Motherwell may hold casting vote

454

St Johnstone (through manager Steve Lomas) and Kilmarnock, through Rangers supporter (literal sense) Michael Johnston, have both declared their vote to allow a Newco to take Rangers place in the SPL next season.  Celtic will vote against and Dundee United appear open to persuasion.  The next most important team in the country is Motherwell.

Motherwell, alongside Celtic, Dundee United and St Johnstone have a place on the SPL board.  They are migrating towards ownership and control by a large number of small supporter-shareholders, they’ve benefited from Rangers demise and in July will feature in the Champions League qualification draw, broadcast live from Monaco.

On the downside, despite their on-field success this season, the club will have to trim football budget for the coming season as Champions League qualifying money does not make up for earning less from cup runs this season and inflation pushing costs up.

Motherwell fans seemed to enjoy their visit to Ibrox on Saturday but does anyone expect them to vote against Rangers?

You can buy a hard copy of the new issue of CQN Magazine via Magcloud here.

The graphic below is just for a flick through, to read the magazine go here to it’s dedicated site.

Click Here for Comments >
Share.

About Author

454 Comments
  1. Pages:
  2. 1
  3. ...
  4. 5
  5. 6
  6. 7
  7. 8
  8. 9
  9. 10
  10. 11
  11. 12

  1. Jeanie was a spoilt young brat she thought she knew it all…

     

    She smoked mentholated cigarettes and she had sex in the hall.

  2. Awe_Naw_No_Annoni_Oan_Anaw_Noo on

    Starry

     

     

    and shit stirring hunposters ?

     

     

    Hail Hail

  3. Celtic_First on

    ABZMike on 7 May, 2012 at 16:28 said:

     

    If it is so impossible to make a decision, then do nothing, the status quo continues – RFCiA die, and any NewCo formed joins the queue to join Scottish football at the bottom of the pyramid. Simple really…

     

     

    Excellent.

  4. gordybhoy64 on 7 May, 2012 at 16:28 said

     

     

    I agree, I think Windy Miller is taking a punt. As Alex Thommo pointed out, D&P statement did not even refer to CW who owns 85% of the shares.

  5. Fritz A. Grandold ‏ @fritzagrandold

     

    Initial reaction was “What? Why are they delaying?” Now, I can see what they’re thinking. Clubs unsure whether Bill Miller is even real deal

  6. Allgreen tthinks SPL are at it on

    Looks like the spl agreeing to the delay means they hope HMRC do their job for them.

     

    Suppose it’s true that if you’re going to lie and cheat, lie and cheat big.

  7. gordybhoy64 on

    OFF TOPIC,

     

    i have asked a couple of times but can anyone recommend a decent

     

    mid price hotel in edinburgh,about £100 a night,plenty on line

     

    but was hoping someone would know one from experience

  8. Paul – MTH ‏ @MTHForum

     

    Dunfermline FC appear to have bigger balls than Celtic FC, how embarrassing.

  9. TheBarcaMole on

    Quelle Surprise!

     

    No change there then………….

     

    Same old, same old………

     

    Been beating this drum for some time now and not with the intention or hope of being a proven doom-sayer but hey c’mon this is going to run and run and run……….

     

    At risk of repeating myself…..

     

    It’s a long game for them; and with the connivance of the brotherhood, their political allies and the the carpetbaggers within, they will hope to draw the whole thing out to achieve the desired result; survival of RIA (no, not a typo) in as near as possible a guise to the original model.

     

    May well mean continued administration (for however long, for them) and the (comparatively insignificant) concomitant penalties that go with it but hey, sorry to say, ‘the people’ will be/are still here giving it out with impunity………….

     

     

    Hope that I am wrong……..Really!!!

     

     

    Regards & Hail Hail

     

    TBM

  10. Awe_Naw_No_Annoni_Oan_Anaw_Noo on

    gordybhoy64

     

     

    but the more time he is given the more chance it is likely to succeed

     

     

    and that´s why he was given it.

     

     

    Hail Hail

  11. Antrimkev:

     

     

    …or fire Daimond pointed bullets filled with holy water into the beasts bloated body…that is sure to kill them off.

  12. jude2005 is Neil Lennon \o/ on

    I see Miller has married a young thing. Hope she’s got a pre nuptial all signed and sealed??

  13. Brogan Rogan Trevino ‏ @BroganRoganTrev

     

    Well, well, well— what happens if the big tax case rules in the next two weeks I wonder???? Rangers damned/ Rangers Saved???

  14. Fritz A. Grandold ‏ @fritzagrandold

     

    Yorkston said clubs are looking for more clarity on the EBT/SPL inquiry issue. I don’t think there’ll be any hiding places for Rangers.

  15. How I see this unfolding:

     

     

    1. FTT rules against RFC(IA)

     

    2. SPL can then rule on dual-contracts ( without fear of serious appeal due to FTT ruling)

     

    3. Sanctions mean that RFC(IA) are demoted to SFL

     

    4. Newco have to apply to SFL for admission to Div3.

     

    5. SPL do not need to rule on Newco.

  16. The Temporary Stand ‏ @TemporaryStand

     

    Only real weapon in the struggle against Newco huns is boycott. Nothing should be ruled out and that includes season tickets. #NOTONEWCO

  17. Awe_Naw_No_Annoni_Oan_Anaw_Noo on 7 May, 2012 at 16:31 said:

     

     

    Awe Naw huv ah been duped??

     

     

    I just barged in and opened ma big mooth, no like me but having said that if we as a support are anti-racism it follows that we are anti-sexism too..naw??

  18. Sorry: too long & rambling but need to let loose:

     

     

    INTEGRITY v FINANCIALS

     

    If I follow the Kilmarnock Chairmans statement correctly he argues the financial losses his club would incurr should a Newco not be allowed into the SPL would be a disaster for his and most other clubs.

     

    Am I missing something here?

     

     

    NEWCO & FINANCIAL SECURITY

     

     

    He is suggesting that the existing SPL model has to be maintained to ensure financial security. Pardon me? Where is the evidence of the SPL model being of financial benefit? His is one of the clubs, to a greater or lesser extent, hamstrung by debts built up to dangerous levels. The SPL model AS IT IS, is not a financial success! Continuing with the SPL model is MORE dangerous.

     

     

    HYPOCRICY

     

     

    There are SPL clubs past & present (Falkirk, St Johnstone, Partick, Hibs etc) who have fought & trimmed to maintain a stable financial position whilst others like Kilmarnock(!) were delinquent. What hypocrisy! ” We’ll let a Newco in so as to protect my club & the game and continue to hide our own part in this gross mismanagement.”

     

     

    SKY CONTRACT

     

     

    This is surely the most bizarre TV contract in the Western World (or elsewhere for that matter).

     

    A GUARANTEE of 4 Glasgow derbies a season, guaranteeing no CFC or RFC finish outwith top 6! And for that get paid peanuts!!

     

    If you hand that type of contract over to TV you should be squeezing every ‘thin dime’ out of them. The person negotiating this deal should have got his jotters.

     

     

    RFCIA CHEATING

     

     

    How can SPL clubs pretend to be blind to this? Surely they must see that the cheating in years past has deprived them of much more money than any they will get back by allowing a Newco? I need to shout this at them: THEY HAVE STOLEN YOUR INCOME.

     

     

    The years of RFC cheating spend contributed to the general level of SPL indebtedness as some others tried to keep up.

     

    The years of RFC cheating spend contributed to a less competitive SPL. A more even league would have been MORE attractive to punters & TV with resultingly more revenue.

     

    The years of RFC cheating spend contributed to other clubs being deprived of glory through entry to cup finals or being winners of trophies. How many more STs might clubs have sold had they been regularly in final stages of tournaments?

     

     

    Irrespective of SFA/SPL/SFL rules regarding a Newco, it is clear that the current concept of the SPL, media contracts, financial sense, footballing fairness is bust.

     

     

    NOT SAVING RFCIA BUT SAVING FOOTBALL

     

     

    The big issue is NOT saving RFCIA but rather finding a format for the betterment of football in Scotland, not for the benefit a particular club or clubs (not for Celtic or anyone else). Should RFCIA or a successor club earn entry to the top flight thats fine by me. That is EARNING entry to a VIABLE top flight.

  19. Fritz A. Grandold ‏ @fritzagrandold

     

    Assumptions so far. FOR: Kilmarnock, St.Johnstone. AGAINST: Celtic, Dunfermline, Aberdeen. UNKNOWN: The rest.

  20. Scottish Premier League members

     

    want to move the power to deal with

     

    newco applications away from the

     

    board and into the hands of the

     

    clubs.

     

    In a meeting at Hampden, which

     

    administration-hit Rangers did not send

     

    a representative to, the 11 SPL teams

     

    unanimously agreed that they should

     

    change the rules on how a newco team

     

    could be admitted.

     

    Currently it is up to the six man SPL

     

    board, consisting of Neil Doncaster,

     

    chief executive, chairman Ralph

     

    Topping, Eric Riley of Celtic,

     

    Motherwell’s Derek Weir, Dundee

     

    United’s Stephen Thompson and Steven

     

    Brown of St Johnstone, to decide on

     

    whether a newco club can come straight

     

    into the SPL.

     

    Now they want that decision to be

     

    made by representatives of all the

     

    clubs.

     

    The meeting was due to vote on

     

    proposals to set out penalties for SPL

     

    clubs involved in administration and

     

    “insolvency transfer events” – otherwise

     

    known as switching to a ‘newco’.

     

    However, Rangers administrators Duff

     

    and Phelps were not present and asked

     

    for an adjournment until May 30, which

     

    was accepted.

     

    In a statement, an SPL spokesman said:

     

    “The 11 member clubs present in

     

    person at today’s general meeting

     

    unanimously called for the power to

     

    deal with any newco application to be

     

    moved from the board to the clubs.

     

    This requires 21 clear days’ notice. The

     

    clubs will therefore meet again on 30

     

    May to consider a resolution designed

     

    to achieve this.

     

    “In the event that an application for

     

    transfer of share to a newco is received

     

    before May 30, then it can be dealt with

     

    by the SPL board. The SPL board have

     

    indicated that they would, in those

     

    circumstances, call together the clubs

     

    before any such decision was made.

     

    “For the avoidance of doubt, no

     

    decision on any transfer of a share to a

     

    newco has yet been made, nor has any

     

    such application been received.”

     

    The May 30 meeting will now decide on

     

    this matter, the sanctions to take

     

    against clubs in financial problems, and

     

    voting rights.

     

    The vote on how to penalise teams who

     

    go into administration or who form a

     

    newco was previously adjourned for

     

    seven days. American businessman Bill

     

    Miller subsequently assumed preferred

     

    bidder status from Rangers’

     

    administrators Duff and Phelps but firm

     

    powers to deal with a newco

     

    application are still not finalised.

     

    Speaking after the meeting, SPL chief

     

    executive Neil Doncaster denied the

     

    issue had turned into a shambles.

     

    He said: “I don’t think so, I think that is

     

    very unfair. We know that passions are

     

    running high, we know this is a very

     

    sensitive time for Scottish football and

     

    we know that a lot of things are at

     

    stake.

     

    “So it is very important that people take

     

    time to make the right decisions and

     

    are balanced in their approach.

     

    “We had a request just before the

     

    meeting started from the

     

    administrators of Rangers to adjourn

     

    the meeting.

     

    “The administrators I think felt it was

     

    appropriate that any new owner of

     

    Rangers should be involved in

     

    discussions around the sorts of issues

     

    that were considered today and the

     

    clubs agreed with that.”

     

    Dunfermline chairman John Yorkston

     

    said that the representatives did not

     

    have sufficient information to go to a

     

    vote.

     

    Yorkston said: “It took a long time to

     

    not decide anything. We all want to

     

    make quick decisions and come out with

     

    what the story is but we don’t have

     

    enough information.”

  21. iCeltic ‏ @iCeltic

     

    How can an administrator have this much pull to allow for the vote be be adjourned. #corrupttothecore

  22. Awe_Naw_No_Annoni_Oan_Anaw_Noo on

    Starry

     

     

    can you smell the chips and the Broon sauce.

     

     

    To be honest I am kinda surprised you completed the circle of life so quickly after the last wan ;-)

     

     

    But that is genuinely what I love about you.

     

     

    You take people as they come.

     

     

     

    Listen do you fancy buying a football club in South Glasgow ? :-)

     

     

     

    Hail HAil

  23. Fritz A. Grandold ‏ @fritzagrandold

     

    As far as I know the only adjournment RFC wanted was the one on 11-1 voting rights, that’s the only thing they got today.

  24. Saint Stivs on

    gordybhoy64 on 7 May, 2012 at 16:32 said:

     

    OFF TOPIC,

     

    i have asked a couple of times but can anyone recommend a decent

     

    mid price hotel in edinburgh,about £100 a night,plenty on line

     

    but was hoping someone would know one from experience

     

     

    ——————————————–

     

     

    Been going to Embra a few times a year for yonks.

     

     

    Mid prices goodies are the APEX chain of hotels, particularly the one at Grassmarket, looking nothing from outside, but has good rooms, great views, and the restraunt is excellent.

     

    Also the one at the end of pronces st is good, more modern.

     

     

    If you can push the boat out for a few pennies more, the best place to stay is called

     

     

    CHESTER RESIDENCE.

     

     

    georgian apartments, top quality, special place.

     

    and free bar of an evening.

     

     

    in the west end , 5 mins from princes st.

     

     

    i always check late rooms for them, if the price is right , its a brilliant stay.

  25. Briandamage ‏ @Briandamge64

     

    @fritzagrandold They talked for 5-6 hours, yet no hun present to hear what was said? Very peculiar

  26. charles kickham on

    hen1rik on 7 May, 2012 at 16:40

     

     

    lots of huns in disguise there

  27. hen1rik on 7 May, 2012 at 16:38 said:

     

     

    iCeltic ‏ @iCeltic

     

    How can an administrator have this much pull to allow for the vote be be adjourned. #corrupttothecore

     

    ………………………………

     

    Not just any old administrator.

     

     

    The Rangers administrator.

  28. Henriklubo ‏ @Henriklubo

     

    SFA must announce findings of Player registration report NOW; HMRC need 2 announce outcome of EBT’s easy decision for all RFC(IA) to SFL3

  29. SPL Press Release ~ General

     

    Meeting outcome

     

    Attendance

     

    The Administrators of Rangers FC did not

     

    attend today’s General Meeting in person

     

    and instead submitted a proxy.

     

    Financial Fair Play

     

    Immediately prior to today’s General

     

    Meeting, a written request was received

     

    from the Administrators of Rangers FC to

     

    adjourn the meeting dealing with financial

     

    fair play.

     

    The other 11 clubs agreed with this request

     

    and the general meeting was adjourned to

     

    10am on Wednesday 30 May 2012.

     

    Newco

     

    The 11 member clubs present in person at

     

    today’s General Meeting unanimously called

     

    for the power to deal with any newco

     

    application to be moved from the Board to

     

    the clubs. This requires 21 clear days’

     

    notice. The clubs will therefore meet again

     

    on 30 May to consider a resolution designed

     

    to achieve this.

     

    In the event that an application for transfer

     

    of share to a newco is received before 30

     

    May, then it can be dealt with by the SPL

     

    Board. The SPL Board have indicated that

     

    they would, in those circumstances, call

     

    together the clubs before any such decision

     

    was made.

     

    For the avoidance of doubt, no decision on

     

    any transfer of a share to a newco has yet

     

    been made; nor has any such application

     

    been received.

     

    Voting Change

     

    At the request of the Administrators of

     

    Rangers FC, the separate adjourned General

     

    Meeting to deal with possible changes to

     

    rules of voting was also adjourned to 30

     

    May.

  30. Awe_Naw_No_Annoni_Oan_Anaw_Noo on

    Ton Che Dan

     

     

    Good news bud. Nice to hear from you all again.

     

     

    hail Hail

  31. sparkleghirl on

    hen1rik on 7 May, 2012 at 16:29 said:

     

    Iain Maciver Todd ‏ @iainmacivertodd

     

    dunfirmline oppose #rfc SPL newco so #rangers ask for adjournment on #SPL meeting on newco until may 30th when dunfirmline are relegated!

     

     

    That fits with my paranoid panic BUT apparently the vote for a delay, which would work against Dunfermline, was unanimous.

     

     

    I prefer Cirenbhoy’s interpretation but am not holding my breath.

  32. Sir Paul

     

     

    Ah done tole ye.. Two weeks ago,kiddo…

     

     

    The S.P.L/S.F.A.

     

     

    Hiv bin lookin’ up that Dictionary again.. fur help..AGAIN

     

     

    and they …STILL… canny find a Bettah woid… Than

     

     

    PROCRASTINATION.!!!!!!!!

     

     

    Great Woid!

     

     

    Fur it Solves. well.. Nothin’

     

     

    … but,it sure is the Best Excuse in Town!

     

     

    How long kin they use it?.. Ye may ask.

     

     

    Heck..

     

     

    Ah wull Need Some time.. Tae Think aboot

     

    THAT yin!

     

     

    Kojo

     

     

    Still, Laughin’

  33. Andy Coyle ‏ @STV_Andy

     

    Doncaster says important to take time before a considered decision. Yorkston comes out of same meeting saying everyone wants quick decision.

  1. Pages:
  2. 1
  3. ...
  4. 5
  5. 6
  6. 7
  7. 8
  8. 9
  9. 10
  10. 11
  11. 12