

    18. Everton €218.1m

     

    19. Zenit €212m

     

    20. Aston Villa €207.3m

  28. bournesouprecipe on

    SCULLYBHOY

     

     

    They can’t that’s why you get nothing but white noise from the cynics

  29. monetize ubiquitous partnerships

     

    e-enable frictionless partnerships

     

    incentivize back-end schemas

     

    incubate collaborative solutions

     

     

    He’ll be along shortly 🙉